I would say they are both fine rams and decent trophies. The first one has more mass, more backward sweep and worn down tips and he is older than the second. A fine trophy indeed.
The second is also a mature ram, with hard bases, not so much mass, less backward sweep but longer not worn down tips yet, he ain't getting any longer than he is. Also a fine trophy.
Estimating inches from photos especially with animals that have backward sweep is not something I do and is not easily done it would merely be a quess. In order to accurately judge them one needs to see the horns from different angles. As for these two, the right decision was made to shoot them both are fine trophies.
All the best.