If you had to start your gun collection over.

I'm basically happy with ALL my choices. I might choose to own one less drilling. I would sure choose to wait for an upgrade in wood, engraving, and condition to make what I already chose even better.

I would also consider that in having a few less guns, the ones I have could have uncompromising glass on every single one.
 
I'm a fan of "what if?" type questions so I'll play along. It's always fun to not only reconsider my past choices but to see other people's responses as well.

When starting off with my original purchases, I was faced with a couple of limitations. First I was a right-hander who prefers to shoot left because of a bad right eye. So as an involuntary southpaw, I like ambidextrous single shots. They work really well for a lot of the hunting I do so I acquired four Ruger No. 1's and four 1885's. I was stuck in that enjoyable purchasing groove for a while.

Another thing that narrowed my choices was left-handed bolt actions come in a smaller selection of chamberings. Some desirable classics like the 257 Roberts, 7x57, 300 H&H and 35 Whelen (Ruger just announced one!) were never made in factory left-handed rifles. Left-handed DG rifles can be harder to find as well. Fortunately, I really like one of readily available options in the boringly dependable 30-06 Springfield which is why I own three. Setting up each one for a light, medium & heavy bullet, I can cover a lot of situations with this one cartridge alone.

But to answer the OP's original question, if I had to start over, the majority of my small collection would stay. I've never sold a rifle & I really like everything I have. One change I would probably make is I would have gotten a nice kipplauf rifle (e.g. Blaser K95, Merkel K5, Kriehoff Huberus) in a rimmed cartridge like the 7x57r or 7x65r with a neutral butt stock. Maybe add an additional barrel in a smaller rimmed cartridge like the 22 Hornet.

View attachment 774648

I'm not much of a shotgun guy but I would like to own a cast-on SxS for upland hunting like the Fabarms Autumn in 20ga. I do my waterfowl hunting with an ambidextrous Browning BPS 12ga but might consider upgrading to a left-handed semi-auto if I go goose hunting again.

ah_autumn-png.735530


My current rifle safe looks something like this:

DG Rifle: Winchester 70 Safari Express (LH) in 375 H&H, Ruger 77 MkII (LH) in 458 Win Mag

The workhorses: Remington 700 (with a Timney trigger), Sako 85M Hunter & Steyr CL II all in left-handed 30-06.

The 3 Amigos: Ruger No. 1A in 6.5x55, Ruger No. 1 RSI in 275 Rigby, Ruger No. 1A in 303 British. Each one is as good as the other for the deer hunting I do in the southeastern woods & I love them all. The Swede shooting 140gr Partitions has put the more deer in the freezer than any other rifle I own.

Straight Walls: Winchester 1885 Traditional Hunter in 405 Win & a Browning 1885 in 44 Magnum. My early primitive season choices for Arkansas, Louisiana & Mississippi.

Hog Rifle: Wilson Combat Protector Carbine in 300 HAM'R. Semi-auto speed with 30-30 power using 130gr Speer Hot-Cor's.

Varmint: Left-handed Cooper Model 22 in 22-250 Remington and a Browning T-Bolt (LH) in 17 HMR with a varmint barrel.

Small Game: I do most of my squirrel & rabbit hunting with a Weihrauch HW77 pneumatic. But my Browning T-Bolt (LH) Sporter in 22LR is very accurate as well.

My personal favorite stalking rifle: Ruger No. 1S in 9.3x74r with a Minox ZA-5 1.5-8x32 scope.

ah_weihrauch77-jpg.741610
I feel you man. I am left handed with a right master eye. Took me a couple of years to get used to it.
 
DG: I don't know that I have an answer? A lever action that can do that. Frankly a .45-90 seems like my best bet right now.

Everything else: my .338 Marlin Express. It has killed everything I have hunted with it, up to adult Alaskan bull moose here, and kudu and blue wildebeest over there, and out to close to 400 yards. Buying mine was one the best decisions I have ever made and I wouldn't change anything.

Rimfire: a Marlin Model 39. It's still on my bucket list.

Shotguns? I don't use them often enough to have an informed opinion.
Tundra
Do find a good M39 a true American classic
Look for a fine used one from an era you can afford. They can get pricey but are worth it . I’ve had 3 but kept the early 60s one I first had . It was expensive relative to contemporary bolts, pumps and semi autos. Scoped with a Old Weaver 4x 3/4 inch tube ,
 
A member posted his actual setup and it hit me as near perfect. Mine would be very close.

Blaser 8 Professional 2.0 with the following barrels…
- .223 Remington for practice and varmints
- 30.06 Springfield
- .338 Win Mag
- .416 Rem Mag

Matching scopes except the .416, ASR brakes on the last two and a hybrid 46m suppressor to share.

I don’t reload, and the hassle and expense of finding .300 Wby and .416 Taylor ammo has convinced me to keep the calibers simple.
 
.

I'll give it a spin ........ first of all reasonable price, practical & cover all bases -

Small stuff - Anschütz 17 HMR
Europe / Africa plains game - Blaser R8 .270
Africa heavy rifle - CZ .416
Shotgun - Beretta 20 bore

Got all bases covered & well within budget.

Then we have the would be fun & `like to have` ....

Small stuff - Ziegenhahn double in .17HMR topped with a Swaro scope by Jens Ziegenhahn Suhl
Europe / Africa plains game - Kesslerin .300 WSM by Roland Kessler in Degendorf Germany
Africa heavy rifle - 404J from Rigby in London
Shotgun - Beretta 28 bore EELL with a super grade wood stock!

Happy days !!

,
 
I had pretty much restarted my collection and I have the rifles and shotguns that will see me on a very broad range of adventures.
Ruger International 10/22
Beretta A300 Patrol 12ga
Ruger 77 .308 (16” TB)
Ruger 77 30-06
Whitworth Express 375 H&H
Ruger Americans 450bms & 358win
450bm & 5.56 AR platform
Husqvarna 146 9.3x62
If I need something for day time hog hunting, night time hog hunting, deer, bear, elk, moose, bison, small game and everything abroad I have it covered. It has taken me a good while to finally get the rifles I can depend on through the many failures or rifles that just had something missing to get it right.
 

If you had to start your gun collection over.……I would have bought 1 really good 375 hh for big game hunting everything and spent all the money over the years on hunting. Of course this is assuming a 22 lr isn’t counted, everyone has to have one of those if for nothing other than killing stuff around the house.​

What would your grail 375 be?
 
My current battery is Whitworth 375; Mannlicher Schoenauer 9.3x62 Mannlicher Schoenauer 8x57js; Mannlicher Schoenauer 30-06; and Mannlicher Schoenauer 7x57 also Mannlicher Schoenauer 6.5x53. My 22 is a Mauser 350e. Shotgun is a Remington 31
Grandpa Moose, have you ever considered a Mannlicher Schoenauer? Folks who know them like them. I can certainly recommend them. You would probably be happier if you would only consider trying them....lol
 
Many of you have referred to the Blaser R8 as the basis for a range of calibres in their theoretical new line up. Having joined the Blaser club with the 500j I am not sure about adding extra barrels yet, my Ruger No1 in 30-06 takes care of the lower range nicely and the Heym 470 double addresses the DB desire. But I will say that the Blaser action is as smooth as any and surely addresses any misgivings surrounding traditional bolt actions. It seems to be a huge improvement.
 
Grandpa Moose, have you ever considered a Mannlicher Schoenauer? Folks who know them like them. I can certainly recommend them. You would probably be happier if you would only consider trying them....lol
I have all the firearms mentioned plus another 3 MS and a prewar model 70. Love the MS action and the feel at the shoulder
 
I have all the firearms mentioned plus another 3 MS and a prewar model 70. Love the MS action and the feel at the shoulder
Long guns:
A good 22lr, probably Mossberg 152.
Montana Rifle Co American Heritage 30-06.
Remington 870 12 guage with assorted bbls.
Winchester 70 Safari Express 375HH.

Handguns:
S&W 1911 5" 45acp.
Ruger Blackhawk 6" 357 with extra 9mm cylinder.
Sig 938 Nightmare 9mm.
 
Interesting thought exercise here.

If they all evaporated and I had to start over, I would probably do this in this order as $ allowed

Tikka T1x .22 w/ dead air mask
Tikka T3 .30-06 w/ dead air nomad LTI XC
PRI Mk12 mod H w/ AEM5
Benelli SBE 20ga
Tikka T3 .223
Glock 19 gen 6
Glock 17 gen 6
Glock 44
CMP M1 Garand ( I cant be without this)
Model 70 safari express .375 h&h

That would make for a very boring but tremendously functional gun safe that would cover all my needs and my kids needs for a long time.
 
I've been on a intellectual path of trying to reduce the amount of rifle cartridges I have. I realized that I have too many, around 15 with an excessive amount of overlap. I also think I still have close to 30 rifles.

I would in theory end up with something like this in center fire rifles. I have a fondness for sporterized Mausers.

223
7-08
35 Whelen
404 J

If flat out limited to 4 rifles total with an all American perspective fitting for #250.
22LR
223
30-06
458

If I had just purchased nice Winchester 70"s for everything, I would have been happy.

But the thought of a Blazer with a nice wood stock and 3 barrels is appealing.

Shotgun
20 gauge

Pistol
9x19mm
 
Last edited:
Long guns:
A good 22lr, probably Mossberg 152.
Montana Rifle Co American Heritage 30-06.
Remington 870 12 guage with assorted bbls.
Winchester 70 Safari Express 375HH.

Handguns:
S&W 1911 5" 45acp.
Ruger Blackhawk 6" 357 with extra 9mm cylinder.
Sig 938 Nightmare 9mm.
We can’t readily carry handguns here in Canada due to the commie liberals. But there are ways around it for those who want them. Antique pre 1898 handguns in specific calibers are considered just an antique and are exempt from most all rules. My carry guns are a pair of 1877 41 caliber Colt Thunderers allowed most everywhere
 
Just kind of a fun thought experiment if you had to start over knowing what you know now. What would you get.

Dg rifle
Plains game rifle
Rifle for europe
Rifle for NA
Small game 22lr or similar.

and shotguns
12
20
Or 28 gauge
pick 2

Most importantly why you made your choice. And any fun stories related to it.

And if im missing anything feel free to add on. Just kind of a fun thought exercise.
I'd probably stick with what I've got in most areas

CZ550 in .375, bought for a buffalo hunt in Australia that never came to be (mother got sick, then COVID, then i ended up with knee replacement) bought for relative ease of finding ammunition and low recoil as DG rifles go. Probably won't hunt DG at this point, but the rifle is a lot of fun to shoot!

CZ557 Carbine in .30-06. Had a lot of different rifles in different calibers before I settled on this. Would be my go-to for NA, Europe and plains game.

I would have a Ruger/Marlin 336 as well. Currently have an old Model 94 - family heirloom. A lever gun is my choice for deer sized game inside of 150 yards or so. Also works well on hogs in thick brush.

Also a Ruger 10/22 for small game. Reliable, customizable if one wants to and accurate enough for my needs.i have an old MagTech 7022 that has been reliable, but if starting over, I'd go with Ruger

I do a lot of bird hunting and have or have had shotguns in 20, 16 and 12 gauge in semiauto, sidexside and pump configuration. If I had to start over I would go simple. Probably a couple od Remington 870s. One in 12 gauge 31/2 for turkey and waterfowl and one in 20 gauge for upland and doves.
 
Just kind of a fun thought experiment if you had to start over knowing what you know now. What would you get.

Dg rifle
Plains game rifle
Rifle for europe
Rifle for NA
Small game 22lr or similar.

and shotguns
12
20
Or 28 gauge
pick 2

Most importantly why you made your choice. And any fun stories related to it.

And if im missing anything feel free to add on. Just kind of a fun thought exercise.
DG rifle, and Plains game rifle: Blaser R8, barrels like 300 win mag and 375 H&H, with possible add on in 416. The reason is swapping barrels possibility and availability of calibers. Modern factories do not produce calibers over 9.3x62, and 375 H&H is rarity, while other larger calibers in factory rifles are extinct.
Reason: availability of DG calibers, and economy (Mauser DWM in 416 starts with 14 k price tag)

Rifle for Europe: I could use Blaser R8 in 300 win mag, but specific European rifle in design for my taste would be: CZ 550, Sako 85, 90, , Mauser M12, Sauer 101.
I would pick a specific all round Europe hunting caliber 7x64. With 5 round magazine, flush with stock.
Reason: European tradition and look, and no military calibers. Pure hunting purpose.

Shotguns:
For gentlemen's day in the field, side by side shotgun, 16 GA. Preferably Beretta
(16 GA At least. Smaller the gauge, more gentlemanly it is)
Reason: 500 years of Beretta history.
Side by side:
There is a real cultural tradition in parts of the British shooting world where a best-quality side-by-side (SxS) and, to some extent, smaller gauges are regarded as more elegant or sporting than an over-and-under (O/U) and a 12-bore. However, this is not a formal rule, and today many of the very best shots in Britain use over-and-unders and 12-bores.
During the Victorian and Edwardian periods (roughly 1850–1914), the great British gunmakers developed the classic English game gun.
At that time: the side-by-side was the sporting shotgun, virtually every aristocrat owned one.
and driven pheasant shooting itself was largely invented by the British landed classes.

Arguably, some people consider the side-by-side "more sporting":

A side-by-side generally: has more felt recoil, has a little more muzzle movement, different sight picture, requires slightly different gun mounting, however none of these make it dramatically harder.
But among traditionalists, successfully shooting difficult birds with a classic SxS demonstrates greater refinement.

For more rough hunt, shotgun Berreta silver pigeon, 12 GA, O/A (optional choice Browning b 525)
Reason, locking system of berretta makes it most elegant factory shotgun for my taste. And browning b525 descendent of B25 is indestructible Browning design, made today with extremely high quality control in Japan, both of them for reasonable price.

Smaller game, 22lr
I would not go to more power, like 22wmr and above.

Cheapest ammo. Training, plinking, small game, training the next generation.
I would choose Brno 2, cz 452, cz 455, cz 457. Maybe tikka t1x. Anschutz 1761 in some hunting stock

Reason: I have problem finding any better design in 22lr rifles, to combine the look, accuracy, handling, feeding as those that I noted.
It seams that gun factories today do not pay too much attention in workable and aesthetic designs, on 22lr rifles, produced for mass market to be on extreme budget level.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
68,825
Messages
1,532,354
Members
157,551
Latest member
eldigtahunt1981
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Enjoying hunting in the Kalahari with good FREIND Brendan HTK safaris
Stnelson wrote on Never Been's profile.
I want one of the stocks.
buckstix wrote on 450 Dakota's profile.
SENT THIS PM YESTERDAY ..

I will take a set .. I would take more than one set if you have more.

BUCK STIX - [redacted]
 
Top