So today was the big announcement of “Trump Accounts”. I read the IRS publication linked below trying to make heads or tails of this new kiddie account and why anyone should give a damn.
Answer: You shouldn’t. These are very stupid accounts.
The only upside I see is it is trying to teach kids to save, but it does so with a social welfare program where a kid gets $1000 to start off the account “free” from the American taxpayer, provided they were born after Jan 1, 2025. They can’t touch the money until they are 18, they or their parents, or an employer can contribute to it each year up to a maximum from all sources of $5000 per year. The investments are going to be a small swath of “American” ETFs or indices. When an adult, the child can take a 10% penalty it appears, and access the money. Otherwise it is basically an IRA that is taxable as ordinary income in retirement.
What the hell is Trump and his chronies thinking? There is a superior option already in existence, the ROTH IRA! A kid can contribute to that, up to $7000 per year. Kids pay hardly any taxes on earnings because they are below the poverty line anyway, and a ROTH’s proceeds are tax free in retirement. Prior to retirement, withdrawals for education are also tax free but it can only be the principle amounts invested, not the growth. (A WAY better version of a 529 plan with way more ways to use the money) Oh, and a ROTH can be invested in virtually any stock, bond, or ETF or mutual fund.
So what the hell is the point of this political grandstanding to create a loser investment vehicle that provides no incentive to the parent, it only creates inflation and national debt?
If someone sees something I’m missing on this hairbrained idea, please let me know: