Ending Trophy Hunting Of Elephants: Is This A Conservation Success?

Royal27

AH ambassador
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
9,456
Reaction score
13,336
Media
109
Articles
5
Hunting reports
Africa
6
Member of
DSC, NRA, SCI
Hunted
USA - TX, CO, GA, ID. Africa - Zimbabwe, Zambia, and South Africa (Limpopo and EC)
Good read.

https://sciblogs.co.nz/chthonic-wil...rophy-hunting-elephants-conservation-success/

shutterstock_123350116.jpg



Ending Trophy Hunting of Elephants: Is this a Conservation Success?
By Brendan Moyle • 23/11/2017 • 2

Following a wave of popular outrage, the US government appears to be backtracking on the decision to allow the import elephant hunting trophies.

Nonetheless, despite the support of celebrities and Animal Rights groups like the HSUS, it is not obvious this will help conserve elephants. Sadly I don’t host popular talk shows or star in movies. I do research ivory black-markets though. And not by sitting in my office using Google. I do it by going to the places these black-markets operate. It’s not the safest way to do research (albeit in contrast to my colleagues’ perceptions, I don’t get shot at every time I go overseas). And it’s not the easiest. But it gets results. I’m informed enough to provide expert advice to organisations as varied as the World Bank, the Chinese SFA and the UN Office on Drugs and Crime. I don’t have a popular chat show though.

So let’s try another take on the whole trophy-hunting ban issue.

1 It’s a misnomer to describe it as a ban on trophy-hunting.
The US regulations allow for the imports of hunting trophies of endangered animals, if they meet an enhancement condition. That is, the hunting operation leads to net conservation benefits in the hunting area. The EU operates similar regulations. The US decided that in 2014 that Zimbabwe and Zambia did not meet the enhancement test. Trophy imports from other compliant range state continued. For instance, Namibia is a significant user of trophy-hunting and CITES import data, shows the US continuing to import elephant trophies from Namibia in this period.

Note that in 2015 the EU had already determined that Zambia and Zimbabwe did meet their version of the enhancement regulations. Since 2014, both Zambia and Zimbabwe have been working to become compliant again.

2 It wasn’t a decision by Trump
The US FWS were looking for these states to provide more population data, evidence of anti-poaching efforts and evidence that enough money from the trophy-hunts was being used for conservation. This was a process started during the Obama-administration and by 2017, the US FWS was in the same position as the EU. Elephant trophy-hunting was in the affected areas, a net conservation benefit.

Note that the decision is not made on what the elephant population is, in the entire country. Nor is it made on what the historical elephant population was. It is about the areas that elephant trophy-hunting occurs.

The cleverest PR move by the Animal Rights groups opposed to trophy-hunting, was linking this decision to Trump. Trump is a deeply unpopular president and by associating it with him, opposition to the FWS decision quickly grew. What this does is completely discount the work done by the affected African governments to meet the US conditions. It ignores the historical context.

3 Why we shouldn’t worry about Trophy Hunting
From a conservation perspective, trophy-hunting removes a very small number of elephants from the total population. The biggest losses of elephants are caused by habitat-loss, competition with live-stock, and poaching. Poaching removes 25-30,000 elephants a year. It’s harder to estimate losses from habitat-loss and live-stock competition, but the fact that elephants (like other wildlife) have disappeared much faster in East, Central and West African regions to the South, is significant. Elephants need the same pasture, the same grazing, the same water as cattle. And they need a lot of it. These northern regions have much higher population densities and human growth rates (Graph 1)


Graph 1: Human Population to 2050 via Nature.com
Most elephants in Africa are now located in the Southern Range states. Zimbabwe, with 83,000 elephants, has the second highest population in the Continent. Kenya in comparison has 23,000. Namibia has now overtaken Kenya in terms of elephants. It’s gone from 16,000 in the 2007 census to 25,000 in the 2016. In 2007 60% of Africa’s elephants were found in Botswana, Zimbabwe and Tanzania. (Heavy poaching in Tanzania has since affected that).

Human-Animal-Conflict (HAC) has a mortality rate of about 0.5%. That removes 2000 to 2500 elephants a year. HAC is basically what happens when aggressive elephants move into populated areas, damaging property, consuming crops and sometimes killing people.

Trophy hunting removes very little elephants. With elephants listed as endangered, most range states have set quotas for CITES purposes. Zimbabwe is 500, Zambia is 30. Note that this is an upper limit and is often not reached. Trophy-hunting isn’t a carte blanche operation involving thousands of elephants. It’s the least-consequential form of elephant loss there is.

So the things that keep me in a cold sweat about elephants and their conservation are poaching, and habitat loss/competition. Poaching is definitely getting a lot of attention, but its hard to be confident that habitat-loss is under control.

4 What are the risks of trophy hunting?
I’ve seen suggestions that trophy hunting could be used to smuggle poached ivory. This is ridiculous. The nature of ivory smuggling is that it is dominated by large shipments of raw tusks, hidden in containers, sent to East Asia. Asian criminal organisations aren’t going to be sending them in small shipments under permits cross-checked at either end, to the US, in the hope they can then be shipped to East Asia. Somehow. Because nobody in the US will be smart enough to compare the number of hunting trophies to the tiny quotas permitted. The link to poaching is inventive and unrealistic.

5 How does trophy hunting help conservation?
Well, it doesn’t always. It can be mismanaged. But it can help sometimes. I’ve already alluded to the increase in elephant populations in Namibia.

So how does hunting help?

The key is where hunting occurs. Many reserves are bordered by buffer areas where wildlife and humans mix. In some regions there are no reserves and the area is managed by the community. The basic model is that hunters do not go into the reserves, but these community areas where wildlife spills over into. It’s not easy getting elephants to stop moving at the edge of a nature reserve.

In these community areas, elephants suffer mortality for several reasons. They could get poached. They could be prevented from grazing or feeding in some areas (habitat loss). They could starve because the human livestock eats the pasture instead (competition). They could get shot by a trophy hunter. The population could also go up by elephants reproducing and migration. (One of the dilemmas for Zimbabwe is they’re too successful and while their reserves can sustain 40,000 elephants, they’ve overshot to 80,000+).

Anyway, trophy hunters pay the local community a lot of money (by their aspirations), even after leakage to corrupt officials. So this gives the locals a strong incentive to reduce mortality from the other sources. So if mortality from poaching and competition drops a lot after trophy hunting, elephant populations rise. This more than offsets the loss from trophies. For example, in the early days of the community-based conservation programme CAMPFIRE in Zimbabwe, it was reported farmers were removing cattle from the landscapes to have more elephants. It works the other way as well. If there is no trophy hunting, then mortality form these other source scan surge. In short, it’s complicated.

A lot of meat also goes to local communities also. About 340,000 kg of meat was returned to communal conservancies in 2016 Namibia alone.

6 Trophy Hunting is Icky
Well, I’m a vegetarian and I prefer taking photos to shooting stuff. But the goal is to have more elephants. And that seems to be something trophy hunting is helping with in some places. It’s not about making Westerners feel good, but conserving elephants on the ground.

7 Why not use Eco-tourism instead?
Because ecotourists stick to nature reserves. Reserves have high densities of wildlife and few humans, goats and cattle. Tourists want to see wildlife in their natural state. They don’t go to communal conservancies and buffer-areas as a rule. Wild animal populations are lower and there’s too many goats and cattle.

In the big picture, 30% of Africa’s elephants live in reserves. 70% range over landscapes shared by people. Elephant conservation cannot ignore that 70%. And if elephants are going to survive in that 70%, the decisions made by local communities matter. Because if they don’t want to share those landscapes with elephants, there’s very little we can do to stop them. Elephants will disappear incrementally, steadily and permanently. Having tools that persuade them that elephants are good to have around, and with revenue being an effective tool, then hunting is something to consider.

Summary
Sadly in the end, this looks like an animal rights decision masquerading as a conservation, and a charade that a scientific decision was really a political decision by an unpopular President. It is getting hard to be optimistic about elephant conservation. Human population growth is on track to reduce elephant numbers in almost all range states, bar the south. Poaching is still not under control. The very high numbers in the Southern Region are likely due for a correction because of the sheer density. Zimbabwe estimated their reserves could cope with about 40,000 elephants back in the early 1990s. They have 80,000+. We look to have a serious ecological overshoot problem.
 

Attachments

  • human-population-projection.png
    human-population-projection.png
    154 KB · Views: 162
Last edited by a moderator:

Royal27

AH ambassador
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
9,456
Reaction score
13,336
Media
109
Articles
5
Hunting reports
Africa
6
Member of
DSC, NRA, SCI
Hunted
USA - TX, CO, GA, ID. Africa - Zimbabwe, Zambia, and South Africa (Limpopo and EC)
Thanks royal
Finally someone with intelligence and facts as opposed to someone with a mouth full of pablum and full diapers cheers

And did you notice he's a vegetarian? Says even more to me just because of that.
 

rinehart0050

Gold supporter
AH legend
Joined
May 24, 2015
Messages
2,249
Reaction score
2,195
Media
300
Articles
6
Hunting reports
Africa
2
USA/Canada
1
Australia/NZ
2
Hunted
New Zealand, South Africa (NWP, Limpopo, Eastern Cape); USA (NE, NC, MD, AZ, TX)
Great article. If people made decisions lb facts alone, the right decision is clear. Unfortunate, most let emotion govern thier opinions and cloud thier judgement.
 

Tom Hawk

AH enthusiast
Joined
Sep 23, 2017
Messages
274
Reaction score
234
Articles
1
Too many undereducated people. Research before you speak.
 

cbvanb

AH veteran
Joined
Apr 19, 2010
Messages
101
Reaction score
130
Media
6
Hunted
South Africa, Zambia, Zimbabwe, Canada
As someone pointed out in an earlier discussion regarding this issue, the ban only affects trophy imports, not hunting. We can still hunt elephants all we want, and the reality is the ban tends to drive down prices dramatically. So there is some benefit if the ban continues.

There is always the option of taking castings of your ivory, and you still own the trophies. Some enterprising outfitter needs to find a way to store trophies for hunters in the event the fools in America wake up one day and realize the damage they have done to all African animal populations, as elephants are now impacting many other species.

I would personally like to be able to import one trophy from Zimbabwe, where I have hunted elephants, and been hunted by elephants off and on over the past 25 years. Circumstances in the past were such that I was unable to bring anything home, and it’s the one species for which I have nothing to show, save a few elephant hair bracelets. It may be that ship has sailed, but that may also put elephant hunting back into the realm of possibility for me.
 

IdaRam

AH legend
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
2,059
Reaction score
3,591
Location
Idaho
Media
194
Hunting reports
Africa
2
USA/Canada
1
Member of
NRA Life Member, NAHC Life Member, SCI, DSC, Wild Sheep Foundation, NSSF
Hunted
Idaho, Montana, Utah, Wyoming, California, Alberta Canada, South Africa, Zimbabwe
Some enterprising outfitter needs to find a way to store trophies for hunters in the event the fools in America wake up one day and realize the damage they have done to all African animal populations, as elephants are now impacting many other species.
Not just America, Canada and Europe have their share as well ;) But yes, between the ARA’s and politicians, animals of many species have some serious challenges in their future. Ecosystems must be managed, not just individual animal species.
 

Tom Hawk

AH enthusiast
Joined
Sep 23, 2017
Messages
274
Reaction score
234
Articles
1
I’ll give every hippie a sheep. What’s that? You don’t like coyotes? Kill them all?:DOK! A dollar each!
 

J.Ogilvie

AH member
Joined
Mar 2, 2016
Messages
15
Reaction score
12
Location
Australia
This really is a great article! The author deserves some serious praise for being truthful and sticking to the facts.
 

50lawman

Bronze supporter
AH member
Joined
Oct 30, 2011
Messages
48
Reaction score
39
Location
Honolulu, Hawaii
Media
9
Member of
SCI/ North American Hunt CLub
Hunted
Namibia
My world is roiling in confusion right now. I did notice that Royal27 (or was it someone else) declared that he is a vegetarian. He can't be both! A vegetarian (Indian word for bad hunter) and he has still hunted all over the world. I guess I will have to accept that fact. Man there are a lot of interesting, intelligent, compassionate, and humble people on this site. I think I'll stay.
 

Hank2211

Gold supporter
AH legend
Joined
Jan 12, 2010
Messages
2,900
Reaction score
6,492
Media
141
Articles
3
Hunting reports
Africa
10
Member of
SCI, DU, Pheasants Forever
Hunted
Canada, United States, Zimbabwe, South Africa (Eastern Cape; Northern Cape; North West Province, Natal, Mpumalanga, Limpopo), Namibia, Cameroon, Benin, Ethiopia, Argentina
Not just America, Canada and Europe have their share as well ;) But yes, between the ARA’s and politicians, animals of many species have some serious challenges in their future. Ecosystems must be managed, not just individual animal species.
Not sure what you mean @IdaRam. Canada follows CITES when it comes to hunting, and doesn’t add any particular view of its own as to what should be allowed or not.

Elephant are Appendix 2 for most Southern Africa populations, including those in respect of which the US has a problem. So long as you have a CITES quota and an export permit, elephant trophies are allowed to be imported without compliance with any additional local measures. If you hunt an Appendix 1 population, you will need an import permit, but so long as, again, you have an export permit and CITES permit, the import permit will be issued.

If you meant share of irrational anti-hunters, well, agree with you there.
 

IdaRam

AH legend
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
2,059
Reaction score
3,591
Location
Idaho
Media
194
Hunting reports
Africa
2
USA/Canada
1
Member of
NRA Life Member, NAHC Life Member, SCI, DSC, Wild Sheep Foundation, NSSF
Hunted
Idaho, Montana, Utah, Wyoming, California, Alberta Canada, South Africa, Zimbabwe
Not sure what you mean @IdaRam. Canada follows CITES when it comes to hunting, and doesn’t add any particular view of its own as to what should be allowed or not.

Elephant are Appendix 2 for most Southern Africa populations, including those in respect of which the US has a problem. So long as you have a CITES quota and an export permit, elephant trophies are allowed to be imported without compliance with any additional local measures. If you hunt an Appendix 1 population, you will need an import permit, but so long as, again, you have an export permit and CITES permit, the import permit will be issued.

If you meant share of irrational anti-hunters, well, agree with you there.
Hi Hank,
As I re-read my post it is clear that I wasn’t very... well, clear :D
My comment was intended to say that America doesn’t have a corner on the market when it comes to fools. Plenty of idiots across the globe whose actions are doing no favors to animal populations and are in fact doing just the opposite.
Although, in re-reading the post by cbvanb, it is unclear if he was referring to americans in general or to America and our lack of willingness to accept CITES at face value.
in the event the fools in America wake up one day and realize the damage they have done to all African animal populations, as elephants are now impacting many other species.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
36,196
Messages
681,822
Members
62,392
Latest member
BourbonTrail
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Rickmt wrote on Justbryan's profile.
What is your new shorter rifle? Thanx Bryan !
raamw wrote on neckdeep's profile.
Supply your address so I can get shipping Paypal Friend (no ) fee) is fine
Viral_SIGness wrote on Rifle57's profile.
Great person to deal with. Fast communication and quick shipper!
Sarg wrote on Philippe's profile.
Hello Philippe, did you get my PM that I sent you earlier ?

Regards Mark
raamw wrote on AfricaHunting.com's profile.
Can you advise me to properly post pix, sometimes I get it right sometimes not
 
Top