Guys, I started this thread to share thoughts and learn—not to referee a cage match over who’s “right.” Plenty of good points on all sides; let’s keep it useful and civil.
I think there has been quite a bit of qualified, data driven, factual information provided in this thread..
a guy with 25 years of law enforcement experience with a major west coast agency that spent much of his career in investigations has advised that in his entire career he is aware of exactly 1 residential safe attacked with tools (Im going to guess that single case involves very specific circumstances.. like it was a high net worth family or high value house.. or there was gang involvement.. and that it is very likely that there was "inside" information, such as a house keeper married to a gang member that knows that a) a safe is in the house and b) the safe contains expensive jewlery, etc).. ..
another guy with 10 years of law enforcement experience with a major southern agency in what most consider to be the worst crime city in the south and just under 40 years of experience in security consulting and management (me) has offered that for a middle income american, the need for a professional grade safe is statistically not present. For what its worth in my just under 40 years Im unaware of ANY middle income family safes ever being attacked by tools or by pros.
the username of yet another guy with 30+ years of experience in law enforcement in the 3rd largest city in the US, who spent almost his entire career in investigations, much of that in a senior leadership role was provided to ask his opinion. He's now in private security (not polyester suit wearing guards, but higher profile security and investigations) to ask his opinion...
Further information has been provided in several posts about what criminals do, how they do it, who they target, how they target, etc by people that actually work in criminal investigations.. Additional information has been provided about how to properly secure your possessions and household if you are truly interested in security of those items that goes well beyond what safe you purchase..
youre original question was a simple one: "Looking for a standing gun safe that will not break the bank and not too big or bulky. Good for couple of rifles and handguns and few more extras"
Outside of red herring nonsense being thrown out over and over again to argue invalid points about the value of professional grade safes (ie middle income americans dont own $50K rifles typically... commercial burglaries are not the same thing as residential burglaries.. police agencies do not make burgarlies a low priority (FWIW burglary is an FBI index crime.. hundreds of millions of federal dollars get distributed to city, county, and state police agencies based on their management of index crimes.. with that sort of money on the table, I can assure you, burglaries are taken very seriously and are very high priority for the overwhelming majority of police agencies), etc..etc.. theres been a good bit of very valuable information provided..
the question is... in looking for the answer to YOUR question.. do you want to listen to industry professionals that bring decades upon decades on hands on experience offering fact based information?
Or do you want to listen to someone thats been asked 3 times what their experience is, hasnt answered, and now acknowledges they merely offer opinion (that clearly isnt substantiated in training, experience, or education)? Who also from what I can tell, doesnt own and has not owned a pro grade safe that he seems to advocate for (the question has been asked.. but also has gone unanswered)..