Why are most ammo holders seen in Africa open top style?

I have a couple versions….elastic open top and bottom and leather with closed bottom.

IMG_0598.jpeg


All leather…..

IMG_0601.jpeg
 
What is the reason most ammo holders on the belt are open top instead of one with flap closure? Is this a legacy of double rifles needing quick access to more ammo that has just continued with more modern rifles holding 4 or more rounds? Is there a real functional purpose to avoid a flap closure on a belt mounted ammo pouch for use in Africa?
View attachment 650297
View attachment 650296
Good points all. I believe the decision is just a matter of personal choice and what works effectively for YOU.
Personally, I settled many years ago on what I consider the best of both worlds...security... and ready unhindered access.
My ammo pouch is the belt worn, suede, bi-fold variety. It is snapped closed 90% of the time, unsnapped and dropped open as circumstances dictate. No top flap to hinder access in critical moments.
Best
Spike

20241218_205955.jpg
20241218_210009.jpg
20241218_210039.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's interesting to see how long one can talk about a topic like this.

Ultimately it's a matter of taste because the difference between both types of ammo holders is small when it comes to reloading quickly. The cartridges certainly seem to be within easy reach in an open holder, but it could also be that the cartridges are clamped more firmly in the loops so as not to get lost than it were the case with a closed holder. A short soft flap over a holder is on the other side not an obstacle to a quick access to the cartridges. I have hunted with both types of holders over the years and have never noticed a clear advantage when reloading quickly. I tend to lean towards a closed ammo holder in Africa for the reasons I mentioned in previous posts.

Homemade holder for the cartridge 10,75x68. I used it two times in Africa.

IMG_0004 (1).jpeg
 

Forum statistics

Threads
58,919
Messages
1,273,612
Members
106,300
Latest member
Rattler1
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Preparing for the adventure of a lifetime. Looking forward to my 2026 Africa hunt with Van Wijk Safaris in South Africa.
Monster Free range Common Reedbuck!!
34d2250a-fe9a-4de4-af4b-2bb1fde9730a.jpeg
ef50535d-e9e2-4be7-9395-aa267be92102.jpeg
What a great way to kick off our 2025 hunting season in South Africa.

This beautiful Impala ram was taken at just over 300 yards, took a few steps and toppled over.

We are looking forward to the next week and a half of hunting with our first client of the year.
Handcannons wrote on Jaayunoo's profile.
Do you have any more copies of African Dangerous Game Cartridges, Author: Pierre van der Walt ? I'm looking for one. Thanks for any information, John [redacted]
 
Top