I posted this on Facebook recently, after getting sick and tired of all the bickering about whats right and what not... Thought you guys may also weigh in on my opinion.
Recently, a lot of flack has been slung back and forth between different countries’ outfitters, PH’s and even hunting clients. Our Namibian guys try and downplay the South African outfitters smaller (on average) game farms, their hunting of captive bred lions, and breeding of game animals for larger horn size or different colours. The South Africans normally retaliate with the fact that a lot of bred game are sold across the border to Namibia, that Namibia is a dry country thus the farms have to be bigger, and recently they even try to make the suggested ethics training of Namibia’s MET off as a point against Namibian hunting.
As a Namibian with interests in both countries, my two cents:
All this does, is create divide amongst like minded people. And like it or not, we are playing right into the hands of the anti-hunting brigade by doing this. I understand that everyone is under pressure to try and promote their business, and one of the most effective ways is to distinguish it from your competitors. But, this should never be done by slandering someone else’s way of doing business.
Just remember, the anti-hunting people really does not care HOW we hunt wild game, they are only concerned by the fact that we actually kill it, and by the perception that we may even enjoy it. So, by criticising someone else’s way of earning a living, we are playing right into their hands. Who are we to decide who should enjoy hunting, and how?
I personally have no problem with outfitters that breed game, restock game, hunt captive bred animals, hunt on smaller farms, etc. Whatever you need to do to make your piece of land profitable and accessible for hunting, hell, do it! (As long as it’s within the law.) There is a market for all these ways of hunting, and all these animals, so feed the market, get more land under conservation, and most of all, stand together to form a united front against the ant hunting onslaught.
Are there problems? Hell, YES! But I think most of these can be traced to simple lying to clients. The moment you have to revert to lying to sell your product (a hunting safari), you are part of the problem, just like the individuals that revert to name calling and trying to badmouth another person’s way of earning a living.
The moment you sell your dropped off game, as “born on the property”, the moment you start calling a game farm “a concession”, the moment you start calling lions on a 5000 acre area “free roaming”, the moment you start restocking your 1000 acre property just before the next hunters arrive, the moment you start telling clients that to shoot a captive bred lion is “better” than a wild lion, the moment you tell a client that a buffalo bull out of a breeding project is “the same thing” as hunting a truly wild animal, the moment you have to revert to shooting drugged animals, you are part of our problem. Please note, all above are examples of lies being told to clients.
Please note, I am not necessarily against the practice of captive bred lion hunting, or hunting on smaller properties, or shooting bred up animals. I am just against the lying associated with this.If the client KNOWS this, and he or she has no problem with it, and it is a legal activity, by all means you have my blessing. It may not be how I choose to hunt, but I will not criticize you for doing it. (I personally have an issue with the color variants though, but that's a personal thing. I would still not criticize anyone doing it if this means more land is conserved for game. We should just guard against when it is considered game and when it becomes livestock... not that Brahman bulls that became wild are not fun to hunt...),
So please, let’s stop BS clients, stop fighting amongst ourselves, and rather help each other against the onslaught.
Recently, a lot of flack has been slung back and forth between different countries’ outfitters, PH’s and even hunting clients. Our Namibian guys try and downplay the South African outfitters smaller (on average) game farms, their hunting of captive bred lions, and breeding of game animals for larger horn size or different colours. The South Africans normally retaliate with the fact that a lot of bred game are sold across the border to Namibia, that Namibia is a dry country thus the farms have to be bigger, and recently they even try to make the suggested ethics training of Namibia’s MET off as a point against Namibian hunting.
As a Namibian with interests in both countries, my two cents:
All this does, is create divide amongst like minded people. And like it or not, we are playing right into the hands of the anti-hunting brigade by doing this. I understand that everyone is under pressure to try and promote their business, and one of the most effective ways is to distinguish it from your competitors. But, this should never be done by slandering someone else’s way of doing business.
Just remember, the anti-hunting people really does not care HOW we hunt wild game, they are only concerned by the fact that we actually kill it, and by the perception that we may even enjoy it. So, by criticising someone else’s way of earning a living, we are playing right into their hands. Who are we to decide who should enjoy hunting, and how?
I personally have no problem with outfitters that breed game, restock game, hunt captive bred animals, hunt on smaller farms, etc. Whatever you need to do to make your piece of land profitable and accessible for hunting, hell, do it! (As long as it’s within the law.) There is a market for all these ways of hunting, and all these animals, so feed the market, get more land under conservation, and most of all, stand together to form a united front against the ant hunting onslaught.
Are there problems? Hell, YES! But I think most of these can be traced to simple lying to clients. The moment you have to revert to lying to sell your product (a hunting safari), you are part of the problem, just like the individuals that revert to name calling and trying to badmouth another person’s way of earning a living.
The moment you sell your dropped off game, as “born on the property”, the moment you start calling a game farm “a concession”, the moment you start calling lions on a 5000 acre area “free roaming”, the moment you start restocking your 1000 acre property just before the next hunters arrive, the moment you start telling clients that to shoot a captive bred lion is “better” than a wild lion, the moment you tell a client that a buffalo bull out of a breeding project is “the same thing” as hunting a truly wild animal, the moment you have to revert to shooting drugged animals, you are part of our problem. Please note, all above are examples of lies being told to clients.
Please note, I am not necessarily against the practice of captive bred lion hunting, or hunting on smaller properties, or shooting bred up animals. I am just against the lying associated with this.If the client KNOWS this, and he or she has no problem with it, and it is a legal activity, by all means you have my blessing. It may not be how I choose to hunt, but I will not criticize you for doing it. (I personally have an issue with the color variants though, but that's a personal thing. I would still not criticize anyone doing it if this means more land is conserved for game. We should just guard against when it is considered game and when it becomes livestock... not that Brahman bulls that became wild are not fun to hunt...),
So please, let’s stop BS clients, stop fighting amongst ourselves, and rather help each other against the onslaught.
Last edited by a moderator: