I have hunted over GSPs and they are okay. Problem is I don't like to hunt the early season when too many fair weather hunters are about with their goofy kennel raised dogs. Late season when snow is on the ground and wind blowing hard works better ... but not for shorthairs. Also, birds are spookier late in the season and GSP range to the next zip code. No matter how good a pointer, the birds won't hold till hunter shows up. I have the ideal bird dog: a pointing Lab. Ellie works close and hunts uplands like a cat. If she goes on point and it's a rooster, he's only got about 20% chance at best of not landing in the pot. And she is the happiest most loveable dog I've ever owned. Loves EVERYONE. Nice thing about Labs is they pretty much come ready to hunt right out of the chute. When I see a Lab in the field wearing e-collar it's because 1) the dog is stuck in a kennel instead of living in the house with the hunter or 2) the hunter is just in a technogeek addict. Your Lab that wouldn't hunt is an anomaly. And that is an understatement. Finding one that won't show YOU how it's done is rare indeed.
View attachment 797453
Another breed to consider is French Brittany ... not the American variety. French Britts are smaller and work closer than their long-legged more wound up American cousins. And they are prettier. Tri-color black-white-brown is not uncommon. My little fifteen year-old "Puppy" is a sweetheart. Not as outgoing as Ellie but friendly. Very much attached to me. She won't hunt under anyone else, not even my daughter who was raised with her. I dropped them off and then drove off to take my grandson to sitter. Puppy went running down the highway after me! Camps at the bathroom door whenever I'm taking a dump or in the shower. Lays on the floor as close as possible to my head. Formerly she laid next to my heart in bed but in recent years prefers to lay on hard surfaces. Something to do with arthritis maybe. In a few days we will leave for what will probably be both dogs' last hunting season (Ellie the Lab is eleven). Puppy will be limited to short time in the field but she's still alert and surprisingly mobile. Anyway, if your wife sees a Fr Britt, the searching will be over! Pretty dogs, affectionate, great hunters, and really just the right size, especially for travelling. A bit high maintenance but nothing like GSP. I wouldn't have a wirehaired German dog on the place. Never let my dogs hunt around them. I have seen too many ornery ones.
Honestly, I don't know why anyone would own any dog but a Lab. Sure, I've seen other fancy breed pedigreed dogs that simply would not hunt. It happens. But very very rare for a Lab. If you are considering a Lab for uplands, and they are great for it, I advise steering clear of English Labs. Legs too short and bodies too bulky. Get a long-legged long-nosed American Lab. Lots more endurance.
Incidentally, I have been raising hunting dogs since 1964 (all but Puppy have been Labs) and never owned an e-collar. For a long time I hunted with three dogs at once and they were always under control.
View attachment 797454