Owning Multiple Rifles from the Same Manufacturer?

Hillbilly Marine

AH veteran
Joined
Apr 19, 2017
Messages
112
Reaction score
205
Location
Hertford, NC
I have had a whole bunch of stuff over the years. Winchester, Remington, Ruger, Weatherby, CZ, Mauser of many models, Mosin-Nagant, HK, and lord knows what else. I try to just find what feels good to my shooting style (and eye appeal). After Ruger changed to the MK II I gave up on them as they just never felt right after that. Also never warmed up to Remington. I do own 3 different makes of .270 Winchester (Ruger, Savage, and Weatherby) along with a .270 Weatherby Mag in a MK 5. I have yet to warm up to the Weatherby MK 5 because plastic and SS are ugly. My thoughts go along this line, get what does what you need in terms of calibers in the same action and the fill up whatever you want to play around with. Then get rid of the ones you don't want.
 

fourfive8

AH legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2017
Messages
2,167
Reaction score
4,132
Media
245
Hunted
USA, South Africa, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Zambia, Botswana
:) Can relate to many of these posts! Based on all the various rifles/calibers I've owned and shot, a few seem better to me. I have built and have had built quite a few custom and semi-custom rifles over the years. But if comparing a good factory rifle to a good custom rifle- the lines gray somewhat as to which is the better tool.

For me it's hard to beat the basic CRF Winchester M70 for hunting. I've had and shot quite a few pre-64 M70s and they are generally very good but don't seem any better nor more useful nor more accurate than the ones made in the early 2000s. I've read about a slump of QC sometime in the late New Haven rifles but I haven't experienced it. All those later M70s were still made with quite a bit of hand labor and with machines that were old with some having to be re-set after each shift to correct runout. I suppose if an employee got lazy it would cause a problem- I just never saw one.

I had a new post New Haven, FN M70. I shot it quite a bit so we had some mileage- it was OK. Seemed reliable enough and within average accuracy potential of all the M70s I've been around. I did not care for the MOA trigger, however. We never "bonded" so It was in a group of my earlier liquidations- a few years ago. :)

Thinking back on all the actions and rifles, a few stand out for impressive workmanship in the category of "factory or military factory rifle". In no particular order- Chilean M1895 7mm Mauser made by Loewe (Berlin), a couple of the Mexican War - Civil War era rifle muskets made by US armories like Springfield or contractors like Whitney, an M1950? FN Mauser, CRF Winchester M70s in 375 HH and 416 Rem Mag made in the early to mid 2000s, some of the early Winchester lever guns in Models like 1876, 1873, 1892, 1886 and 71. While I had several reliable M1894s and still have one, they always seemed to be the "rattle battles" of the Win lever group and not my favorites. The "odd feller" of the Winchester lever group IMO was the M1895. Cumbersome as all get out to carry, not the best geometry for heavy recoil but really a very strong action with better than average smooth cycling. Of all the M1895s I had, the best shooter by far and the one I liked the best was in the nearly instantly obsolete caliber of 35 Winchester. :) With a good bullet and proper loading, mine was as impressive if not more so than the famous 405. The 405 I had was pristine in nearly unfired condition and was 1st year production. And last but not least- the Winchester lever gun and caliber that impressed me in the same way the M1895 in 35 Winchester did was the M1876 in 45-75. All three I had were impressive shooters!
 

ldmay375

AH fanatic
Joined
Nov 8, 2011
Messages
529
Reaction score
969
Media
31
So I think I am about to commit to acts of rifle sacrilege. First, I am looking at buying a non-Weatherby rifle in a Weatherby cartridge. Second, I am looking at buying the same model rifle that I already own. The rifle in question is a Dakota Arms model 76 in .257 Weatherby.

I was just wondering if y'all have a personal rule against owning too many rifles from the same manufacturer or at least in the same model. My Dakota is the nicest rifle I have ever owned but I still feel bad picking up another simply because there are so many great rifle manufacturers out that it seems like a waste to just have all of my guns in the same model from the same manufacturer.

Obviously this is a rather ridiculous question and is ultimately inconsequential but I just want to know if anyone else thinks like I do about this.
I see no issue with own rifles of the same manufacturer. Nor do I see any issue with identical rifles in the same cartridge, scopes, stocks, etc. I like rifles.
But, there are only a handful of the mass manufactured rifles that I like. So having more than the one of the same, with the same modifications, is pretty much unavoidable.
 

MS 9x56

AH fanatic
Joined
Apr 10, 2020
Messages
693
Reaction score
1,288
Location
Central NY
Media
1
I don’t really have any brand alliance other than I like a quality product. I do have a definite preference for Mannlicher stocks. As I get older I find myself gravitating to older classic rifles. The older guns just seem to fit me better now. They are not as accurate but accurate enough to keep the freezer full. Every year for the last 5 or 6 I pick 2 rifles to use until they make meat then back in the cabinet and pick another. Saturday the Savage 99 F in 308 and I get reacquainted. Next up is the Ruger 77 RSI in 250 savage. If it raine the remington model 14 in 30 rem will take me for a walk. Variety is the spice of life. To me at least brand is far down the criteria list.
 

MS 9x56

AH fanatic
Joined
Apr 10, 2020
Messages
693
Reaction score
1,288
Location
Central NY
Media
1
Its funny in that I never thought of it before. I don't own any rifles in duplicate calibers and few by the same manufacturer. Usually when I buy a new rifle I am looking for something different. My only duplications are Mannlicher stocks which I do have a decided preference for. Variety is the spice of life as they say. Never owned a straight pull or a big bore single shot so still got some holes to fill.
 

BnC 04

Gold supporter
AH elite
Joined
Jan 30, 2011
Messages
1,296
Reaction score
1,890
Location
Tennessee
Media
73
Hunting reports
Africa
3
USA/Canada
3
Member of
DSC
Hunted
Canada/Europe/Africa/14 US States
I have a fondness (several dozen worth) for pre64 and post 64 classic Winchesters. Then maybe 15 smoothbores and Winchester levers tossed in the mix.
That being said, I/we do have a few non-Winchester made manufactured firearms. Benneli, Ithaca, H&R, Mossberg, Fausti, Richland and come mid July a Heym.
 

Bob Nelson 35Whelen

AH ambassador
Joined
Oct 28, 2018
Messages
6,057
Reaction score
12,193
Location
Wyong new south Wales Australia
Media
139
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
SSAA
Hunted
Australia
Its funny in that I never thought of it before. I don't own any rifles in duplicate calibers and few by the same manufacturer. Usually when I buy a new rifle I am looking for something different. My only duplications are Mannlicher stocks which I do have a decided preference for. Variety is the spice of life as they say. Never owned a straight pull or a big bore single shot so still got some holes to fill.
@MS9X56
The only problem with owning multiple rifles of the same manufacturer is getting the bolts mixed up. Fortunately I have a P14 and a m17 and it's easy to tell the bolts apart. I would hate to have half a dozen rems and try and sort the bolts out. In Australia we used to have to store rifles with the bolts removed.
Bob
 

Ike85123

AH fanatic
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
781
Reaction score
1,624
Location
Arizona, USA
Media
1
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
None
I agree on the feel and stick with it. I went from a rem 700bdl to a rem 700cdl, when buying a new rifle. The stock was alitlle different, but same basic feel.
I didnt feel like I needed to go back to school with the thing !
 

ldmay375

AH fanatic
Joined
Nov 8, 2011
Messages
529
Reaction score
969
Media
31
I have a fondness (several dozen worth) for pre64 and post 64 classic Winchesters. Then maybe 15 smoothbores and Winchester levers tossed in the mix.
That being said, I/we do have a few non-Winchester made manufactured firearms. Benneli, Ithaca, H&R, Mossberg, Fausti, Richland and come mid July a Heym.
The Winchester post 64 M70 stainless rifles are a definite weakness of mine. Those and Ruger stainless Mark II’s and the newer Hawkeyes. The Rugers and Winchester bolt rifles are by far the majority of mine. Marlin and Winchester lever rifles are dominated in lever guns. Rimfires are a mix, definitely favoring the 1960’s - 80’s range.
 

lwaters

Bronze supporter
AH legend
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
2,246
Reaction score
2,811
Location
Manhattan Kansas
Media
117
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
4
USA/Canada
1
Australia/NZ
1
Member of
SCI
Hunted
Texas,Namibia,Kansas, Missouri, Wyoming, Colorado, Idaho, South Africa, New Zealand
I have two Ruger No.1's in 30-06 and 450/400. and two in model 77 Hawkeye in 300RCM and 375 Ruger with 20in. Barrels.
Screenshot_20210412-202342_Photos.jpeg
Screenshot_20210419-082536_Amazon%20Photos.jpeg
 

mark-hunter

AH legend
Joined
Aug 14, 2016
Messages
2,628
Reaction score
3,841
Media
30
Articles
2
Hunted
Namibia - Kalahari, Namibia - Khomas highland
I choose my rifles or pistols in advance and carefully, by barrel lenght, barrels thickness, grips, caliber, having in mind specific use: hunting, target shooting, training, specific hunting etc..
It comes down to it, that I dont have same makers multiple products.

But what I do have, is 3 firearms in same caliber: 22lr ( for three usages: small varmint hunting- rifle, match thick barrel - rifle, and pistol training and plinking, pistol)

For someone who is frequently using shotgun, for hunting, clay targets, etc etc... next most common gauge / caliber in various smooth bore platforms would be 12 GA, that would be my guess.
 

Joker12

AH veteran
Joined
Jun 21, 2021
Messages
177
Reaction score
338
Location
Michigamme, Michigan
Member of
NRA
Hunted
South Africa
For me Winchesters, Rugers, and anything using a good Mauser98 action. Doubles are not in the cards unless the lottery is good to me someday and no Remingtons. That being said I do have an old Sako Finnbear 375 that I like a lot.
 

steve white

AH enthusiast
Joined
Feb 9, 2018
Messages
436
Reaction score
572
Location
dallas tx
Articles
1
Member of
dallas safari club, mannlicher collectors assoc., era
Hunted
Cape buffalo, plains game
You may think I am weird but most of my rifles have been old Mannlicher-schoenauers in various calibers--shame I didn't buy one in 458 win mag when I had the chance. I can strip them down to the firing pin, including the rotary magazine, without tools of any kind. I like more drop at comb (and even more so with shotguns) so they fit me well and look great to boot. I will never lose a dollar on them over time, either. I do have a Sako safari in 375 H&H which I just adore. If I were going to shoot past 300 yds in range as is the rage nowadays, I would rethink everything, leaning toward bean field rifle technology.
 

Tundra Tiger

Bronze supporter
AH fanatic
Joined
Jun 1, 2019
Messages
504
Reaction score
2,347
Location
SW Alaska
Media
45
Hunting reports
Africa
2
Hunted
South Africa, USA (Alaska, Kansas, Maryland)
It's a funny thought, to me, that never crossed my mind until I saw this thread.

I buy based on desired calibers and also desired models, without a thought to who made it.

Some same manufacturers that come to mind in my stable:

Savage: Model 99 (x2), Axis, 340, Model 24
Marlin: Model 60, 336, MXLR, GBL
 

Forum statistics

Threads
41,052
Messages
807,915
Members
74,493
Latest member
Sandbagger
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Akunasek wrote on Jager Waffen74's profile.
do you still have the Ithaca 10 ga semi auto?
kdenn wrote on TROPHY SHIPPERS's profile.
Afternoon, going to South Africa August 22 hunting with wife. will need your help with trophies. what information and how soon do you need it? went to the website and completed the form but seems i have negative energy or something with electronic communication often.
thanks for your help
ken dennison
Docpk wrote on Jager Waffen74's profile.
I would but the Swarovski scope
CADJR55 wrote on roverandbrew's profile.
Is that Level 7 Type 2 Primaloft PCU parka still for sale?
geoff rath wrote on Aussie_Hunter's profile.
Apologies, been somewhat preoccupied with (poor) health issues; were you interested in the Norma factory 550 grain Solid 450 Rigby ammo I mentioned?
Geoff Rath
 
Top