1. An easy Google search will provide you with numerous sources that nearly universally label the DHS Funding shutdown as a Democrat shutdown while they fight for ICE reform as part of the deal. Regardless of WHY they are doing it, it is undeniable THAT it is the Democrats doing it. --- Don't try to blame Republicans when that is clearly false.
1b. It is the Legislative branch only that dictates this funding issue. I'm not smart enough to know what options the Executive or Judicial Branches have to go around Legislative on this issue, but it would be extremely limited, if at all possible. So that leave the Republican majority Legislative branch. But, guess what? There are only 53 Republicans in the Senate, and 60 votes are needed to pass this DHS funding bill, which therefor allows a minority of Democrats to be able to hold up the progress.
As an aside, and why I mentioned in my previous post the entire Senate and House should be gutted and rebuilt with all new members, I take great issue with the fact that our Democrats and Republicans are so polarized that they largely refuse to work together. I honestly don't see how this country survives another 100 years without some sort of Civil War or major event that brings the two sides back together. Living in extreme divisive viewpoints cannot endure forever.
2. thanks, I will review.
3. As noted in separate post above, I meant Department of Education, not Energy. --- A good example how different interpretations of reading the same thing is possible.
4. You referenced Trump firing Federal Employees as Illegal. None of that deals with "These large multinational trillion dollar companies laying ppl off aren't loosing money buddy". Apples and Oranges conversations. ... We agree that useless employees being fired is beneficial: I see the employees he fired as, largely, useless employees. If you disagree, then we can discuss why.
5. I'm not sure what this section is in reference to, as it relates to either your original post or my reply to you. I have no problem with providing services to American Citizens. The services you mentioned: Post office, Amtrak, defense spending, all good. There are many more services and programs that are absolutely necessary and/or beneficial that require funding. There are also numerous services and programs that are completely useless and by every single metric considered a waste of money. More of this on point 6 next.
6. I have no
misunderstanding of where federal monies go. I have a
problem with where it goes. Do a google search for "useless government programs" and tell me with a straight face we don't have a spending problem. Tell me honestly that you don't think that gutting government waste (which can be whatever programs and services you want to acknowledge as wasteful) would not be beneficial to reigning in our massive debt.
I would love for you and every other person who would describe "bloated programs and salaries and spending" as mere rounding errors to send me $100 in rounding error each month. I'll retire and have one hell of a hunting budget living off your cumulative ignorance.
7. "Democrats didnt bury this country in debt. Republicans did." --
Bullshit... Both Democrats and Republicans buried us in debt.
View attachment 755325
You want to use Clinton as your example of how its not Democrats fault? Fair enough. I agree from 1993-2000 were easily the "Best" years of minimizing debt growth. Let's add some context: in those years, the debt grew most, and grew every year, between 1993-1996, when democrats had controlled congress (both chambers) from '87-'94. It was split chambers in '95-96 at its high. Then it reduced from '98-2001 while Republicans controlled both houses for the end of Clinton's years and to start Bush Jr's term. One could make an argument from that factual data that it was the Republicans in house/senate that were responsible for the balanced budget.
I could also provide you a chart that shows the 2 most massive debt increases under a presidents tenure happened under Democrats FDR & Wilson (and also under democrat controlled congress both times). Both of these were over right around 790% debt growth. The next closest is Regan at 161% (split or Democrat controlled congress), then Bush Jr at 73% (split or Republican congress), and Barry at 64% (all 3 variations of congress). Those are the only Presidents that had a % debt change over 43% during their terms. *I do not have data for Trumps 2nd term (since he's in office!!!) yet. ---- If we do it by actual dollar amount, for quicker summary, we have Biden highest over $8.4T, Trump 45 at $7.8T, Barry $7.66T, Bush Jr $4.2T as your top 4 in dollars.
Data can be manipulated. I'm not making the argument that Republicans are not to blame for the deficit, but you absolutely cannot argue that Democrats "didn't do it."
8. See above. You see the data how you want to shape it to fit your narrative. I see it differently. neither of us will convince the other they are "wrong" - I will encourage you to at least see that it's not 100% or even anywhere close to a majority one way or the other; I very much have acknowledged that.
9. Nope, I repeat #7 & #8.
This will be my last reply, I've more than proven my points. Anything more is just wasting breath to say the same thing in a round. I see why
@mdwest bowed out a couple pages back. he also proved his points, numerous times, and this discussion has advanced as much as the Senate has on a DHS funding bill.