S&W Model 19

“The 19 was known to shoot loose with a steady diet of full house loads too, not just the Python. Its what led to the L frame Smiths.”


Yes sir, here is my 586 L frame. Made with a heavier frame. It’s not as pristine as the one listed for sale Mine has been carried and shot
IMG_1988.jpeg
 
“The 19 was known to shoot loose with a steady diet of full house loads too, not just the Python. Its what led to the L frame Smiths.”


Yes sir, here is my 586 L frame. Made with a heavier frame. It’s not as pristine as the one listed for sale Mine has been carried and shot View attachment 563780
I always wanted one of those, but never did. Have owned a few model 27's and larger cal N frames. My main .357 in fact only .357 currently is a Colt Border Patrol, just a MkIII Trooper with a matte finish and Border Patrol stamped on the barrel, great shooter.
IMG_0628.JPG
 
The 19 was known to shoot loose with a steady diet of full house loads too, not just the Python. Its what led to the L frame Smiths.
Yes and mentioned that in my post, Magnum loads put more stress/wear on revolvers then standard loads and Python was a little more sensitive to magnums then the S&W 19. Smith introduced the 586/686 to better withstand magnum loads but even it (along with very sturdy/clunky Ruger
 
“The 19 was known to shoot loose with a steady diet of full house loads too, not just the Python. Its what led to the L frame Smiths.”


Yes sir, here is my 586 L frame. Made with a heavier frame. It’s not as pristine as the one listed for sale Mine has been carried and shot View attachment 563780
Yes and mentioned that in my post, Magnum loads put more stress/wear on revolvers then standard loads and Python was a little more sensitive to magnums then the S&W 19. Smith introduced the 586/686 to better withstand magnum loads but even it (along with very sturdy/clunky Ruger
Sorry ——hit send too soo....: “but even the 586 will hold up better with a steady diet of .38 specials then hot .357’s. Perhaps the very sturdy/Clunky Ruger can handle a long steady feeding of magnums but Ruger is rarely considered in the same class as the older S&Ws or Colt Python, not to imply that Ruger is not a functional durable revolver. There is more to a fine, well crafted revolver then brute strength - at least in my opinion. The Colt Python followed closely by some of the early S&Ws were exceptionally well made revolvers and finely crafted - to the point that they can no longer afford to be made to that level of fit & finish. They may still function & shoot as well but the “extras” that made them special are no longer.
 
I was obsessed with handguns for many years, with wheel guns being my favorites. I had the honor of meeting and talking to Skeeter Skelton, Bill Jordan and Elmer Keith when I was a kid and that just helped put my passion for handguns in overdrive at a very young age.

In my experiences with wheel guns, most will eventually "shoot loose" via lots of shooting of full power loads. Fortunately, most people will never shoot one enough to know. I have put thousands upon thousands of rounds through revolvers. Some of my favorites being S&W Models 13, 19, 24, 27, 28, 29 and 625, Colt's SAA and Ruger 3 screw Blackhawks. If I recall correctly, Elmer Keith only fired 600 or so rounds his first year with the M29. When I was shooting handguns regularly, I would put 500+ rounds through one (or more) of my revolvers in a weekend.

I have sent S&W Models 13, 19 and 29 and a few Ruger Old Models back for rebuild. That was after shooting a LOT of ammo. I mostly burned Unique and 2400 pushing Keith profile cast bullets. I never "shot loose" any S&W Models 24, 27, 28 or 625. I considered a revolver "shot loose" when it was out of timing or begins to malfunction. My favorite 4" M29-1 was rebuilt 3 times.

I will never shoot like that again in my life, so the revolvers I currently carry will never be put to those extremes.

Of all the revolvers I have ever owned, my favorite ones to carry will always be S&W M29 4', Colt's SAA .45 colt 4 5/8", and a Ruger Old Model 4 5/8" .357 that Jim Stroh converted to .44 special for me (thank you, Skeeter) and of course, S&W M19 4" such as was listed and sold here. It is one of the best of the best. No need to pound them to submission with full power loads. The gun and your hands will appreciate it. :D

Safe shooting
 
I’ve tried to love revolvers… owned several over the years… but for whatever reason just never could get past the friend zone with them lol…

Got closest with a S&W 686 with a 4” bbl… that thing shot freaking incredible groups and was silky smooth…

But still not much more than a good friend :)
 
I was obsessed with handguns for many years, with wheel guns being my favorites. I had the honor of meeting and talking to Skeeter Skelton, Bill Jordan and Elmer Keith when I was a kid and that just helped put my passion for handguns in overdrive at a very young age.

In my experiences with wheel guns, most will eventually "shoot loose" via lots of shooting of full power loads. Fortunately, most people will never shoot one enough to know. I have put thousands upon thousands of rounds through revolvers. Some of my favorites being S&W Models 13, 19, 24, 27, 28, 29 and 625, Colt's SAA and Ruger 3 screw Blackhawks. If I recall correctly, Elmer Keith only fired 600 or so rounds his first year with the M29. When I was shooting handguns regularly, I would put 500+ rounds through one (or more) of my revolvers in a weekend.

I have sent S&W Models 13, 19 and 29 and a few Ruger Old Models back for rebuild. That was after shooting a LOT of ammo. I mostly burned Unique and 2400 pushing Keith profile cast bullets. I never "shot loose" any S&W Models 24, 27, 28 or 625. I considered a revolver "shot loose" when it was out of timing or begins to malfunction. My favorite 4" M29-1 was rebuilt 3 times.

I will never shoot like that again in my life, so the revolvers I currently carry will never be put to those extremes.

Of all the revolvers I have ever owned, my favorite ones to carry will always be S&W M29 4', Colt's SAA .45 colt 4 5/8", and a Ruger Old Model 4 5/8" .357 that Jim Stroh converted to .44 special for me (thank you, Skeeter) and of course, S&W M19 4" such as was listed and sold here. It is one of the best of the best. No need to pound them to submission with full power loads. The gun and your hands will appreciate it. :D

Safe shooting
I bet you would like this one then. S&W 26-1 .45 Colt Georgia State Patrol
IMG_4506.JPG
 
fullsizeoutput_8ab.jpeg

Un Fired Mod 29,
 
Last edited:
Known as the Dirty Harry all Mod 29s were 44mag
I believe only the 6.5” barrel was the Dirty Harry model and commands a higher value
 
I believe only the 6.5” barrel was the Dirty Harry model and commands a higher value
For most of the film the 6.5" barrel model was used but I've read that for some shots where emphasis was given to the gun, generally pointed in the direction of the camera, a model with 8 3/8" barrel was used. Too bad the armorer was around for some newer movies.
 
For most of the film the 6.5" barrel model was used but I've read that for some shots where emphasis was given to the gun, generally pointed in the direction of the camera, a model with 8 3/8" barrel was used. Too bad the armorer was around for some newer movies.
RAY B that’s very interesting and I didn’t know that, certainly can confuse the “collector” criteria. You either know movies, revolvers, or both? As for the S&W model 29s - I like them all - with the exception of the 8 3/8” barrels.
I purchased mine NIB unfired about 10 years ago - guy bought it in the 1970s and told how he paid “double” list price because of how popular they were after the movie came out - I think list price in 1974 was around $240 and he paid $475....it was a lucky find for me.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
62,204
Messages
1,366,130
Members
118,896
Latest member
AlanEdgew
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

FDP wrote on dchuntley56's profile.
I have a 30-06 that is fluted and has sights. Shot very little & I have it listed on gb, Derek
NEW ZEALAND SAFARIS wrote on Djei5's profile.
Afternoon I just received a message but cannot find the text sorry, how can I help?
csmith wrote on 19_A_CPT's profile.
Not sure your price range. Have a 375 H&H with a muzzle brake. Nice rifle only fired a few times. Also a Mossberg 375 Ruger its been used and shows a few hunts on it.
Two African Safaris Hunted South Africa both times,
9 game animals taken
Has anybody hunted with Phumba safari in steenbokpan south Africa?
 
Top