USA: NJ Public Land Black Bear DIY 2026

HookMeUpII

AH elite
Joined
Apr 15, 2021
Messages
1,374
Reaction score
3,541
Location
USA
Media
14
Hunting reports
Africa
1
USA/Canada
1
Hunted
New Jersey, Georgia, RSA
I resigned myself this year to take a black bear in my home state of NJ before they shut it down again. NJ has a relatively storied history of black bear hunting, dating back to the 1970's. It was closed for 33 years, only to reopen in 2003. They then closed it down again periodically from 2003 until 2023 when they had a slew of attacks/incidents. Not surprising at all, really.

I can get into the whole process but it would take volumes to fully express and we can just get to the good parts. What I will say is 1) I took up bowhunting primarily for this, 2) I only picked up a bow exactly 6 months ago and 3) days and many miles have been consumed leading up to this. I underestimated this whole process.

In terms of the land, I was hunting semi-public. My stand is technically on public land, but only really accessible within reasonable means via the land-lease of the club I am a member of.

The hunt opened Monday, October 12th. My plan was two sits, every day of the week, as long as it took while it was open. Morning and afternoon. Monday morning was a bit chilly with wind chills in the 40's. Never the less, I had a small bear I had on cam come in and nose around my site, under my stand. It was very neat, and fulfilling, to see my hard work at least pay off somewhat. I left the stand around 10am, went home, logged on to do some work.

The plan was to return around 2:30pm and be in my stand by 3:00pm. My cousin, Mike, was going to also be hunting his stand a bit closer. He's a veteran hunter and he and my uncle introduced me to hunting.

Most of the good bears I had on cam were coming in around 6:00pm. The afternoon was a complete flip of the morning. Now we were close to 80 degrees and no wind. I climbed into my stand, and began my second sit. It was a bit hot, for sure, and I did not know how it would pan out.

Around 5:30pm I heard a huffing and growling to my left, coming up the trail I approached from. Shortly after, a decent (maybe 200-225 lb) boar comes up. He spins 180 degrees, and looks back down the trail...ears back, posturing low. And I knew what was coming. Up the trail behind him comes a good boar, big thick head, wide set small ears. I had seen both these bears before. In fact, they fought on my camera once or twice. He looked right at me, nose in the air. He disregarded my presence and focused on the smaller boar in my site he was intending to battle. This was going to be my bear.

From that point, I can't remember what my body did, how I did it, or anything else. It just went through the reps. He fully showed himself, giving me a right to left broadside shot at 18-20 yds. I vaguely remember my site picture and putting the 20-pin 5-6" behind the shoulder. I let the arrow fly. The GT Pro Hunter with Grim Reaper Whitetail Special broadhead slammed him hard and I heard the "whack." He spun around growling, and took off. The other smaller boar took off. In my mind, I saw the arrow sticking out of him. I heard him, thunder back the trail. Then he hooked left, ran back up towards my direction. I actually caught a flash of him running back up. Sticks were cracking and smashing, but no death moan. I looked at my watch: 5:39pm.

I immediately assumed a bad shot in the shoulder. Called my cousin. He said lets give him 20 min and then he would come over. Then the mind-games began. "Why did I rush the shot? I had time. Now you wasted an amazing opportunity." etc. My cousin arrived at my site with my arrow in hand, which he found on the trail. It was covered in thick blood all the way to the fletching. We found blood immediately where I shot him, and it never stopped. On hands and knees we crawled into thick briars, virginia creeper vines, into an absolute hell hole. With my head lamp I spotted a lump of black fur nestled in a thick tangle of briars.

My cousin and I shared a handshake and hug. I called my wife, on my knees, briars and vines over my head and said "I got him...." 50-60 yds from where I shot him, he died, next to his den. My bad shot actually was quite good. It took the front of his lungs out and severed the top of the vessels off his heart. No death moan, he just expired.

James Black Bear 1 EDIT.jpg


And as anyone who has DIY hunted any bear goes, the real work starts when you put your hands on black fur. I'll get into that later in another post.
 
Last edited:
Congratulations, well done.
 
Nice looking bear, hope you can get some info from the tags in his ears from fish and game
 
Congratulations nice bear!
 
Recovery was rough. First, we had to get him where we could work with him.

James Black Bear 2.jpeg


We used some hand saws, clippers, and gloves that I keep with me to cut around and get him out. Then I had 550 cord we tied around his back ankles. Working in unison, we dragged him into a clearer area. Still not great, we gutted and dressed him there. The problem now was we had to go up a slight incline with what we estimated was a 300 lb bear to get to the trail. We tried, wasn't working. Too much friction between him and the ground.

I returned to my truck and grabbed my sled. A mile back in, we tipped him into it, using the incline to help. The sled now allowed us to go up hill easier.

We reached the main trail and then we began the drag.

James Black Bear 3.jpeg


Back at the truck, we used a hill to get the ground between the tailgate short, and we lifted him in with the sled. He stretched the entire length of my 5'7" box.

With the recovery now official, I made the call in to NJ department of fish and game for a late check in. It was now 9:50pm.

I stopped on the way home to grab 6 bags of ice, per the taxidermist instructions, and packed him good in the sled.

My wife wife met me outside our house at 11:15pm. She hugged and kissed me. She didn't know what to say after seeing the bear. Finally she found the words:

"Ok here is a garbage bag for your clothes. Take them off in the garage. Shower and come to bed." LOL
 
One heck of a bear. Well done.
 
One heck of a bear. Well done.

Thank you! I was very pleased. In NJ, this is a "good" bear which made me happy. We have some monsters here.

Yesterday, a 707 gutted, was checked in.

My friend Brian was the individual who took the 900 lb+ bear in 2024.
 
Awesome bear. Good to see guys down that part of the coast getting after it and harvesting bears and deer!
 
I looked at my phone, 12:10am October 13th. I rolled into bed. My adrenaline was still going. I couldn't sleep. Tossed and turned all night. Wasn't bad anxiety but anxiety none the less. I had a very large bear sitting in the back of my truck that needed to be properly "finalized".

Making a few calls, a mentor said just get to the check in station with him first thing. Coincidentally, the check in was literally 2 miles from where I arrowed him. Wasn't sure what to expect. Would it be protestors like years past? Would they be pissed and smug with me? 8:00am I left the house to be there for 9:00am opening.

Quite the contrary. I was met by 3 NJ biologists, all smiles, excited to weigh and study my bear. A younger woman comes up and says "Oh a bigger one! Awesome!" Her colleague, an absolute monster of a man, grabbed the sled with one hand in the back of my truck and slid it back. In my mind, I figured either I was very weak or my bear wasn't that big. They asked me what I thought the weight was. I said 200. They laughed, chained him up, and hoisted.

The scale said:

James Black Bear 4.jpeg


Given that, they estimated live weight of 330-340. I was happy. Well beyond what I thought it weighed.

They opened his mouth, clipped a piece of his tongue. I believe they took some other samples too. The biologists began explaining the double Texas tags and the lip tattoo which I had no idea he had lol.

James Black Bear 5.jpeg


He was apparently 7-8 years old on the high side. 6-7 on the lower. He was handled this year in the spring. Caught in a snare on a tree, darted with a pole. He put on 40-50 lbs. supposedly.

A CO came over, said it was a nice bear. Congratulated me and shook my hand. Everyone there was super supportive.

They presented me with this patch, which I admit, is pretty cool looking. I gave it to my son who was gassed up to get it lol.

James Black Bear 6.jpeg


From there I went to the taxidermist. He skinned and quartered it. Went right into the cooler.

James Black Bear 7.jpeg


Then an hour later, it was dropped off at the butcher.

He called me the next day (October 14th) to tell me my 80 lbs of product is ready:

Chop meat
Back strap medallions
Kielbasa
Cheddar jalapeno brats
German brats
Italian hots

At this point, everything just felt like a blur. Less than 24 hours later, the bear was gone. On the way to being fully processed.
 

Attachments

  • James Black Bear 5.jpeg
    James Black Bear 5.jpeg
    3.1 MB · Views: 19
That’s a pretty bear, are going to do a half mount? My Uncle who is a life long woodsman once said dragging a bear is like dragging two deer tied together with a rope. I never understood what he meant until I arrowed one about 6-7 years ago. It was an experience :ROFLMAO: congratulations.
 
Awesome story. This was my first year chasing them in Wisconsin. Struck out but at one point had 7-8 on baits. It’s 10x more fun than deer hunting but also a ton of work! I can’t wait to try again
 
That’s a pretty bear, are going to do a half mount? My Uncle who is a life long woodsman once said dragging a bear is like dragging two deer tied together with a rope. I never understood what he meant until I arrowed one about 6-7 years ago. It was an experience :ROFLMAO: congratulations.

I'm doing a shoulder to showcase the head. He's got a real wide set skull. Curious to see if he scores.

The body composition on them is the issue. You are exactly right. It's like moving concrete-jello. The funniest thing was when I grabbed a back leg, went to drag, and he went no where. I looked at my cousin and said "This is going to be fun..." The fat + fur + the weight = not easy to move.

Once we got him into the sled and cut down on the friction/drag, it was refreshingly easier.
 
It’s 10x more fun than deer hunting but also a ton of work! I can’t wait to try again

It's definitely different. I've not yet shot a deer. What I will say is having him come in, look right at me, and then proceed to try and go challenge the other bear is just something insane. Having this all happen below your feet is a wild experience.
 
.

Congratulations ! A great & educational report ( tags, lip tattoo etc) ! Thanks for sharing !

.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
70,611
Messages
1,580,877
Members
171,882
Latest member
nessfiposen1988
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Tuna are Running good time to Come fish or Spear. combine it with a plains game hunt.
JD Noblin wrote on caanaya5711's profile.
Hello @caanaya5711, this is JD Noblin and I saw your thread about a new Double. I am a Chapuis dealer and have a new Elan Classic 470 Nitro in stock for $18,199....it is listed on GunsInternational. Feel free to call to discuss, 405/822.1564.
Soon to be chasing dove and quail in AZ.
Hornedfrogbbq wrote on Rhoyland4's profile.
Do you mind me asking what auction you are referencing? I'm not in the market for any of those rifles...just curious.

Frosty in Fort Worth
Getting some culling done!

 
Top