Politics

I think they're blaming a system that failed to help her in any meaningful way when it was obvious to anyone with half a brain that there was something wrong with her (perhaps that's why some of you guys on here can't figure this one out). That doesn't excuse her actions. But this tragedy could have been prevented if more people helped her, or just gave a shit.

At some point we'll be right back here in the future because of those on the right who would rather scream about personal responsibility rather than improve a broken system. Do you think if you scream it loud enough it'll bring back those three kids?
“But this tragedy could have been prevented if more people helped her”

Help her exactly how. She was prescribed a dozen drugs. Under the care of two doctors
Everyone that knew her knew she needed to be locked up.

In every major city the “homeless” are primarily mentally handicapped people. It’s the Left that is against sweeping them up and locking them up somewhere they can get help and or at least not push people in front of subway cars, stab them in the neck or light them on fire.

And the left isn’t opposed to locking them up due to compassion. It’s that doing so would impede with the homeless NGO grift.

What do you say should have been done to help her ?
 
You can do it WAY cheaper than actually going on African Safaris. For example, my last 18 day wilderness Zimbabwe safari cost $28,000, whereas I can hunt for free on my own land.

Hunting on your own land for free is definitely an option. You just need a few frugal improvements to do it right.

$1000 for a mineral wallow
$500 for a water trough to keep the wildlife watered
$15,000 for an orchard for early season.
$2000 for chestnut trees to attract them late season.
$1000 for persimmon trees to attract them mid-season.
$12,000 for box blinds, tree stands, safety lines, etc.
$1000 for buddy heaters and comfy chairs for the box blinds.
$1000 for wildflower and pollinator seeding to create a complete ecosystem.
$2500 for managed forestry to ensure the acorn mast years encourage wildlife.
$2000 for controlled burns to regentrify prairie health.
$2500 for a good bow and proper arrows, you do want a clean pass through.
$3500 for a good crossbow so guests can make a clean kill.
$2500 for seed, planting, and glyphosate to ensure your bean plots, clover, and brassicas do well.
$5000 for a good rifle, powder, primer, bullets, and reloading gear for that perfect shot.
$400 for flashlights, because you need to recover the game shot at dusk.
$20,000 for a UTV to recover the deer because its a long walk.
$500 for a roto tiller to make false scrapes
$250 for licenses and tags
$1000 for early, mid, and late season clothes
$250 for a safety harness because safety matters

See, its way cheaper, practically free. You should see the size of the doe I shot last year "on the cheap"!
How big a block is that for?
I’ve been debating on posting a thread asking if anyone can assist me in choosing a block for hunting (if I sent links or where to search to find them)
 
If you listen to the liberal media, Trump hates Canada and just indiscriminately slapped tariffs for no reason.

I’m no fan of how the world wide tariffs have been used overall. I think they should have been used like a scalpel not a hammer.

But once again Quebec screws the rest of Canada. Requiring U.S. and other provinces use French as a primary language in packaging directions and instructions.
If we in the U.S. order items from Quebec. The packaging and instructions must be in French.

The other Provinces are not fans of bill 96 either.


 
I think they're blaming a system that failed to help her in any meaningful way when it was obvious to anyone with half a brain that there was something wrong with her (perhaps that's why some of you guys on here can't figure this one out). That doesn't excuse her actions. But this tragedy could have been prevented if more people helped her, or just gave a shit.

At some point we'll be right back here in the future because of those on the right who would rather scream about personal responsibility rather than improve a broken system. Do you think if you scream it loud enough it'll bring back those three kids?

Typical, blame something not the individual, she was crazy, she was in drugs, her friends didn’t see the signs, blah, blah, blah. For decades the left has been blaming everything else, except the individual. It all comes down to personal responsibilities/accountability.
 
If you listen to the liberal media, Trump hates Canada and just indiscriminately slapped tariffs for no reason.

I’m no fan of how the world wide tariffs have been used overall. I think they should have been used like a scalpel not a hammer.

But once again Quebec screws the rest of Canada. Requiring U.S. and other provinces use French as a primary language in packaging directions and instructions.
If we in the U.S. order items from Quebec. The packaging and instructions must be in French.

The other Provinces are not fans of bill 96 either.



I’m withholding commenting until I can see what was actually being argued about so far all i can find is just speculation and no one seems to have a copy of what was actually in the trade agreement.

As it’s being reported here lutnick blew up the deal by making eleventh hour changes ahead of the signing whether intentional or not.
 
Youre a lawyer. I am assuming all of those men would be found guilty.

Think you are just arguing for arguing sake.
You assume wrong. Lots of men have been found not criminally responsible due to mental illness.

It has been going on for decades.
 
Projection much?

Feminists are backing this nutjob and blaming her husband.

If a man had murdered his 3 kids, condemnation would come from every corner, including feminists, but most especially from other men. The feminists are circling the wagons and trying to excuse abhorrent behavior, blaming everyone and everything other than the woman who did the murdering.

I bet you're the sort who eats dinner with your wife's boyfriend.
I guess you simply havn't followed the case and want to babble on with some woman hating bullshit.

The argument in her case is that she had undiagnosed bipolar disorder and post-partum psychosis and the evidence they apparently will call was that she was prescribed 20 different medications for her mental illness that interacted poorly and did not solve her problem.

I don't know if the defence will fly or not but that is what they are arguing. It has nothing remotely to do wth the normal stresses of life, you just chose to lie about that. No surprise. Women hating nutbars tend to be dishonest.

You also clearly don't know the first thing about the criminal justice system. People get charged and their lawyers try to find ways to beat the charge. But not guilty by reason of mental defect as a defence has been run by men in thousands of cases. Sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't.

You are the kind of schmuck who takes a terrible tragedy, combines it with a profound ignorance of the law and a clear hatred for women and tries to make a bizarre political argument based on lies.

Well played. What does your wife think about your idea that women shouldn't vote or drive?
 
You assume wrong. Lots of men have been found not criminally responsible due to mental illness.

It has been going on for decades.

Counsel that was not the question, we know people can plead not guilty due to insanity.

Does being Bi-Polar excuse someone from criminal responsibility of murder?
 
If you listen to the liberal media, Trump hates Canada and just indiscriminately slapped tariffs for no reason.

I’m no fan of how the world wide tariffs have been used overall. I think they should have been used like a scalpel not a hammer.

But once again Quebec screws the rest of Canada. Requiring U.S. and other provinces use French as a primary language in packaging directions and instructions.
If we in the U.S. order items from Quebec. The packaging and instructions must be in French.

The other Provinces are not fans of bill 96 either.


Trump is actually doing a great job in bringing our country together. In the past you were quite right on Bill 96 but the worm is turning.

I am not sure, however, that even if the labelling issue was not on the table that the deal would have gotten done anyways.
 
Trump is actually doing a great job in bringing our country together. In the past you were quite right on Bill 96 but the worm is turning.

I am not sure, however, that even if the labelling issue was not on the table that the deal would have gotten done anyways.
It was one of the sticking points.

The others are repealing provincial restrictions on alcohol and dairy products form the US. The national govt can’t get the provinces to agree. In the case of alcohol most provinces removed is wine and spirits form their shelves when the tariffs went into effect last year.

A bigger deal is a provision the US wants which restricts Canada’s ability to pursue individual trade agreements with other partners. I believe this is with China in mind.

There is also some disagreement about trucks manufactured in Canada being treated differently than other vehicles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLD
Counsel that was not the question, we know people can plead not guilty due to insanity.

Does being Bi-Polar excuse someone from criminal responsibility of murder?
It can depending on the severity, the facts of the crime and the medical evidence. This defence has a shot to succeed.

For instance in this case, one of the diagnoses the defence is running up the flag pole is post-partum psychosis. Some experts define the post partum period as a number of weeks, and this case the murders took place 8 months after birth. Other experts will say that as long as the illness started in the first few weeks it can be considered post partum. Yet other experts will say PP can run up to a year after the birth.

Plenty to argue about, and for someone charged with three murders of her own children, not much to lose in running everything you can up the flag pole.

But whatever you think about mens rea and mental illness defences the idea that they are a product of feminism is bullshit, and the idea that women should not be able to vote or drive a car is equally stone age.
 
Counsel that was not the question, we know people can plead not guilty due to insanity.

Does being Bi-Polar excuse someone from criminal responsibility of murder?
Here are a couple of fairly famous examples:

1. The Retrial of Andrea Yates (2006)
  • The Case: In 2001, Andrea Yates drowned her five children in a bathtub in Houston, Texas. [1]
  • The Diagnosis: Yates suffered from severe postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis. While initial headlines focused heavily on schizophrenia, her long-term medical diagnosis was established as bipolar disorder. [1, 2]
  • The Verdict: Her initial 2002 murder conviction was overturned due to false testimony by a prosecution expert witness. During her 2006 retrial, the jury found her not guilty by reason of insanity. Experts testified that she was in a severe psychotic state and truly believed she was saving her children's souls from Satan. She was committed to a high-security state mental hospital, where she has chosen to stay ever since. [1, 2, 3]

2. Richard Rojas (2022)
  • The Case: In 2017, Richard Rojas drove his car down a crowded sidewalk in Times Square, New York, killing a teenager and injuring 22 other people. [1]
  • The Diagnosis: Rojas, a U.S. Navy veteran, suffered from severe mental illness. Medical experts at his trial testified that he was experiencing a severe psychotic episode driven by a combination of schizophrenia and bipolar spectrum mania, heavily worsened by untreated substance abuse.
  • The Verdict: In 2022, a New York jury accepted his defense and found him not responsible by reason of mental disease or defect. Instead of going to prison, he was committed to a secure state psychiatric facility for long-term treatment
 
It was one of the sticking points.

The others are repealing provincial restrictions on alcohol and dairy products form the US. The national govt can’t get the provinces to agree. In the case of alcohol most provinces removed is wine and spirits form their shelves when the tariffs went into effect last year.

A bigger deal is a provision the US wants which restricts Canada’s ability to pursue individual trade agreements with other partners. I believe this is with China in mind.

There is also some disagreement about trucks manufactured in Canada being treated differently than other vehicles.
Canada is also very close to concluding a free trade agreement with India as well and I doubt Carney was willing to give that up.
 
Here are a couple of fairly famous examples:

1. The Retrial of Andrea Yates (2006)
  • The Case: In 2001, Andrea Yates drowned her five children in a bathtub in Houston, Texas. [1]
  • The Diagnosis: Yates suffered from severe postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis. While initial headlines focused heavily on schizophrenia, her long-term medical diagnosis was established as bipolar disorder. [1, 2]
  • The Verdict: Her initial 2002 murder conviction was overturned due to false testimony by a prosecution expert witness. During her 2006 retrial, the jury found her not guilty by reason of insanity. Experts testified that she was in a severe psychotic state and truly believed she was saving her children's souls from Satan. She was committed to a high-security state mental hospital, where she has chosen to stay ever since. [1, 2, 3]

2. Richard Rojas (2022)
  • The Case: In 2017, Richard Rojas drove his car down a crowded sidewalk in Times Square, New York, killing a teenager and injuring 22 other people. [1]
  • The Diagnosis: Rojas, a U.S. Navy veteran, suffered from severe mental illness. Medical experts at his trial testified that he was experiencing a severe psychotic episode driven by a combination of schizophrenia and bipolar spectrum mania, heavily worsened by untreated substance abuse.
  • The Verdict: In 2022, a New York jury accepted his defense and found him not responsible by reason of mental disease or defect. Instead of going to prison, he was committed to a secure state psychiatric facility for long-term treatment

Thank you sir for the example, you are correct I assumed wrong.

Seems like it has to be an extreme example but it does seem like it is a credible defense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLD
Mental health issues are incredibly challenging and are influenced by so many internal, external and cultural factors. As a treated paranoid schizophrenic fellow once confided in me : “they have treated me but they can’t take away the fact that I have spoken to god”
 
Thank you sir for the example, you are correct I assumed wrong.

Seems like it has to be an extreme example but it does seem like it is a credible defense.
Always happy to chat about law. The guy who shot Reagan ran a similar defence IIRC.
 
I can’t for the life of me understand why any American citizen would want Canada to give ground on the dairy issue. Currently I subsidize Canadian milk proportionately to the amount I buy. If American milk gets on the Canadian market the American tax payer will be subsidizing my milk.
 
Mental health issues are incredibly challenging and are influenced by so many internal, external and cultural factors. As a treated paranoid schizophrenic fellow once confided in me : “they have treated me but they can’t take away the fact that I have spoken to god”

I am just wondering where we are going as a society. I have known numerous people with some form of mental illness including bi-polar, and never considered them mentally incompetent.

I realize we need to take mental health seriously and one of the things I love about the younger generation is how conscious they are of mental health.

I am afraid to look it up, but have people who have been on drugs, or drunk ever been found mentally insane, I have seen more crazy shit from people who are blacked out. And if the person was diagnosed with a disorder and didnt take their medicine, are they still considered mentally incompetent. What is the difference between someone not taking their medicine and someone doing drugs, both made a decision that impacted their ability to make logical decisions. I realize this is a gray area, but feels like this is a slippery slope.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
69,872
Messages
1,558,766
Members
165,628
Latest member
JoannaSald
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Alex Sniper wrote on Bynotic's profile.
Good morning. I see that you had a Sauer 202 for sale for $3,000. Did you sell it at that price?
I have one for sale as well. I listed it (on here ) at $3,000 as well. Is the price high, low or right where it should be?

Thanks. Alex. [redacted] in case you want to call me to discuss further. I appreciate your time help and support.
I broke my cherry, August 2026, 41" Cape, hooked for life.
Member of the South African Hunters and Game Conservation Association
supergrizzly wrote on AZDAVE's profile.
Dave, I could use both of them if still available. I just picked up a new .22 mag and a .22 pump that they would be perfect on.
 
Top