Extractors or ejectors?

Gsxrmike

AH veteran
Joined
Mar 7, 2013
Messages
150
Reaction score
238
Location
Texas
Media
8
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
NRA Life member, SCI, DSC
Hunted
Zimbabwe, USA
You guys have probably discussed this previously but I am about to buy my first double rifle to use on my next buffalo hunt. Please help me decide whether to buy one with extractors or ejectors.
They still make new rifles either way so one is obviously not vastly superior to the other or else no one would buy the inferior design. What is your opinion on the topic? Thanks for your time.
 
My personal choice would be ejectors for a double rifle to clear the chambers quickly for a reload if necessary. On shotguns, I prefer extractor only because I don't like to chase empties and bird hunting and clay shooting seldom require a quick reload.
 
As the client rather than the PH, I personally prefer extractors. They allow a very quiet reload of the first barrel if that buff or tusker has hit the brush before the second shot. If I were the PH and trying to stop inbound mayhem, then I would want ejectors to quickly clear the chambers. However, either answer is correct. This is very much a subjective judgement.
 
EJECTORS....when I buy my double it will be with ejectors... I want the quick reload availability for any emergency situation!!
 
Is it possible with a DR that has ejectors to break the action open and "catch" the empties preventing them from clanging around on the ground? Or is the main source of noise the ejectors themselves?
 
The main source is the ejectors themselves. The brass sometimes likes to "ring", but really it's the ejectors. My opinion.
 
Personally I like extractors, but I think a strong argument could be made for either. I wouldn't decide solely based on extractors/ejectors.
 
The main source is the ejectors themselves. The brass sometimes likes to "ring", but really it's the ejectors. My opinion.
Correct. Issue is not the landing - it's the launch. Remarkably loud in the stillness after a shot. If you have an OU or SXS shotgun give it a try - particularly away from a bird hunt or clays shoot.
 
Correct. Issue is not the landing - it's the launch. Remarkably loud in the stillness after a shot. If you have an OU or SXS shotgun give it a try - particularly away from a bird hunt or clays shoot.

Seems like an opportunity for improvement. I would presume the source of the noise is when the extractors hit a backstop. I could see putting a bit of hard rubber on the backstop to quiet this would work, but that may introduce more problems than it solves.
 
They both have advantages and disadvantages.Ejectors are a somewhat complicated mechanisms that are fine when working correctly but not so good when out of tune.Extractors are simple and a practiced rifleman can tip the barrels up and reload very quickly not to mention the quietness of extractors.
Quietness and reliability under duress make extractors my choice.
 
They both have advantages and disadvantages.Ejectors are a somewhat complicated mechanisms that are fine when working correctly but not so good when out of tune.Extractors are simple and a practiced rifleman can tip the barrels up and reload very quickly not to mention the quietness of extractors.
Quietness and reliability under duress make extractors my choice.

Excellent points.

Regarding complication, the Southgate ejector (and its kind) is pretty straightforward and works on the over-center principle, the tumblers forced over center due to their working relationship with the forward end of the cocking levers (or rods, as when interfaced with the Purdey/Beesley lock).

The other main kind of ejector, however, the Anson & Deeley has a bit more to it (it being, in some respects, its own bit of lock work).

The Boss ejector is fairly basic and different enough from the others to be considered another class altogether (it also uses coil springs...quite rare in traditional English double gun design), but its not all that common.

There's others, of course, but most are an iteration of one of the above or are so rare (experimental) as to not be worthy of mention.
 
Southgate ejector mechanism:

image.jpeg
 
Southgate interface with sidelock and boxlock actions (in the upper image it's nearing the over center position and is about to kick the empties free):

image.jpeg
image.jpeg
image.jpeg
 
Practice with extractors until you become very confident.
I understand extractors to be quieter and somewhat more reliable.
Not speaking from any experience, just my uncommon sense.
 
I prefer ejectors.

-matt
 
I definitely would prefer ejectors but, the only buffalo I have taken so far was by means of an extractor double that I used to own.
That buffalo dropped to the shot once each from each respective barrel (one soft and one solid).

He did not get up after receiving the 2nd bullet.
So, no fancy reload was needed.
However, I like the speed of ejectors, especially for any future DG I might be fortunate enough to hunt some day.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
71,158
Messages
1,595,398
Members
175,579
Latest member
Magnolia11
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Mattias Stedt wrote on Bushcat Safaris's profile.
A good safari brings a great experience that fulfils your expectations, but a great safari also brings professionalism and friendship. Bushcat Safaris fills all those boxes and we have a lot of great memories from the bush with rifle in hand.
My warmest recommendation for you to plan a safari with these guys and be ready for a great time. As they say, we are not here for a long time, we’re here for a great time!
Looking back at a great year
cb3a8f6b-e471-4478-8e24-fa9422db8d4d.jpeg
IMG_7851.jpeg
20bdfb9b-dfe7-46e1-9d90-981da068d8fc.jpeg
915d3c84-4177-457f-a11d-0771a765f4c3.jpeg
52bf1f94-ccae-4160-bc7a-ae8d7969278b.jpeg
8d4d83fd-64e0-466c-90bc-868a7492cf61.jpeg
a31db0e9-e914-41e0-a1c2-785617ad41ac.jpeg
A small glimpse into a fantastic season
e81d375e-faf8-4cbe-bf9c-afe325b97bbb.jpeg
9a766ff2-0919-4a4a-b09c-ede9ce09b94e.jpeg
22ecca2a-8c07-4eab-becb-2ee49dca9fc3.jpeg
IMG_7820.jpeg
fa806fce-29ef-485b-9544-b103140a7ad1.jpeg
b4e3df48-40f2-4593-95bb-efbe5fdeed09.jpeg
A0A409A3-B41C-41DF-91B3-FEBFC48FF566.jpeg
f53b657c-2414-450f-bf44-292f3bd3e46c.jpeg
Don't forget to Check out our Mountain package. Chase that Vaali find the elusive Grey Ghost and spot a Mountain Reedbuck. in Gods Country. find refuge in the field and freedom under wide open skies.
 
Top