Given NIL deals, most guys are getting paid in college. The ACC cant compete with the SEC on NIL deals, not sure how HBCU would be able to match would the SEC schools offer on a large scale anyway.
take away the NIL deals and theres still no competition..
The best programs in the best HBC's are good.. but when compared to the SEC schools they simply dont compete..
For example, for pre medical school placement, Xavier is often best rated school among HBC's..
It doesnt make the top 50 list for placement into medical schools though... but Vanderbilt, an SEC school does (19th).. so does UT Austin (40th) and Texas A&M (49th)...
Howard is considered to have the best Communications school among HBC's... but doesnt make the top 50 list in the US... The University of Texas does though (top 10).. So does the University of Georgia (top 20).. So does Univ of Florida (top 30).. Kentucky and Alabama are in the top 40..
Tuskegee is considered the best aerospace engineering program within the HBC's.. but also doesnt make the top 50 list nationally..
Texas A&M is #12 though.. UT Austin is 16... Univ of FL is 20.. Univ of TN is 30... Mississippi State is 33... Kentucky is 48.. Arkansas is 49...
NC A&T is the #1 producing school of black engineers in the US.. and is considered to have one of the best engineering programs among the HBC's.. They dont rate in the top 50 engineering schools in the US though.... 7 SEC schools are in the top 50...
The list goes on and on and on....
Thats not to say you cant get a good education from an HBC.. I have found that quality education is as much about the student as it is about the instructor and/or the institution..
That said, it is abundantly clear that HBC's on their best days dont come close to competing with SEC schools academically as institutions..
Sports.. its not even worth getting into detailed comparison.. they arent large enough and lack the money to compete and do well against NCAA Div 1 schools in major sports.. and in minor sports like track and field they dont have the best record either..
The last time an HBC won a NCAA Div 1 national championship was in 2012 when Hampton University won the Womens Outdoor Track and Field National Championship (14 years ago).. Prior to that it was 1962 when Texas Southern won the NAIA national champtionship for basketball (not NCAA)..
In Div 2 they dont fare much better.. Virginia Union has a pretty decent basketball legacy and has won the Div 2 national championship as recently as 2005 (21 years ago).. Norfolk State won the mens national track and field championship in 84, 85, and 86..
So... this brilliant idea that the Congressional Black Caucus has come up with where gifted atheletes that have opportunities to play in the SEC should pass on those opportunites and instead make the conciouis choice to attend universities that offer lessor academic programs and play on teams that generally speaking dont win championships, dont get nationally televised often, etc..etc.. and certainly dont play at the level that the SEC plays at in any sport.. is frankly stupid...
I dont care if you are white, black, yellow, green, or orange... if the University of Alabama offers you a full ride to play football, basketball, or hell, soccer for that matter... and you turn it down to instead take a full ride to Alabama A&M.. for no other reason than your congressman told you it was a good idea... dont be surprised when you find the job market more difficult upon graduation.. and dont be surprised that the pros didnt come to look at you after your impressive game against Alcorn State..