Who belongs on the Mount Rushmore of active PHs?

Simon Evans is my trusted PH for years, I would not trust anyone else as long as he is active! He is my honest voice and he knows entire Africa like the back of his hand.
 
Lots of great comments and observations here; keep 'em coming!

Several have pointed out that this conversation leaves out the all-time, historical or retired PHs. They are correct, so I've started a separate, parallel thread to invite that conversation, which is a different one, but also fascinating.

"Who belongs on the Mount Rushmore of all-time PHs?"​

 
Ultimately, these are all hunters who have a strong presence on social media.
Ultimately, there are plenty of hunters who can hold their own against all of them, but they just never participate in the Facebook/Instagram circus.
Not true of Robin Hurt I'd say but your over all point is well taken. Michel Mantheakis. Mike Angelides. Fico Vidale. Natasha Illum-Berg.
 
For a fun discussion, I would love to get the thoughts of the board on this question. Let's restrict this conversation to currently active PHs. I'm not asking about outfitters or booking agents or hunting concessions or areas; I'm thinking of the actual PH who will be on the hunt with you, carrying a rifle. In many cases the individual PH may purchase quota, and may hunt in different areas or even different countries.

Other criteria at the discretion of whoever wants to comment; please discuss your thought process or rationale as appropriate.

I'm assuming that in many cases these may not necessarily be a PH that you have personally hunted with, and the discussion may be centered around word of mouth, general perception, past awards, access to particular areas, previous average or exceptional trophy production, types of clientele served, etc. In my opinion we have a large roster of wonderful PHs working across Africa today, so of course there will be many worthy considerations and it's a subjective list, but that's part of the fun. We may see nominations for grizzled veterans who have proved it over and over for decades, and we may see nominations for young hard-chargers who are up and coming. Some may be sponsors or otherwise active on this board, and some may not. We may have an emphasis on bushcraft, or perhaps on personality/client management skills, or on trophy judgement skills, or on quality of overall trackers/team, or quite likely on shooting skills when the chips are down and a charge must be faced, or a wounded animal followed up in difficult circumstances.

In deference to the Mount Rushmore convention, you can only carve 4 on the side of the mountain...

I just think it will be fascinating to hear some discussion about this. These guys take on a very difficult job, in challenging circumstances and without much of a safety net or margin for error. Let's talk about some of the great ones and give them their flowers!
AFRICA
Murray Clayton
Rayno Egner
Wayne Williamson
Jason Roussous (sp)

EUROPE
Juan Mitjans
Johannes Stiedl IV
Beltran Cotoner

SOUTH PACIFIC
Simon Kyle-Little
Shane Johnston
 
So, to the original poster: are you planning to publish the four answers that receive the most votes?
I ask because this is a subjective and user-centered question. The quality of the PH certainly matters, but so do the individual hunter’s experience, expectations, quarry, and circumstances.

Put ten knowledgeable hunters in a room and you could very well get ten different answers and several of them could be equally valid. :)

So I’m not sure that simply counting votes necessarily identifies the “best” four.
 
Johnny duPlooy Zambia, Neil and Gary Duckworth Zim and Moz, Lindon Stanton Zim and Moz, Metzgers Namibia, Clive Eaton Bots, Michael Mantheakis Tanz, Garry Kelly RSA.

All these folks will give you a spectacular safari from start to finish.

Mark
 
I asked chat gpt to tally up the votes so far and these are the current leaders
IMG_1343.jpeg
 
So, to the original poster: are you planning to publish the four answers that receive the most votes?
I ask because this is a subjective and user-centered question. The quality of the PH certainly matters, but so do the individual hunter’s experience, expectations, quarry, and circumstances.

Put ten knowledgeable hunters in a room and you could very well get ten different answers and several of them could be equally valid. :)

So I’m not sure that simply counting votes necessarily identifies the “best” four.
In these modern times I will run an AI analysis of the thread and summarize for the benefit of all, once folks have had their say. I'm learning a lot and enjoying the discussion.

P.S. - I see that @Muntjacer23 has already queried ChatGPT on what we have so far.
 
I have no personal experience with Cliff Walker but he is up there with the best in terms of Lions and Leopards and other dangerous game taken. Appears to be someone I'd enjoy sharing the fire with some day. I don't have vast experience having only been twice (but planning next two) but Russ Lovemore has been w me on both and I hope he can come along on the next two! If a PH kills a charging elephant and it drops 30yds from your wife on you're first hunt in Africa (and it was actually on our anniversary), I dunno you kinda want to have him around from then on? At least makes him "your" all time top PH?
 
LOL I'm taking that as one vote for Mark Sullivan

I already voted earlier in the thread ..... this was more of a creative 3 spare minutes in my Friday agenda!

.
 
So, the AI analysis of the thread indicates the following:
Buzz Charlton
John Sharp
Robin Hurt
Jeff Rann
 
All time great PH’s that would have given you a safari from North to the South of Africa and stood the test of time! Gary Kelly could still do it!!!
Luke Samares
Geoff Broom
Nassos Rousos
Garry Kelly
 
You hit the nail on the head.

So, if I may ask, who would you consider to be in the top echelon of PHs today?

I'm not necessarily talking about the most famous names or those with the biggest trophy lists, but rather the PHs who combine experience, fieldcraft, judgment, tracking ability, ethics, and the ability to handle dangerous game when things don't go according to plan.
Sorry, I haven’t been on here lately. I’ve been busy enjoying an excellent safari on Coutada 9 with some friends.

I won’t name just four, but rather a larger list of whom I think are top tier PH’s that I regard as among the very best of the best.

Johnny DuPlooy
Fico Vidale
Jason Roussos (also his father, Nassos, but he doesn’t hunt much now)
Christophe Morio
Alan Vincent (the finest PH I’ve ever hunted with)
Neil Duckworth (also excellent definitely one of the very best)
Michel Mantheakis
Robin Hurt
Gary Kelly
Clive Eaton


Gotta run, lunch is waiting.
 
Thank you, Sir. I just read your wonderful report on hunting with Alan Vincent in the Selous. What a fantastic account!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
70,156
Messages
1,565,287
Members
167,438
Latest member
MathiasMan
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

migrabill wrote on Surgeon1's profile.
Be careful of this Wolfen guy. 2 messages. Both trying to sell something. He PM'ed me trying to sell something and he PM'ed my friend on here trying to sell something. Fishy.
autofire wrote on Dr Ray's profile.
Hi Dr. Ray, I will be in Cooktown from Oct 16 to Oct 23 fishing Lizard Island Black Marlin Tournament.

I have several "slack" days after fishing before I head for stay in Sydney and Fiji.

Do you have any recommendations for 1 or 2 day hunt near Cooktown?

I've hunted both DG and PG in 4 different countries in Africa.
Thank you,
Bob
 
Top