I once had a table at a very large gun show, and a few tables down was an M1941 Johnson rifle in original status and at least 90% condition. I'd always wanted one for my battle rifle collection. Price was $3100 (this was 20+ years ago). I agreed to that, and asked him to hold it for 30 minutes while I collected the cash from a transaction in another building. He agreed, and off I went.
I returned in about 20 minutes (i.e., I wasn't late) with the $3100 cash, only to see a guy shelling out money for the Johnson. "
Hold on there, he was holding that rifle for me!" I exclaimed. The seller replied, "
Well, this guy offered me $100 more, and you weren't back yet." (The interloping buyer feigned a "
I don't want to get in the middle of your deal ", but that's exactly what he did by having offered the seller a $100 premium over tag price.) The seller nonetheless sold the Johnson to him for $3200 right in front of me.
I made a big damned stink about it, right there. "
So, that's the price of your honor, $100? And in front of your son? Training him to be a deal breaking scumbag like his father? " He wouldn't budge. So, for the rest of that Saturday afternoon, whenever I walked past him I muttered imprecations with a quiet rage I hadn't felt in years. I think it spooked him because he packed up that night and didn't exhibit his two tables on Sunday.
Sunday, I'm still 92.61% as pissed as I was the day before. I'm walking around, still stewing. Well, in another building was a table, and on it was that same M1941 Johnson! And the same guy who'd sniped it from me was behind the table. By then yesterday's drama was pretty well known throughout the show, and the buyer had learned who I was as the author of "
Boston's Gun Bible" (which was very popular back then). I think folks had given him some mild hell behind the scenes, as he confessed to feeling bad about it all. Although he didn't sell the Johnson to me at his cost, I did manage to buy it for a price tag I'd have still paid the day before. I hated to pay him
any premium, but I did go home with the rifle.
Somebody later tried to lecture me about the business rule of Offer/Acceptance/Consideration, and how I'd missed out on the rifle because I didn't put down a deposit. I replied that the seller didn't ask for one to hold it for a half-hour, and two, a scumbag like that seller would have reneged on a deposit as well, while an honorable seller would have kept his Acceptance word without a deposit (I have done exactly that many times at shows as a seller).
MORAL: I more regularly pay a deposit and get a receipt for ____ item at $___ price being held until _____. While it won't protect you from the worst of welshers, but it's something in a world that rarely honors handshake deals any more.
Regarding this thread's incident, I think the seller should have
at once posted SPF, and the AH rules specifically ask one to do so. Also, I think he should have more clearly communicated with
@buckstix (either publicly, or in DMs). His "
Sorry, selling as a package" reply (two hours
after the early buyer's DM) to thread questions implied that the goods were still available. Regarding
@buckstix's level of expressed disappointment, I can easily empathize with him given my Johnson rifle story.
@tblom is a newer member than
@buckstix, and as far as I can tell uses AH only to sell stuff. He would be wise to refine his technique here.
A forum SPF post is similar to Offer/Acceptance while waiting on Consideration. It's a form of handshake deal, and we all should try to protect that here. Timely and clear communication is vital to avoid misunderstandings and hard feelings.