It's an old thread, but I too am familiar with the Rolex BS & probably went to the same dealer you visited in NOLA. I was after a matching set for the Wife & I , salesman told me I could get on a wait list , so I said sure. A few months later we were in Key West, on an Anniversary trip & Fly Fishing run , while out "shopping" with the Wife we stepped into a jewelry store, there was everything imaginable. I asked about Rolex , same diatribe BS , but they offered a Tudor , I passed on the way out I saw the Longines - Hydroconquest & Doxa ..... the Wife didn't like the looks of the Doxa, but the Longines had a "His & Hers" set, so we bought the Longines. Part of that decision was given because I have a high end Longines dress watch that was my Grandfather's - 1960s custom with 14K case , Diamond hours, black pearl face, Alligator band, solid Suit or Black Tie kinda fare, a beautiful watch with a solid movement. Of course what is offered by Longines of today is not what was 50+ yrs ago, being that Longines is part of the "Swatch" conglomerate. Despite the Mechanical Self-winding movements are solid quality at a price point that is mid-tier. Plus, Longines has a long history with equestrian events & that was another positive for me. It's been a great watch, and the only time I wear it is when I'm on free diving/snorkeling trips, so its in the salt a lot.
Oh, and the Rolex dealer finally called over a year later, and said, "We have the 'His' watch in, but not the 'Her' watch, if you can get here by such time .... yata, yata ...... I thanked him & passed.
Long story just to say I agree ....