I would concede that whitetail CAN be overrated.. but I think that really depends on what someone is looking to get out of the hunt.. its certainly not challenging if thats the primary qualifier..
I genuinely love whitetail hunting though.. not for the trigger pull.. thats pretty easy to accomplish when using a rifle thats rested on pack or some other object, in the window sill of a blind, thats exactly 100 yards from the feeder that the deer has come into to get his morning breakfast..
What I love about whitetail hunting is the peace and quiet.. just sitting in the blind a half hour before sun up, listening to the birds start to wake and move around, watching the squirrels and cardinals steal a few bites of corn every few minutes, while sipping strong coffee from a thermos.. no one else talking to me.. no one else to worry or be concerned about.. phone off.... total calm... I enjoy watching the deer come in, watching their behaviors, etc.. and then after the morning hunt, spending some time in camp with friends, having a nice lunch, bullshitting around, etc... same thing after the afternoon hunt.. hanging out around the fire with buddies, and just enjoying not being in the office.. the trigger pull is just about filling the freezer for me to be honest.. I go deer hunting for all of the other reasons..