@bobdahunter84, so what is your synopsis of the 375 H&H you posted a link to....It website sates it is of 1952 manufacture. Is this considered a "particular" model ? Alaskan term began in 1959; was this a "big" or "dangerous game " model, a "safari" or any other particular model. The buttpad looks black, was it red on the original model of that year ? The rear sight looks "small and lacking"--is this original ?
Should the front sight be hooded ? would the receiver be factory drilled and taped ? Could this possibly be a rebarrel based on length and taper of the barrel ?
Sorry for a lot of questions but there are a lot of unknowns. Finally, what would be a fair price for that particular rifle ?
Thanks
I'm certainly no expert on the pre 64s, but I own 30 or so of them, so I've gained probably more knowledge than the average guy.
In terms of the name "Alaskan" it was really just a marketing ploy. They didn't change anything with the gun when they attached the name to it. In fact, the 338 Win Magnum was also called the "Alaskan" in their catalog.
They similarly gave the 264 Win Mag a name "The Westerner". If you notice a trend--most of the names were attached to new cartridges Winchester had developed. The 264 Win Mag (Westerner), 338 Win Mag (Alaskan), 458 Win Mag (African). Really only the 375 H&H is the odd choice to give a name to, because it was a non-propietary classic caliber that had been around.
Specific to that random gun I posted a link of. Definitely not an original butt pad. To your point, the original would have been red. And most 70s came with the steel/aluminum/plastic butt plate. But the 375 did have the red rubber pad. The aftermarket pad in of itself is not a big deal in my opinion. From a value perspective, the bigger deal is when someone cut the stock to keep the LOP the same if the new pad is thicker. Not sure LOP on this one.
That rear sight is a good question..while I recognize it may look non-original, I believe that was likely factory installed. That appears to be a Lyman 48 WJS Receiver Sight. That sight could be requested when ordering a standard grade rifle. The good about it--it's probably a $300+ sight today if you took it off and sold it. The downside is the receiver would have holes if you did that. Hence the reason MANY pre 64s have the holes in the receivers from the different Lyman and Pachmayr receiver sights of the day.
A gun of this vintage would definitely be drilled and tapped from the factory. Don't quotes me, but I believe that started around serial number 87,000 give or take.
I bet 50% of model 70s i bought had sight hood removed. You can buy the after market ones on eBay or Gunbroker for $20 that are really no different than the originals. They slide on easy enough. I'm 41 years old, so never had the opportunity to buy a pre 64 from the factory. My understanding was they all shipped with the hood, but they weren't attached at factory. So if buyer didn't put it on, it often got lost.
24" barrel is an offering from the factory, so I have no reason to believe it was cut.
In terms of price, this one is fair it appears. Not an amazing deal by any means. But not an outrageous price either. A 375 H&H isn't a super rare caliber. But it's also not a 30-06 or 270. The rarity certainly impacts the value. If someone was thinking of taking off that sight and getting a few hundred for that, they might find the net price more appealing.
I was at Wanenmacher this past weekend. 80% of the sellers had the "I don't really want to sell this, but if you give me too much, I might" price. I'd say Gunbroker and Guns International are more reasonable than the gun shows generally but still a good portion of overpriced guns. Tracking the penny auctions with no reserves is an excellent way to get a feel of what they're actually worth....
Sorry for the long post. I think I answered all of the questions.