Politics

Interesting that you get taxed on primary residence capital gains in America. Here in communist Canada, all you have to do is live there for six months and any profit is tax free. Don’t worry though, we also have a housing shortage
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLD
I agree with you. But you can also argue that the step up basis creates the incentive. If it was eliminated the tax impact would be the same selling now or later. There is a policy argument to both reduce the CG rate and eliminate the step up basis.

If they end the step-up in basis, then my home never gets sold. It's already in a Trust and I'd like if the kids could enjoy it long after I'm gone, but with the step-up they can sell it. Without a step-up in basis, it will live eternally in the trust across many generations as the ownership will never change. I think a Trust is valid for 200-500 years, longer than most cultures.
 
If they end the step-up in basis, then my home never gets sold. It's already in a Trust and I'd like if the kids could enjoy it long after I'm gone, but with the step-up they can sell it. Without a step-up in basis, it will live eternally in the trust across many generations as the ownership will never change. I think a Trust is valid for 200-500 years, longer than most cultures.
That's one possibility. But some kids (including yours) might want to sell the home and pay the tax so that they can use the money elsewhere. Or fund the purchase of a home in a different area.

My point is that all tax provisions are interrelated. Any tax is a disincentive to certain activities. The goal should be the make the tax code as agnostic as possible so that it doesn't change behavior. I agree that the current code is encouraging baby boomers to not sell right now.
 
Tax behavior drives a lot of this from a long term perspective but every homeowner who refinanced at 3% isnt going to easily give that up, so until the 10 year comes down, there is going to be a shortage.

And as mentioned many homes doubled in price so no one is doubling their interest rate and then taking a tax hit on top of it.
 
It’s disappointing that the Secretary of Defense does not know you’re not supposed to talk, let alone laugh and have a raucous conversation there at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier.

Hegseth put that sentinal in a really shitty position.. I am 100% certain the sentinal knew exactly who he was going to have to call out before he did it.. its not like Hegseth isnt name/face recognizeable to pretty much everyone in the US... not to mention his photograph is in every HQ in the DoD...

Im glad the sentinal had the balls to step up and do what was obviously the right thing and hold the SECDEF to the exact same standard that everyone else is held to.. That couldnt have been an easy moment for him.. Hopefully everyone at the 3rd Infantry Regiment hoisted a toast to that guy later that night and have commended him for his actions and no politically driven SNCO or O tries to overtly or covertly take him to task over it..
 
Tax behavior drives a lot of this from a long term perspective but every homeowner who refinanced at 3% isnt going to easily give that up, so until the 10 year comes down, there is going to be a shortage.

And as mentioned many homes doubled in price so no one is doubling their interest rate and then taking a tax hit on top of it.

Thats actually the quandry Im in right now... I bought the home Im in right now at about 4%.. The value has gone up significantly and I have a ton of equity in the house.. but.. with rates hovering around 6% right now, I'd actually pay more for a lessor valued home if I were to sell and move..

My wife and I are very interested in picking up a house and some acrege and starting the transition to a home we would want to retire in.. but rates are going to be a big driver determining when Im willing to stroke a check and close on something..
 
Thats actually the quandry Im in right now... I bought the home Im in right now at about 4%.. The value has gone up significantly and I have a ton of equity in the house.. but.. with rates hovering around 6% right now, I'd actually pay more for a lessor valued home if I were to sell and move..

My wife and I are very interested in picking up a house and some acrege and starting the transition to a home we would want to retire in.. but rates are going to be a big driver determining when Im willing to stroke a check and close on something..
I've had this conversation with my financial advisor multiple times. He's a friend who is also in a similar situation to me. We love our neighborhood but the house doesn't fully suit our current needs. At some point we want to either move, or are actually considering tearing our house down and building a new one. I bought the house in 2006 and have a ton of equity. I refinanced when I had to during a divorce and am sitting on a 3.25% rate.

Ultimately, his advice was rates are not going to come down to the level I'm currently at any time in the next few years. We just have to change our thinking about what is realistic and accept we will pay a higher rate. We can afford to do so even if we don't like it. But at the end of the day do you want to be happy with the house you live in and where you live or not. He's a good financial advisor and has helped me do well with my money, but what I like best is that he always reminds me that every decision doesn't have to be about the maximum savings or return, you have to live your life and enjoy it too.
 
Thats actually the quandry Im in right now... I bought the home Im in right now at about 4%.. The value has gone up significantly and I have a ton of equity in the house.. but.. with rates hovering around 6% right now, I'd actually pay more for a lessor valued home if I were to sell and move..

My wife and I are very interested in picking up a house and some acrege and starting the transition to a home we would want to retire in.. but rates are going to be a big driver determining when Im willing to stroke a check and close on something..
Financial responsibility is important, but sometimes you have to say eff it and get what you want. Especially when looking at something that is going to be your next forever home. Give the misses what she wants, and enjoy the view over your nice quiet property, interest rates be damned. The best part of money is the fact that you can always make more of it.
 
I've had this conversation with my financial advisor multiple times. He's a friend who is also in a similar situation to me. We love our neighborhood but the house doesn't fully suit our current needs. At some point we want to either move, or are actually considering tearing our house down and building a new one. I bought the house in 2006 and have a ton of equity. I refinanced when I had to during a divorce and am sitting on a 3.25% rate.

Ultimately, his advice was rates are not going to come down to the level I'm currently at any time in the next few years. We just have to change our thinking about what is realistic and accept we will pay a higher rate. We can afford to do so even if we don't like it. But at the end of the day do you want to be happy with the house you live in and where you live or not. He's a good financial advisor and has helped me do well with my money, but what I like best is that he always reminds me that every decision doesn't have to be about the maximum savings or return, you have to live your life and enjoy it too.
6% is also a hell of a lot lower rate than a solid chunk of our membership bought their first homes at. I’m glad I’m young and bought my first house in 2008 at 1.6%, as opposed to 14% in the 80’s.
 
I have read that there is an increase in land contracts due to high interest rates and capital gains.

Seller sets the interest rate. The Government mandates that it is higher than 0%.

The realized gains are spread out over years.

Of course there are pitfalls. And it won’t work for everyone.
 
Financial responsibility is important, but sometimes you have to say eff it and get what you want. Especially when looking at something that is going to be your next forever home. Give the misses what she wants, and enjoy the view over your nice quiet property, interest rates be damned. The best part of money is the fact that you can always make more of it.
That's what we are doing. Going to due a complete teardown and rebuild and have a "game" room and larger garage added. I had the architect make sure every door and bathroom was wheelchair accessible, just in case I end up in one. I don't want to move again. The next house should be the funeral home.
 
That's what we are doing. Going to due a complete teardown and rebuild and have a "game" room and larger garage added. I had the architect make sure every door and bathroom was wheelchair accessible, just in case I end up in one. I don't want to move again. The next house should be the funeral home.
A single story? Don’t forget an elevator if not.
 
Hegseth put that sentinal in a really shitty position.. I am 100% certain the sentinal knew exactly who he was going to have to call out before he did it.. its not like Hegseth isnt name/face recognizeable to pretty much everyone in the US... not to mention his photograph is in every HQ in the DoD...

Im glad the sentinal had the balls to step up and do what was obviously the right thing and hold the SECDEF to the exact same standard that everyone else is held to.. That couldnt have been an easy moment for him.. Hopefully everyone at the 3rd Infantry Regiment hoisted a toast to that guy later that night and have commended him for his actions and no politically driven SNCO or O tries to overtly or covertly take him to task over it..
Yeah that was a hard task...he should get a medal for it...wait he did!

Put that one in your fruit salad baby.
 
Interesting that you get taxed on primary residence capital gains in America. Here in communist Canada, all you have to do is live there for six months and any profit is tax free. Don’t worry though, we also have a housing shortage
Only if its above 250k (single) or 500k (married) in gains, or if you live in it less than 2 years. The problem was they never indexed the exemption to inflation, so after 30 years the value has been diminished. Interesting that Trump didn't address this oversight in either of his two “tax cut for the rich” bills that passed during his presidency.
 
Only if its above 250k (single) or 500k (married) in gains, or if you live in it less than 2 years. The problem was they never indexed the exemption to inflation, so after 30 years the value has been diminished. Interesting that Trump didn't address this oversight in either of his two “tax cut for the rich” bills that passed during his presidency.
The goal of the cuts were to focus on things that would allow reinvestment that would create jobs. There was much more discussion about limiting the mortgage interest deduction to pay for those cuts. $500k in gains impacts a relatively small number of people compared to other provisions. And not a lot of people were clamoring for the change.
 
This is not going to end well without government incentives, or rather government changes to suspend punitive capital gains on property.

The vise is squeezing:

Jaw 1 is that mortgage rates are high against modern norms and it is creating an affordability crisis along with many people holding their properties because they don't want to give away their 3% 30 year mortgages.

Jaw 2 is that the Baby Boomers own a LOT of homes and they won't let loose of them because of the capital gains implications and the paltry $500k lifetime primary-residence gains exemption for married filing jointly.

Why should left and right political stripes want to give the Baby Boomers and everyone else a "free pass" allowing them to sell their homes now without paying capital gains to the IRS? Boomers are presently holding their properties until their deaths, which is creating a housing shortage and in turn higher prices. When the Boomers die owning real property, the heirs pay no tax because they get a free "step-up" in basis. So it is tax advantageous to hold real estate until death, rather than sell it now and stimulate the economy with all that captive wealth that could be spent or invested in the market that creates jobs and wealth for all.

Stupid government disincentives are making the cost and supply of housing worse while suppressing the flow of capital. Giving everyone a hall-pass on real estate capital gains doesn't cheat the government of any taxes because the current strategy of real estate owners results in no taxes due anyway...in 20 years.
Correct.
 
Only if its above 250k (single) or 500k (married) in gains, or if you live in it less than 2 years. The problem was they never indexed the exemption to inflation, so after 30 years the value has been diminished. Interesting that Trump didn't address this oversight in either of his two “tax cut for the rich” bills that passed during his presidency.
So if you live in it for over two years, it’s free of capital gains? That seems like it would cover 98% of American home owners
 
1783553866396.png
 

Forum statistics

Threads
71,072
Messages
1,593,554
Members
175,106
Latest member
MyrtleStil
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Mattias Stedt wrote on Bushcat Safaris's profile.
A good safari brings a great experience that fulfils your expectations, but a great safari also brings professionalism and friendship. Bushcat Safaris fills all those boxes and we have a lot of great memories from the bush with rifle in hand.
My warmest recommendation for you to plan a safari with these guys and be ready for a great time. As they say, we are not here for a long time, we’re here for a great time!
Looking back at a great year
cb3a8f6b-e471-4478-8e24-fa9422db8d4d.jpeg
IMG_7851.jpeg
20bdfb9b-dfe7-46e1-9d90-981da068d8fc.jpeg
915d3c84-4177-457f-a11d-0771a765f4c3.jpeg
52bf1f94-ccae-4160-bc7a-ae8d7969278b.jpeg
8d4d83fd-64e0-466c-90bc-868a7492cf61.jpeg
a31db0e9-e914-41e0-a1c2-785617ad41ac.jpeg
A small glimpse into a fantastic season
e81d375e-faf8-4cbe-bf9c-afe325b97bbb.jpeg
9a766ff2-0919-4a4a-b09c-ede9ce09b94e.jpeg
22ecca2a-8c07-4eab-becb-2ee49dca9fc3.jpeg
IMG_7820.jpeg
fa806fce-29ef-485b-9544-b103140a7ad1.jpeg
b4e3df48-40f2-4593-95bb-efbe5fdeed09.jpeg
A0A409A3-B41C-41DF-91B3-FEBFC48FF566.jpeg
f53b657c-2414-450f-bf44-292f3bd3e46c.jpeg
Don't forget to Check out our Mountain package. Chase that Vaali find the elusive Grey Ghost and spot a Mountain Reedbuck. in Gods Country. find refuge in the field and freedom under wide open skies.
 
Top