Politics

What you said was the leaker wouldn’t be subject to the UCMJ. Read your post.

If the leaker is a military service member, which is who would most likely have access to the data being leaked, they would absolutely be subject to the UCMJ.

You claim to be a PhD. Personally I doubt it. You’ve demonstrated a thousand times a lack of ability to research or conduct proper data analysis. You also claim to be a veteran, but have also made bloviated and ridiculous claims about your service, so that’s in question too.

If the enemy obtains the information as a result of your action, and your intent was for classified information to be released outside of its classified constraints, there are multiple charges that can be filed against you under the UCMJ, which if found guilty would have you’re clearance revoked and have you ejected from service at a minimum, but could have to put into federal incarceration at Ft Levenworth as a maximum, which is what was said in the post you quoted.

I thought a self proclaimed PhD would know how to read? Who knew lol
Multiple charges yes, but not treason. Hand secrets to an Iranian spy, then yes, go warm up the electric chair. Hand them to the press, then maybe Trump should go after the news agency for treason. But, as I said, that would be tough given the 1st Amendment. Also, it would be tough proving the news they broadcast significantly aided and abetted the enemy given the way this war has progressed (or lack thereof). Actually, as I said, the one who seems to have been aided was Trump. Hegseth has been pleading for more funds to keep this war going. Looks like there's evidence now that there isn't enough money. So Congress must poop or get off the pot. Well, that might have worked ... except Trump denies there is any shortage of missiles and US is building new defence plants everywhere every day, blah, blah, blah. Dumb. Just go with the flow Donald and make it work! But he's not smart enough to figure that out or listen to someone who might be. Just jumps on the keyboard and starts blazing away. Again, if it's not true then no secrets were handed off and no treason was involved.

You could argue that every time the press reports some disagreement in Congress (e.g. failing to pass a military budget) that aids the enemy (which I'm sure it does) editors should go to jail. Doesn't work. Ask John Adams. Personally, if I was in a position to know critical weapons were in short supply and nothing was being done to fix it (inept leadership or lack of funding), I probably would want the public to know so maybe it can get fixed. Give me a medal! Arcom comes to mind. The other option is sit on my hands and maybe let service personnel lose their lives because they don't have the necessary equipment. Not sure I could do that.

Anyway, we all know this isn't about real or imagined missile shortages or treason. This is all about Trump and his perception of himself as the greatest thing walking the earth (while wearing a halo and robes). Someone leaked something, true or not, that made him look flawed. And he just cannot take that laying down. Only Trump is entitled to make himself look like a fool.
 
Last edited:
It seem inevitable that the west will suffer the same fate. Peace can only be obtained and maintained from a position of power look at history. Athens fell to Sparta because they got soft and philosophical. Rome got handled over and over again by the visgoths, vandals, and finally Odoacer when their decadence and expansion lead to much debt and their population became soft(for their time atleast).
Honestly there would be no Christians left if the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church didn’t reunite again the Muslims a thousand years ago when they kept ransacking and invading Europe.
Hard to win against an opponent that is not only fanatical but also not burdened by fear of consequence. I hope I’m wrong.
 
Multiple charges yes, but not treason. Hand secrets to an Iranian spy, then yes, go warm up the electric chair. Hand them to the press, then maybe Trump should go after the news agency for treason. But, as I said, that would be tough given the 1st Amendment. Also, it would be tough proving the news they broadcast significantly aided and abetted the enemy given the way this war has progressed (or lack thereof). Actually, as I said, the one who seems to have been aided was Trump. Hegseth has been pleading for more funds to keep this war going. Looks like there's evidence now that there isn't enough money. So Congress must poop or get off the pot. Well, that might have worked ... except Trump denies there is any shortage of missiles and US is building new defence plants everywhere every day, blah, blah, blah. Dumb. Just go with the flow Donald and make it work! But he's not smart enough to figure that out or listen to someone who might be. Just jumps on the keyboard and starts blazing away. Again, if it's not true then no secrets were handed off and no treason was involved.

You could argue that every time the press reports some disagreement in Congress (e.g. failing to pass a military budget) that aids the enemy (which I'm sure it does) editors should go to jail. Doesn't work. Ask John Adams. Personally, if I was in a position to know critical weapons were in short supply and nothing was being done to fix it (inept leadership or lack of funding), I probably would want the public to know so maybe it can get fixed. Give me a medal! Arcom comes to mind. The other option is sit on my hands and maybe let service personnel lose their lives because they don't have the necessary equipment. Not sure I could do that.

Anyway, we all know this isn't about real or imagined missile shortages or treason. This is all about Trump and his perception of himself as the greatest thing walking the earth (while wearing a halo and robes). Someone leaked something, true or not, that made him look flawed. And he just cannot take that laying down. Only Trump is entitled to make himself look like a fool.
Only “contributor” here whose use of the first person plural constitutes a constituency of one.
 

Should of just stayed in England then
 
My issue with the leakers isn’t even the hard numbers of each specific platform or weapon system. It’s more the psychological and or negotiating boost this type of information gives the enemy.

China and others have people planted in pretty much every U.S. industry. That is also why we have intelligence people in just about every U.S. industry.
So they have access to more than they should.

But giving Iran the psychological boost during negotiations is exactly why many American Legion and VFW posts still have stickers of Jane Fonda‘s face in their urinals.
Yup. I still ain't fonda Hanoi Jane.
 
I can’t imagine Putin would be so stupid as to launch an attack against NATO. Time will tell.

I'm of the (admittedly not that informed) opinion that it's pretty unlikely, but perhaps not impossible.

If he is going to do so, I'm also of the opinion that it'll be sooner rather than later, and will likely coincide with China having a go at Taiwan. What with Russia now effectively being a Chinese lap dog, it seems an obvious choice for Xi.

Do it today, and the US will have a hell of a time trying to respond effectively in Europe, the Middle East, and the South China Sea simultaneously.

Plus Russia isn't getting any stronger, and currently Europe is pretty weak, even against a threat as pathetic as Russia has proven to be.

Add in NATO relations being in a pretty poor spot as another consideration I suppose. I don't personally think the alliance has weakened enough for it to be a factor, but I can see why a Russian military analyst would consider the possibility.

By contrast, wait to 2029 and I'd expect Europe will finally become at least marginally useful in defending their own back yard, Japan will have become marginally useful in defending theirs, Russia will be even more of a joke than it already is, and hopefully the US will have both wrapped up this middle east adventure and developed some sort of cohesive geopolitical strategy. The opportunity will have passed, or at least will be less appealing.

Let's hope Xi is banking on Taiwan caving politically in 2028 instead of the military option I guess.

I'd give all of this pretty long odds of actually happening to a level that triggers article 5, but that's still not super reassuring...
 
For those that think the U.S. Military is synonymous with Government waste or as wasteful as politicians and their pet project NGO scams.

The reality is that in the trenches, the military is always streamlining, improving processes and procedures. And awarding those that improve processes.

This example isn’t new or rare, the scale may be but the continuous improvement is not.

 
If anyone thinks Mike Rogers has a chance against Abdul I’ll take that bet. I’m betting Abdul will be Michigans next Senator. I will happily lose and pay.


 
For those that think the U.S. Military is synonymous with Government waste or as wasteful as politicians and their pet project NGO scams.

The reality is that in the trenches, the military is always streamlining, improving processes and procedures. And awarding those that improve processes.

This example isn’t new or rare, the scale may be but the continuous improvement is not.


This story speaks well of the culture that young man is working in.
 
This story speaks well of the culture that young man is working in.

In the Marines we have Strategic Cororals, so dubbed by the then USMC Commandant General Krulak,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Block_War From this reference,
"The strategic corporal is the notion that leadership in complex, rapidly evolving mission environments devolves lower and lower down the chain of command to better exploit time-critical information into the decision making process, ultimately landing on the corporal, the lowest ranking non-commissioned officer, typically commanding a fire team of 4 individuals or a squad of 12 individuals (three fireteams). In very rapidly evolving mission situations, obtaining mission instructions from remotely located command may result in mission failure, or in casualties to both force personnel and civilians. Conversely, misusing this kind of responsibility may result in personal liability for the team leader: a decision executed to respond to situational needs may result in later prosecution as the team leader's actions are reviewed by higher authorities."

In the maintenance fields the same applies. Although not intense like infantry in combat, leave it to corporals to figure out how to do things better.

This reminds me of the NCO welding up plows for tanks to push through hedge rows after the D Day landings.
"The invention of a hedge-breaching device is generally credited to Curtis G. Culin, a sergeant in the 2nd Armored Division's 102nd Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron. However, military historian Max Hastings notes that Culin was inspired by "a Tennessee hillbilly named Roberts", who during a discussion about how to overcome the bocage, said "Why don't we get some saw teeth and put them on the front of the tank and cut through these hedges?" Rather than joining in the laughter that greeted this remark, Culin recognized the idea's potential.

A prototype tusk-like assembly was created by welding steel scrap (from destroyed "Czech hedgehogs") to the front of a tank to create a hedge cutter. The teeth helped prevent the vulnerable underside of the tank from being exposed while it knocked a hole in the hedgerow wall. On 14 July, Lieutenant General Omar Bradley inspected the tank and "watched in awe as a hedgerow exploded ... to make way for the Sherman bursting through". According to Hastings, Culin, "an honest man", attempted to give credit to Roberts, but this was forgotten in the publicity surrounding the invention. Hastings concludes: "[Culin] became a very American kind of national hero"."
 
Last edited:
Tubby it doesn’t matter if it works or not. If you look at which age class is voting for what and who.

In Michigan. Our Senate candidate Abdul got 60% of the vote in majority Liberal white college educated areas. and maybe even higher in the Ann Arbor area.

Conservatives are terrible about putting the affordability causation together in a quick concise message.

Keeping the economy closed 18 months longer than necessary under Biden collapsed the supply side. Then he printed and handed out billions.

People were paid more to sit home than they made it work

They were buying toys and spending money like drunken sailors

Too many dollars chasing two few goods drove the cost of everything up.

Employers needing to get people back to work, had to pay more than the government was paying them driving prices up even more


Unless you find a magical way to get people to voluntarily take less pay now, prices are never coming back down

Once again, the Democrats broke it and guess who has the answer to fix it. But now they call themselves Democrat socialist.
 
Unless you find a magical way to get people to voluntarily take less pay now, prices are never coming back down
This is also why manufacturing will never return in a meaningful way. Unless people will take jobs for peanuts you will never compete with China. Unless you can convince people to pay five times more for their Walmart shirts or ziplock bags. Barring a total economic collapse or reset, the status quo will continue.
 
This is also why manufacturing will never return in a meaningful way. Unless people will take jobs for peanuts you will never compete with China. Unless you can convince people to pay five times more for their Walmart shirts or ziplock bags. Barring a total economic collapse or reset, the status quo will continue.

Then as history shows every correction and fix the Democrats need to enact to deal with their disastrous policies will increase inflation and higher prices.
and then it’s just chasing their tail, spiraling the plane into the ground and the country down into default and bankruptcy.
 
This is also why manufacturing will never return in a meaningful way. Unless people will take jobs for peanuts you will never compete with China. Unless you can convince people to pay five times more for their Walmart shirts or ziplock bags. Barring a total economic collapse or reset, the status quo will continue.
While the US may not be able to compete on a cost of labor basis with China today, it may not matter much in the near future. China is running out of Chinese. Their birth rate has been below replacement level for a few decades now. There just aren’t enough Chinese laborers to maintain Chinas position as the world’s factory floor. The CCP is doing its best to hide the ball. They’ve stopped collecting census data…not just stopped publishing it…stopped collecting it. The surest way to tell that they’re experiencing labor shortages is what they have to pay their workers. The cost of labor has risen 15%-18% per year over the last decade. This has knocked China out of being the lowest cost source for manufacturing. The whole world is trying to figure out how to get along without cheap Chinese goods because the writing is on the wall.
 
While the US may not be able to compete on a cost of labor basis with China today, it may not matter much in the near future. China is running out of Chinese. Their birth rate has been below replacement level for a few decades now. There just aren’t enough Chinese laborers to maintain Chinas position as the world’s factory floor. The CCP is doing its best to hide the ball. They’ve stopped collecting census data…not just stopped publishing it…stopped collecting it. The surest way to tell that they’re experiencing labor shortages is what they have to pay their workers. The cost of labor has risen 15%-18% per year over the last decade. This has knocked China out of being the lowest cost source for manufacturing. The whole world is trying to figure out how to get along without cheap Chinese goods because the writing is on the wall.
Well then replace China with Bangladesh in ten years. I used China as a large umbrella to cover all the sweatshop nations around the globe. And likewise, when I say US I mean the entire west because we all have fallen into the same trap.
 
Then as history shows every correction and fix the Democrats need to enact to deal with their disastrous policies will increase inflation and higher prices.
and then it’s just chasing their tail, spiraling the plane into the ground and the country down into default and bankruptcy.
I don’t think I mentioned or even alluded to any political parties in my post. It was essentially western thinking for the last 30 years and now we can’t go back.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
69,411
Messages
1,547,027
Members
161,651
Latest member
RZWFinn535
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Nomosendero wrote on gregrn43's profile.
Between Blak Rock and Pocahontas, I did not want to say that on the forum. That's a nice Cat!
curt672 wrote on WoodencrossIII's profile.
just making sure my message went threw
30-06Ken wrote on ftothfadd's profile.
I'll take the Vortex scope cover you have listed in the Pay it Forward thread.

Ken [redacted]
Scott CWO wrote on mark-hunter's profile.
Hi Mark. My email is [redacted]
Selling real estate in dchum’s head
 
Top