Auction Find. Colt Army 1917 45ACP revolver

Jcordell

AH member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
35
Reaction score
82
Location
Idaho
Media
6
Member of
National Rifleman Association, DAV
So I went to an estate auction today. The gentleman who passed was a serious gun collector. All of the pieces were in fantastic condition. There were three revolvers that I was interested in. A New York State police S&W Model 520. A Colt Army Model 1917 and a S&W Model 65 with a 3" barrel. First up was the Model 520. My pain threshold was $600.00. It sold for $875.00. Next up was the Model 1917. I expected it to also go soaring pass my cut-off. But ,as I listened to the bidding, I was surprised at how sluggish it was. The auctioneer eventually dropped it down to $200.00 before anyone started to bid. Well I jumped in and won with a bid of $550.00. Now figure in the Buyer's Premium (10%) and the Idaho Sales Tax (6%) and the final figure was $641.30, but I'm satisfied with that price. Very clean and mechanically it's in excellent condition. Serial number is 304*** . Seems appropriate with it being the 100th anniversary of World War I. The revolver is massive. It weighs 40 ounces unloaded, but considering it was made under wartime conditions and demands the workmanship is excellent. I almost skipped this auction. I was certain that I would be outbid. Guess the old adage about "Nothing ventured is nothing gained" is true at times.






 

Attachments

  • 1917A6_zps3vxswiwq.jpg
    1917A6_zps3vxswiwq.jpg
    261.2 KB · Views: 386
  • 1917A2_zpsj2fdzap8.jpg
    1917A2_zpsj2fdzap8.jpg
    291.2 KB · Views: 307
  • 1917A7_zpsban8heqx.jpg
    1917A7_zpsban8heqx.jpg
    111.4 KB · Views: 324
  • 1917A4_zpslvn3z53c.jpg
    1917A4_zpslvn3z53c.jpg
    200 KB · Views: 308
  • 1917A1_zpskt2kemhe.jpg
    1917A1_zpskt2kemhe.jpg
    253.2 KB · Views: 283
  • 1917A5_zpsztpc65it.jpg
    1917A5_zpsztpc65it.jpg
    190.7 KB · Views: 288
Last edited by a moderator:
Love the Classics
 
What a great find.
 
if that is the original blue (and the markings seem very crisp), then you made a steal. Congrats on a great handgun. Now you need some half or full moon clips to get her up and running. And when it comes to auctions, sales or shops - great guns are where you find them.
 
Gorgeous, still shoot mine with mild target loads to keep the dust off. Still have some original half-moon clips that I am using for my S&W625 JM. Mine was still accurate with the 230 gr lead ball ammunition out to 75 yds on an 8 inch target, pretty neat actually. Nice find and enjoy!
 
Going to get out to the range this Tuesday. Let you know.
 
Great gun in a fantastic condition, congrats !
 
My wife's favorite is a S&W 1917 Brazilian (2nd contract) manufactured (if I recall correctly) late 1930's. Great shooter, quite accurate and happily devours 230gn ball.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
64,310
Messages
1,416,107
Members
129,788
Latest member
sunwinroyal
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

wheelerdan wrote on Jager Waffen74's profile.
Sir, I think I have been writing to you about the purchase of the HK 639 rifle under an email "Tt Jake." If this is you, then I am truly interested. I am just trying to verify identify. Tt Jake is asking for a cash transaction. No disrespect intended, Just trying to verify who I am talking to. Thank you. Respectfully. Dan
Gary C wrote on HuntingFreak's profile.
Hey my friend, I am returning to SA for a Cape Buffalo hunt in June 26. My outfitter has suggested Highveld but I have read some poor reports. Wondering how satisfied you were with your mounts from them? Thanks in advance.
Finally back to somewhat normal I missed reading the messages and posts
Remember I will be at the ISE show in Denver Colorado for 8-12 January, and after the show I will be available for meetings anywhere in the USA I will traveling around to meet with old and new clients, let me know and we will set up a meeting!
Beautiful Aardwolf for our Spanish client and good friend Alberto
WhatsApp Image 2025-11-12 at 17.27.22 (2).jpeg
 
Top