Mnwhiskeyman
New member
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2025
- Messages
- 4
- Reaction score
- 10
If this thread is still going I am dying for one in 7x57 mauser
Ruger is the only American company who could take a clean sheet of paper and make
a working man's double rifle for nitro express cartridges. I would love to see than!
Ruger .44 Magnum semi auto carbine. I emailed them awhile ago and was told they have no plans on producing them. Too bad.
I thought this thread had died out a couple of months ago but I see that it has been brought back to life again. If you go back to my original post that started this discussion, you'll notice that it was more about consensus building than rifle building. While a semi-custom or special edition rifle may have been the final result, the majority of the respondents ignored the most critical factor: 49+ other people have to like your choice.
So the question being asked was "What rifle in what chambering would you buy that you think a large group of like-minded hunters would also think is desirable?". The question most people answered was "Here's the custom rifle I want". And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. It's a totally legitimate response that I appreciated because it gave me a good idea of how hard it is to get people to agree on something like this. I'd like to thank @spike.t for popping in on a regular basis to mock the futility of this endeavor to keep me humble. He wasn't wrong. We couldn't hit the halfway point on the minimum possible order.
Basically it was going to be a real challenge to get Ruger to just put a specific barrel on an existing action. But I think the only thing that wasn't requested was a "phased plasma rifle in the 40-watt range".
If you specified something with a COL over 87mm, not going to happen. If you suggested a rifle that is no longer produced, same thing. If there's zero brass for it or it's only available for reloaders, another tough sell. I don't think Ruger is going to retool their production line to make a different receiver for a dozen rifles. I am pleased that most of you suggested some good classics. Not a Creedmoor to be found.
View attachment 716342
I agree with the top choices. Especially the .300 H&H in the No. 1!!!!!Thank you Odonata
I saw this thread and just had to get it going again. It looks like we are getting past 20 on at least one of them. I am hoping we can get this moving forward because it would be a dream rifle for me to own
Thanks again
Some of the responses on this thread should have been posted on the “on a lighter note” thread.I thought this thread had died out a couple of months ago but I see that it has been brought back to life again. If you go back to my original post that started this discussion, you'll notice that it was more about consensus building than rifle building. While a semi-custom or special edition rifle may have been the final result, the majority of the respondents ignored the most critical factor: 49+ other people have to like your choice.
So the question being asked was "What rifle in what chambering would you buy that you think a large group of like-minded hunters would also think is desirable?". The question most people answered was "Here's the custom rifle I want". And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. It's a totally legitimate response that I appreciated because it gave me a good idea of how hard it is to get people to agree on something like this. I'd like to thank @spike.t for popping in on a regular basis to mock the futility of this endeavor to keep me humble. He wasn't wrong. We couldn't hit the halfway point on the minimum possible order.
Basically it was going to be a real challenge to get Ruger to just put a specific barrel on an existing action. But I think the only thing that wasn't requested was a "phased plasma rifle in the 40-watt range".
If you specified something with a COL over 87mm, not going to happen. If you suggested a rifle that is no longer produced, same thing. If there's zero brass for it or it's only available for reloaders, another tough sell. I don't think Ruger is going to retool their production line to make a different receiver for a dozen rifles. I am pleased that most of you suggested some good classics. Not a Creedmoor to be found.
View attachment 716342