Politics

Three quick points:

1) The fourth Geneva convention was passed after WWII and thus did not apply at the time. The legal framework for war is now totally different than it was then. The debate around the legality of acts in WWII and Iran is as different as Sharia law and Britsh common law. Different planets.

2) I have nothing but praise for the conscientiousness with which the United States military has conducted this war with Iran.

3) I still argue that many of Israel's actions in Gaza constitute war crimes.
Please note my example of a true upper tier conflict was a nuclear exchange. For instance a typical Minuteman three warhead has a yield of around 300 kt. Total moderate to heavy damage area is 65 to 70 square miles, depending on terrain and altitude of the blast. Regardless the military, industrial or command and control aim point, lots of noncombatants will be injured and die besides those on the specific target. Also, the US has refuses to restrict itself to any non-first use pledges.

The US did indeed sign the the 1949 Geneva Conventions, but has carved out key exceptions. and has refused to sign several subsequent treaties to maintain military flexibility. For instance the US has refused to sign the protocols of 1977 with respect legal combatant protection for guerilla movements, the Ottawa treaty with respect to landmines (though the US has largely restricted their US to the DMZ in Korea), or the most recent convention on cluster munitions.

Area bombing is indeed considered a violation of the law of war, though the US military does allow interpretation of the rule of proportionality at the strategic level. For instance, commanders are allowed to weigh expected collateral damage to civilians against the overall strategic value of the attack. Furthermore, under US doctrine, not the limitations of the Geneva Conventions, dual-use infrastructure such as national power grids, military/civilian communications networks, fuel processing and storage facilities, and transportation networks can be legally justified when such strikes entail concrete and direct military advantage. As you noted, the US, thus far, has seemed to avoid these targets in Iran, though holding them under threat.

Finally, there is no international body or court, to include the ICC, that the United States recognizes as having any jurisdiction over any American uniformed combatants. This frankly has less to do with the dangers of an international institution running amok, though that may be changing, than in assuring uniformed members of the armed forces have the full protections of the US constitution. In practical terms, it also leaves the US in a self-policing role where guidance can shift with changing international context and strategic interests. Post 9/11 is an excellent example. The US has also, when in its national interests demanded it, supported temporary tribunals such as Nuremburg or the CTY.
 
Control of Hormuz becomes less important by the day. The Saudis have completed a major expansion of the east west pipeline, dramatically reducing their dependence on Hormuz. Further expansion is in the works
Agreed. However, the alternatives are years away. Heck, Iraq and Turkiye just signed an agreement to export Iraqi oil through pipelines to Turkiye instead of going through the Hormuz. UAE is expanding the port on the other side of Hormuz for containers. All these alternatives are adding costs though and countries like Kuwait do not have any other options.

Short term it is and will be a pain and Iran is banking on the Democrats winning the midterms.
 
Agreed. However, the alternatives are years away. Heck, Iraq and Turkiye just signed an agreement to export Iraqi oil through pipelines to Turkiye instead of going through the Hormuz. UAE is expanding the port on the other side of Hormuz for containers. All these alternatives are adding costs though and countries like Kuwait do not have any other options.

Short term it is and will be a pain and Iran is banking on the Democrats winning the midterms.

I would typically agree, but I have been amazed at how fast they are moving. The east west expansion was likely mostly latent capacity, but holy smokes!
 
Shouldn't be arrested for that brilliant plan.

Screenshot_20260801-170329_YouTube.png
 
Stop me if you've heard this before...

So, air strikes will resume Sunday night or Monday morning? And Iran will claim they control Hormuz mid-Monday? Asking for a friend.

1000026345.jpg
 
Stop me if you've heard this before...

So, air strikes will resume Sunday night or Monday morning? And Iran will claim they control Hormuz mid-Monday? Asking for a friend.

View attachment 781317
Right. Blah, blah, blah. We've heard this song and dance replayed too many times. Talking out his arse and everyone knows it ... except Trump.
 
Iran, N.Korea, China, Russia and all the underling nations that hate democracy, freedom and the U.S. should save their money and simply keep backing, supporting the growing anti American coalition’s. All the while using Bots and Algorithms to divide us. Within 20 years they will have the U.S. where they want us. Without a hot war.

Every generation has bemoaned the impending doom. But the edge of that cliff keeps speeding towards us faster every year.

It used to take 10 years to look back and see how much has changed now it’s every year it gets crazier and crazier.

 
This is going to cause some shitstorms in the future....


Seems they actually listened to the experts

 
Three quick points:

1) The fourth Geneva convention was passed after WWII and thus did not apply at the time. The legal framework for war is now totally different than it was then. The debate around the legality of acts in WWII and Iran is as different as Sharia law and Britsh common law. Different planets.

2) I have nothing but praise for the conscientiousness with which the United States military has conducted this war with Iran.

3) I still argue that many of Israel's actions in Gaza constitute war crimes.
Of course you do. You weren’t there.
 
Another good guy with a gun slows or stops a mass shooting event.

This man jumped out of his truck and fired on the person shooting people with an AR at a In and Out burger joint.

It isn’t clear if he killed the shooter but witnesses say he definitely took the focus off the killer shooting more innocent people.

I’ve heard it was a suppressed H&K
IMG_3685.jpeg
 
Another good guy with a gun slows or stops a mass shooting event.

This man jumped out of his truck and fired on the person shooting people with an AR at a In and Out burger joint.

It isn’t clear if he killed the shooter but witnesses say he definitely took the focus off the killer shooting more innocent people.

I’ve heard it was a suppressed H&K View attachment 781338

I’d like to know how that would play out in Canada , if a citizen had blown Gary wortman off of there doorstep I’d like to think we as a country would come together and hoist them up as a hero. Unfortunately they would most likely face charges.
 
Another good guy with a gun slows or stops a mass shooting event.

This man jumped out of his truck and fired on the person shooting people with an AR at a In and Out burger joint.

It isn’t clear if he killed the shooter but witnesses say he definitely took the focus off the killer shooting more innocent people.

I’ve heard it was a suppressed H&K View attachment 781338
Risky though. Cops show up and all they see is a firefight in progress. Which one with a gun do they shoot?
 
Tubby, it’s sad fact that in many countries and U.S. cities. You are better off being shot than shooting a dirt bag.

Better to be judged by twelve than carried by six.
 
Without offering any judgement with respect to the intelligence of anyone who writes their personal diary on a government server subject to FOIA, I found this particular entry from August of 2022 by the good doctor Fauci more than a little enlightening and extremely troubling. It should be of interest to those few of you who still cling to the belief that the vaccine was worth its draconian imposition.

1785677718880.png
 

If this “band” wins in court the North Atlantic will be the maritime reincarnation of the Wild West. The commercial fisherman will just be able to self identify as indigenous and fish year round. There will be no need for seasons anymore.

What was it foghorn leghorn used to say “luckily I keep my feathers numbered for just such an occasion”
 

Forum statistics

Threads
70,166
Messages
1,565,518
Members
167,501
Latest member
TerrenceCo
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

migrabill wrote on Surgeon1's profile.
Be careful of this Wolfen guy. 2 messages. Both trying to sell something. He PM'ed me trying to sell something and he PM'ed my friend on here trying to sell something. Fishy.
autofire wrote on Dr Ray's profile.
Hi Dr. Ray, I will be in Cooktown from Oct 16 to Oct 23 fishing Lizard Island Black Marlin Tournament.

I have several "slack" days after fishing before I head for stay in Sydney and Fiji.

Do you have any recommendations for 1 or 2 day hunt near Cooktown?

I've hunted both DG and PG in 4 different countries in Africa.
Thank you,
Bob
 
Top