Ivan Carter And Elephant Charges

Hank2211

Gold supporter
AH legend
Joined
Jan 12, 2010
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
6,729
Media
141
Articles
3
Hunting reports
Africa
10
Member of
SCI, DU, Pheasants Forever
Hunted
Canada, United States, Zimbabwe, South Africa (Eastern Cape; Northern Cape; North West Province, Natal, Mpumalanga, Limpopo), Namibia, Cameroon, Benin, Ethiopia, Argentina
A couple of days ago I watched an episode of Tracks Across Africa with Ivan Carter. The hunt was for female elephants in Zimbabwe (I live in Canada, and we ususally get these shows much later than when they originally aired in the US, so it may have been an older episode). In any event, as the hunt developed, Carter identified a female elephant to be taken, but rather than trying for a shot before she became aware of the hunters, he told the hunter they would come up behind her, follow her, and that at some point she would become aware of them, turn around, and charge. And then the hunter was to shoot her. And that's exactly how it played out. Very dramatic, and I'm sure an adreneline rush for the hunter.

I've seen (on video) Carter do this many times with elephant. Often these are mock charges, and I have no doubt he knows elephants well - I have his video with Boddington - but that's not the point. At times he does this even when he has no intention of shooting the elephant. When he is actually hunting, he seems to intentionally induce a charge, and then has the hunter take the shot - with him backing up of course.

My first question is, what are the ethics of inducing charges, mock or otherwise, for a camera? I've always thought my best shots were when the animal had no idea I was there - down and out without knowing what hit it. Does that make me old fashioned? In fact, I thought this was actually illegal in some African countries?

If you compare how Carter hunts elephant to how someone like Buzz Charlton hunts elephant (and I'm only going by their videos here), there's a big difference.

My fsecond question is this: how is this different from what Mark Sullivan does (or did) in his videos?

Just asking.
 

Odinsraven

AH fanatic
Joined
May 25, 2013
Messages
667
Reaction score
671
Location
Iceland
Media
11
Hunting reports
Africa
5
Member of
NRA Life Membe,Icelandic Hunting Club SKOTVIS , BASC (UK) Countryside Alliance (UK)r
Hunted
UK ,Ireland, Bulgaria,Iceland,Czech Republic
Have never hunted anything bigger than a red deer however in my own "hunting ethics" I find it rather disgusting and indeed "TV" the best hunting and indeed culling I have ever done is where the animal was never even aware I was there - I have seen some of these USA hunting videos and in my mind and indeed as a personal opinion - I do not like them !
 

VonJager

AH enthusiast
Joined
Dec 24, 2009
Messages
258
Reaction score
226
Media
3
Hunting reports
Africa
2
Member of
SCI Life, DSC, NRA Life, WSF Life
Hunted
Namibia, South Africa.
If it is solely for the camera, I am not defending the behavior. However, there is no ethical shot on an elephant moving away from you.

I have seen in a video of him, taking elephant with clients, where the elephant was not aware of their presence. It seems he prefers frontal brain shots, from about 10 yards or closer sometimes, and it seems difficult to do that all the time with the elephants never aware.

He does say even with the elephant aware of their presence, a correctly placed brain shot ends it before the elephant hears the shot.

I have not seen Buzz's videos so I can not compare them.
 

Code4

AH fanatic
Joined
Feb 2, 2009
Messages
711
Reaction score
401
Media
44
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Australia/NZ
5
Member of
SSAA
Hunted
Australia, Zimbabwe, RSA (2), NZ (2), UK.
I've always thought my best shots were when the animal had no idea I was there - down and out without knowing what hit it. Does that make me old fashioned?
Just asking.

When I learnt to stalk with my father, this was considered the successful end to a properly conducted HUNT. Old fashioned ? Who knows ? Maybe just not in vogue with the popular press.

Anything on TV or Video is subject to editing and exaggeration. Some people take it as gospel, however at the end of the day its just entertainment.
 

Red Leg

Lifetime bronze benefactor
AH ambassador
Joined
May 19, 2009
Messages
6,583
Reaction score
18,977
Location
Texas Hill Country
Media
285
Articles
5
Hunting reports
Africa
2
USA/Canada
4
Mex/S.Amer
1
Europe
3
Member of
SCI DSC life memberships / NRA Patron Life
Hunted
Mexico, Namibia, RSA, Germany, Austria, Argentina, Canada, Mozambique, Spain, US (15 states)
I have never seen him induce a charge on any of his videos - I think I have them all. He does believe in the brain shot. One of his techniques is to walk up behind an elephant and have his hunter take a frontal brain when the elephant turns around. He gets closer than most of his peers, which would concern me a tad if I were one of his clients (several respected friends, who are PHs, think he is nuts). But I have never felt he was creating a charge for the camera.
 

SafariA

AH fanatic
Joined
Jun 26, 2010
Messages
523
Reaction score
304
Media
52
Articles
2
A couple of days ago I watched an episode of Tracks Across Africa with Ivan Carter. The hunt was for female elephants in Zimbabwe (I live in Canada, and we ususally get these shows much later than when they originally aired in the US, so it may have been an older episode). In any event, as the hunt developed, Carter identified a female elephant to be taken, but rather than trying for a shot before she became aware of the hunters, he told the hunter they would come up behind her, follow her, and that at some point she would become aware of them, turn around, and charge. And then the hunter was to shoot her. And that's exactly how it played out. Very dramatic, and I'm sure an adreneline rush for the hunter.

I've seen (on video) Carter do this many times with elephant. Often these are mock charges, and I have no doubt he knows elephants well - I have his video with Boddington - but that's not the point. At times he does this even when he has no intention of shooting the elephant. When he is actually hunting, he seems to intentionally induce a charge, and then has the hunter take the shot - with him backing up of course.

My first question is, what are the ethics of inducing charges, mock or otherwise, for a camera? I've always thought my best shots were when the animal had no idea I was there - down and out without knowing what hit it. Does that make me old fashioned? In fact, I thought this was actually illegal in some African countries?

If you compare how Carter hunts elephant to how someone like Buzz Charlton hunts elephant (and I'm only going by their videos here), there's a big difference.

My fsecond question is this: how is this different from what Mark Sullivan does (or did) in his videos?

Just asking.
I am sorry to say I have the same feelings about this...
 

Spudattack

AH member
Joined
Oct 18, 2012
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Member of
New Zealand Deerstalkers Association, New Zealand Hunting and Shooting
Hunted
South Africa, New Zealand
The other school of thought on this is that it is more ethical in the fact that you allow your quarry to know that you are there and hunting it and it actually knows it is in the game. It then has the chance to play a card whether it is fight or flight.

I am not decided either way but thought i would play devils advocate!
 

EDD

AH veteran
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
108
Reaction score
35
Location
Brakpan
Media
54
Member of
SAGA
I have never seen him induce a charge on any of his videos - I think I have them all. He does believe in the brain shot. One of his techniques is to walk up behind an elephant and have his hunter take a frontal brain when the elephant turns around. He gets closer than most of his peers, which would concern me a tad if I were one of his clients (several respected friends, who are PHs, think he is nuts). But I have never felt he was creating a charge for the camera.

Agree with Red Leg Completely on this one!!!!
Also want to state that There is a BIG DIFFRENCE between Mr Carter & mark sulivan.... Just saying.....
 

RickB

AH fanatic
Joined
Mar 9, 2011
Messages
877
Reaction score
41
Media
11
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
NRA lifetime, SCI Member, Longhunters LLC
Hunted
South Africa, Germany, USA (OH, NY, VA, PA, WY)
Let me start by saying this. The majority of todays hunting shows are garbage. It is no different then watching a "reality" show. There is nothing real about it. You have a producer and you have people doing scripted things. The camera in front of the hunter getting ready to shoot, the camera next to the animal on the ground, and we get a REALLY fake supprise when he finds his animal in the woods. It is all garbage to me. I only truly like over the shoulder hunts. It makes the video more enjoyable. Now this leads me to Mr Cartrer. If this is his perticular way to hunt ele, who am I to judge? I do not care it he wants to go slap the ele on the ass before he shoots it. If that is what he chooses to do, so be it. To me as long as the shot is clean, I am ok with it. I have seen some video where the ele knows they are there and ones where they do not. Does this mean you can not grunt at a deer to stop it just so you can shoot? It knows you are there, it is aware of your presance. What is the difference between that and stalking up to an animal and shooting it once the best opratunity has presented itself. I have been following Mr Carter for years now. He is the last person I would suspect of doing something un-ethical. Just my 2 pennys.
 

svinejakt

AH veteran
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
180
Reaction score
48
Media
7
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
OJJF
Hunted
Norway, South Africa
To compare Ivan Carter and Mark Sullivan is crazy. In what I have seen of IC, I have never seen him doing anything unethical and I would say that he is one of the most imprtant spokesperson for hunting in general in the world. After what I have read in reports Buzz Charlton also likes the frontal brain shot as do IC. I think that`s because you get close range and therefore have a good chance of getting the elephant brained in one shot. If I could choose 2 people to go after elephant. Buzz and Ivan would be in there on league. I would not think about for a second going with any of them. If I wanted to se Mark Sullivan shoot a buffalo in the ass for me then kill it for my trophy money I would choose him. The latter will never happen;)

I do think there are some bad habits by some people in the industry.
Ivan and Buzz is in my honest opinion the best in the business:)
 

postoak

Silver supporter
Bronze supporter
AH fanatic
Joined
Dec 2, 2012
Messages
826
Reaction score
552
Location
Texas
Media
30
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
2
Member of
Patron Life member NRA
Hunted
U.S.A., R.S.A, Namibia
If the client is okay with it (and I suspect that they LIKE the idea of shooting a charging elephant) then I can't see anything wrong at all about it. Since when is it some hunting code that the animal isn't supposed to know the hunter is there?
 

timbear

AH enthusiast
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
424
Reaction score
35
Member of
SSAA, NZDA
Hunted
Germany, NZ, Australia
I believe there is a moral difference between making an animal intentionally suffer and making an animal aware of your presence before you shoot, particularly with animals that are inclined to attack rather than run. It the shot is well placed and results in an instant kill I can not fault the shooter. Having never hunted elephant, I am not sure of kill zones, but from what I've read, frontal brain shots are one of the few methods to bring one down without suffering.
 

Upton O. Good

AH enthusiast
Joined
Jan 27, 2010
Messages
349
Reaction score
249
Website
www.beingkarl.wordpress.com
Media
39
Hunting reports
Africa
2
Member of
NRA Life member, Nature Conservancy, Dallas Safari Club
Hunted
Zimbabwe, South Africa, Canada, Mexico, United States, Louisiana
I'm pretty critical in how most hunting shows are presented, very critical to be honest. Mr. Carter's two shows are the only ones worth watching for many reasons, not the least of which includes his ethics and love of wildlife.

Shooting a frontal brain shot on an elephant is humane, quick, and challenging, I wish I had the resources and guts to do it. But, then again, I guess, if I understand your point of view, it is more sporting to stand off at 100 yards, shoot the elephant with a heart/lung shot so the animal can run a half of a mile while choking on its blood as its blood pressure drops to zero.

And I don't know that I've ever seen an elephant charge induced by Mr. Carter for the sake of exciting video footage. Please reference the episode(s) you are referring to and I'll see if I can find them and see what you are concerns are.
 

enysse

AH ambassador
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
11,762
Reaction score
4,348
Media
136
Hunting reports
Africa
8
USA/Canada
1
Member of
Northeast Wisconsin SCI chapter, Lifetime member of NRA,RMEF
Hunted
Namibia, South Africa (East Cape, Guateng and Limpopo)
I like Ivan and think he's an excellent PH. I have no problems with the way he hunts. You get a up an close hunt, worthy of what you pay for his services. Brain shot, super deadly.
 

35bore

AH legend
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
2,402
Reaction score
877
Media
74
Member of
NRA,Missouri hunters ed, SCI, Owensville Gun Club, Quail Forever
Hunted
USA, South Africa, France
I like Ivan and think he's an excellent PH. I have no problems with the way he hunts. You get a up an close hunt, worthy of what you pay for his services. Brain shot, super deadly.

ditto....
 

gi jane

AH fanatic
Joined
Jun 28, 2013
Messages
516
Reaction score
112
Media
42
I don't know Mr. Carter personally, nor have I hunted with him. However, from what I know and from the research I have done, I must say I am very impressed with him and his technique. Personally, I believe he is legit and I respect his passion and expertise.
Deep-down I think Ivan Carter is a good man and an amazing PH!!
 

bassasdaindia

AH elite
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
1,324
Reaction score
862
Media
20
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
3
I don't know Mr. Carter personally, nor have I hunted with him. However, from what I know and from the research I have done, I must say I am very impressed with him and his technique. Personally, I believe he is legit and I respect his passion and expertise.
Deep-down I think Ivan Carter is a good man and an amazing PH!!

AGREED !
 

DOC-404

AH elite
Joined
Jan 25, 2011
Messages
1,243
Reaction score
301
Media
57
Hunting reports
Africa
1
I like Ivan and think he's an excellent PH. I have no problems with the way he hunts. You get a up an close hunt, worthy of what you pay for his services. Brain shot, super deadly.

Absolutely. Ethical hunting is extremely important to Ivan. He has never been a show-off, he always works hard to give his clients an unforgettable experience without putting anyone in any sort of danger. He knows what he's doing and he understands elephant behavior better than anyone else I know.
 

1ObsessedHunter

AH veteran
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Messages
176
Reaction score
21
Media
3
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
NRA Life Member
Hunted
South Africa
Absolutely. Ethical hunting is extremely important to Ivan. He has never been a show-off, he always works hard to give his clients an unforgettable experience without putting anyone in any sort of danger. He knows what he's doing and he understands elephant behavior better than anyone else I know.
+1 I own a few of his videos and watch him all the time on Tracks Across Africa. I've NEVER seen anything indicative of unethical behavior. He's a conservationist and extremely ethical. Nor can he compared to Sullivan only in that Sullivan is a little crazy. I think Ivan would be very disappointed if he read this thread.
 

enysse

AH ambassador
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
11,762
Reaction score
4,348
Media
136
Hunting reports
Africa
8
USA/Canada
1
Member of
Northeast Wisconsin SCI chapter, Lifetime member of NRA,RMEF
Hunted
Namibia, South Africa (East Cape, Guateng and Limpopo)
I think Ivan would be very disappointed if he read this thread.

I agree! We should be careful, how we talk about people. I have never seen or heard Ivan do anything that wasn't positive for wildlife conservation.

I don't go to the BIG SHOWs, but if I did. I would walk up to Ivan and tell him I enjoy watching his hunts, they bring a lot pleasure to my otherwise dull day.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
37,369
Messages
712,882
Members
66,635
Latest member
Joshuaedurl
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

degoins wrote on Treemantwo's profile.
I have a like new VC .450 I might part with. I had it built in 2013 and it has served me well. Also have a VC fitted leather trunk case for it along with the plastic case it came with. I'll take 14000 for all of it.
Matt W wrote on Jody's profile.
Hi Jody,
I have been looking for ideas on the best way to display my European mounts from Africa. I came across some of your shield work and was wondering if you would be willing to make one for me? If so, please let me know the cost. I like the shield with the two spears that you built for a member years ago. Thanks.
cal pappas wrote on Mnelson2's profile.
Nelson. Is this message a PM format. I want to send you my email, but don't know if this is the cirrect way to do it. I'm at <pappas@mtaonline.net> Send me an email with your phone and I will call you about a skull I have. I went to school in Boston and am from Bernardston in the west part of the state. Moved to Alaska in 1984 adn never looked back.
BeeMaa wrote on Justbryan's profile.
Sold a Blaser scope mount to him. He was a pleasure to do business with.
BeeMaa wrote on 375Fox's profile.
Sold a Blaser scope mount to him. Was a pleasure to do business with.
 
Top