.458 Winchester vs. .458 Lott

HWL

AH elite
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
1,010
Reaction score
1,546
Location
Germany
Media
189
Hunted
RSA, Namibia, Germany, Austria, Norway
After an "Act of madness", I have two rifles .458 Winchester-Magnum in my gunrack. Probably, I do not need even one. But anyways, there is always someting to improve.
Does ist make sence, to altern one to .458 Lott. I had a close look into Norma´s Reloading Manual #2.
.458 Winchester seems to perform better than .458 Lott, even with a shorter barrel! Are there any experiences out there? From the chronograph and from field....

HWL
 

BC.Pat

AH enthusiast
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
427
Reaction score
419
Location
Victoria, British Columbia
Media
9
Hunting reports
USA/Canada
1
Hunted
Botswana , Namibia, Sierra Leone
.458 Winchester seems to perform better than .458 Lott, even with a shorter barrel!
Interesting ! I was on the fence about the Lott as I have two 458 WM already. I will be interested to see what AH sage members say about the comparison. thank you for posting.

Pat
 

CAustin

Bronze supporter
AH ambassador
Joined
May 7, 2013
Messages
14,113
Reaction score
11,129
Media
252
Hunting reports
Africa
7
Member of
Courtney Hunting Club, NRA Life Member, SCI Kansas City Chapter
Hunted
South Africa, KwaZulu Natal, Kalahari, Northwest, Limpopo, Gauteng, APNR Kruger Area. USA Georgia, South Carolina, Arkansas, New Mexico, North Carolina and Texas
The Lott as I understand it was created because the 458 Winchester lacked the punch of it's newer cousin. I have heard it said that with more modern powders hand loaders can increase the capabilities of the Winchester.
@HWL in what areas do you see the Winchester outperforming the Lott as I would like to understand?
 

Gert Odendaal

AH legend
Joined
Apr 19, 2012
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
2,033
Media
873
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
SAJW
I think the focus should be on shot placement , if the hunter using the .458 Win Mag he can kill any elephant of buffalo, more recoil from the Lott version does not guarantee one shot kills every time...only correct shot placement guarantee one shot kills...(y)(y)
 

HWL

AH elite
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
1,010
Reaction score
1,546
Location
Germany
Media
189
Hunted
RSA, Namibia, Germany, Austria, Norway
The Lott as I understand it was created because the 458 Winchester lacked the punch of it's newer cousin. I have heard it said that with more modern powders hand loaders can increase the capabilities of the Winchester.
@HWL in what areas do you see the Winchester outperforming the Lott as I would like to understand?
I simply compared reloading data in "Norma Reloading Manual #2"

Top speed with 500 grain bullet is ....

.458 Winchester Magum 2175 f/s from a 24 " barrel
.458 Lott 2092 f/s from a 26 " Barrel

May be, Norma simply does not "like" the Lott....

But the Lott is a much bigger (longer) case, and I expected a little more punch....

Meanwhile, I had a look into Hornady # 10...... the Lott is ahead, with 50 f/s , both cartridges with 24 " barrels.
 

BnC 04

Gold supporter
AH elite
Joined
Jan 30, 2011
Messages
1,051
Reaction score
1,138
Location
Tennessee
Media
61
Hunting reports
Africa
2
USA/Canada
3
Member of
DSC, RMEF, DU, NWTF, NRA
Hunted
Canada/Europe/Africa/14 US States
As already stated, proper shot placement is/should be the primary goal. If you are comfortable/accurate with your WM your option should be a pretty easy choice. Have you have ever had a chance to test fire the Lott to give you a comparison in regards to recoil?
In regards to the WM outpreforming the Lott, I personally have never read or heard that info.
Best of luck on your final desicion.
 

Ray B

AH legend
Joined
Aug 19, 2016
Messages
2,076
Reaction score
2,100
Location
WA St, USA
Media
75
The 458 Win Mag has a water capacity to the bullet base of 86 grains. Compared to other "African" cartridges this is rather miniscule and would seem to be insufficient to propel a 500 grain bullet to the desired velocities. However with proper powder selection pressures of 62K psi can be developed and with sufficient duration that muzzle velocities over 2000 fps may be obtained. This was the goal of the Winchester designers. The limitations are that the powder selection that will achieve this goal is limited. Some powders are so heavily compressed that the burnrate is disrupted and situations such as Mr. Lott endured may result. Faster burning powders achieve the desired pressure with less volume so as not to be compressed, but have insufficient duration to get the bullet to the desired velocity. But there are powders presently available that give the desired results. The advantage of the Lott is that it has about 10 more grains water capacity which translates to about 12 more grains of powder space, so more powder of slower burnrate may be used to provide more acceleration to the bullet and achieve higher velocities, or Win Mag velocities may be achieved with a larger list of suitable powders. the result is an equal velocity with lower peak pressure is possible due to longer duration with the Lott.
The increased case capacity opens the doors to several options. But with all options there is a trade-off. Before I had the barrel rechambered I'd list the advantages and disadvantages of each and place the items in a listing of importance to me. Reviewing the list would show which cartridge is best for me.
 

Cousin Bongo

AH member
Joined
Jan 12, 2017
Messages
48
Reaction score
57
Media
10
Member of
NRA - Benefactor
Hunted
South Africa, Zambia, Colombia, Guatemala, Mexico, New Zealand, Australia, Paupa New Guinea, Philippines, USA (various including Alaska)
Doesn't really make financial sense, but it makes sense performance-wise. ..if you have a use for the performance. However, I suggest taking a look at the .450 Watts. The Watts is the forerunner to the Lott and preceded it by many years, but Watts wasn't a gun writer. One can shoot Lott or Win Mag in the Watts. A PH friend of mine has a Watts and loves it. The Lott is better known nowadays but, as I said, Watts wasn't a gun writer. The only reason I haven't changed over to .450 Watts from my .458 Win Mag is because my .458 Win Mag is a custom job and the action simply isn't long enough for the Watts or Lott.

CB
 
Last edited:

Gert Odendaal

AH legend
Joined
Apr 19, 2012
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
2,033
Media
873
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
SAJW
Maybe something interesting mentioned by Terry Irwin, PH in Tanzania , the Selous Game reserve many years ago.. He used a .458 Mannlicher Schoenauer, custom made for him by the Mannlicher Schoenauer company...he ordered a custom fitted .458 MS since it had a rotary magazine that will not drop rounds out when using it in stress fire situations..as Richard Harland had used as well....Terry ordered it in a 24" barrel length..The company refused and stated that the barrel needs to be 26" to 28" long to ensure sufficient burning of the propellant to ensure proper muzzle velocity . Terry had to get use to the longer barrel but mentioned it never bothered him..
According to him the .458 MS killed every elephant and other dangerous game dead...he was a proponent of shot placement as the only criteria to consider when shooting at dangerous game...or any game ...

Email from Terry Irwin:
Hi Gert

I used a Westerly Richards .458 and various other large calibres with Mauser type actions. One of the problems I experienced with all of them was magazine plates popping open and spilling all the rounds or, when flicking the bolt open quickly, the top round may pop up right out of the magazine causing a jam. This problem was solved with the Mannlicher's revolving magazine. It holds each round individually and feeds one at a time and the base plate does not open on a hinge. The barrel is also longer than other .458s. I requested a shorter barrel when I had mine custom made but they refused to shorten the barrel saying it would not be ballisticly perfect with a shorter barrel. I did not experience all the under powered shots, with early Winchester ammunition, that gave the .458 a bad reputation when it first came out. I think this was because of the longer barrel. The action is also the smoothest I have used but I had to get used to using the flat bolt I would have preferred a straight bolt with a ball end. Otherwise I think the Mannlicher Schonauer is the best .458 I have used. Enjoy7 it! - Terry
 

BC.Pat

AH enthusiast
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
427
Reaction score
419
Location
Victoria, British Columbia
Media
9
Hunting reports
USA/Canada
1
Hunted
Botswana , Namibia, Sierra Leone
I was quite interested in your post about 458 MS.

Pat
 
Last edited by a moderator:

larry4831

AH fanatic
Joined
May 26, 2015
Messages
522
Reaction score
340
Media
5
Member of
NRA
458 Winchester Magnum with accurate arms 2460 they list 2191 with a 500 grain bullet and a 24 inch barrel. That's not too bad.
 

Gert Odendaal

AH legend
Joined
Apr 19, 2012
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
2,033
Media
873
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
SAJW
Although, the longer .458 Lott version really looks good, bigger and potentially more dangerous than the .458 WM round when standing alongside each other.....(y)(y):LOL:
 

HWL

AH elite
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
1,010
Reaction score
1,546
Location
Germany
Media
189
Hunted
RSA, Namibia, Germany, Austria, Norway
I fired an old 500 gr FMJ Winchester Cartridge in the long barreld Mannlicher.
458Win.jpg


2092 f/s witch is 638 m/s,.... not bad for the old cartridge.

HWL
 

aleli

AH member
Joined
Mar 3, 2017
Messages
18
Reaction score
15
It is absolutely no problem to load a 500 gr bullet to 2300+ fps with the Lott.

Norma even ammo rated to 2300 fps with a 500 gr solid...
 

375 Ruger Fan

Gold supporter
AH legend
Joined
Jun 14, 2015
Messages
3,587
Reaction score
5,076
Location
Houston, Texas
Media
210
Articles
4
Hunting reports
Africa
7
USA/Canada
3
Australia/NZ
1
Member of
NRA, DSC
Hunted
Namibia, Zimbabwe, New Zealand, South Africa (Eastern Cape & NW), Alaska, TX, LA, MO, OH, MT, ID, WA, WY, Canada (Yukon)

HWL

AH elite
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
1,010
Reaction score
1,546
Location
Germany
Media
189
Hunted
RSA, Namibia, Germany, Austria, Norway
...the 400gr Lott is a real booster.....

(n)

HWL
 

Attachments

375 Ruger Fan

Gold supporter
AH legend
Joined
Jun 14, 2015
Messages
3,587
Reaction score
5,076
Location
Houston, Texas
Media
210
Articles
4
Hunting reports
Africa
7
USA/Canada
3
Australia/NZ
1
Member of
NRA, DSC
Hunted
Namibia, Zimbabwe, New Zealand, South Africa (Eastern Cape & NW), Alaska, TX, LA, MO, OH, MT, ID, WA, WY, Canada (Yukon)
...the 400gr Lott is a real booster.....

(n)

HWL
Yea, that 23450 FPS is smokin'. My guess is that's suppose to be 2450 FPS, as it looks like the Lott is 100 FPS faster on each bullet weight.

So if I was tempted to buy a 458, seems like it makes sense to get the Lott and it can shoot either. If anyone already has a 458 WM, it's not a big enough jump to a Lott to justify getting one. Of course, one should never let sound reasoning and good judgement get in the wasy of a gun purchase.
 

Dr Ray

AH legend
Joined
Apr 1, 2017
Messages
2,543
Reaction score
2,414
Location
Cairns, Australia
Media
52
Articles
5
Hunting reports
Australia/NZ
5
Interesting ! I was on the fence about the Lott as I have two 458 WM already. I will be interested to see what AH sage members say about the comparison. thank you for posting.

Pat
If going to South Africa or Namibia I suggest you check the availability of factory ammo in case yours goes astray
I believe, personally, tHat it's a matter of Bullet placement rather than 100 fps for example
I don't like short barrels even though they make finding the target fractionally quicker
It's the muzzle blast for those near you I think is an issue
 

Gert Odendaal

AH legend
Joined
Apr 19, 2012
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
2,033
Media
873
Articles
1
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Member of
SAJW
Maybe another interesting factor I should mention about Terry Irwin when he worked as a geologist for Anglo American company in Tanzania back in those years. He ( other prospectors ) were not allowed to have rifles with them when traversing the vast expanses of the Tanzanian wilderness searching for minerals , diamond rich deposits. Terry mentioned one fact that he learned to become a great skill assisting him in the future was to learn the body language of game. This afforded him the skill to get extremely close to dangerous game animals he later cull, hunt or getting his clients extremely near their quarry.
This on it self is a great advantage when hunting these dangerous game with a client..it afforded the client a much bigger chance to get shot placement correct...using any caliber from .375 H&H upwards on dangerous game when you are a few feet of your quarry really gives a hunter an edge...
Clients hunted with Terry Irwin, numerously mentioned his skill in getting them sometimes just out of arm`s reach of their dangerous game animal they hunted...
Bush craft skills seems to be less important with hunting scenarios today since time is of the essence and safari hunting is too expensive to make time for walk and stalk hunts .(y)(y)
 

HWL

AH elite
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
1,010
Reaction score
1,546
Location
Germany
Media
189
Hunted
RSA, Namibia, Germany, Austria, Norway
To load the .458 Lott to the performance, like the .458 Win-Mag, but with less pressure, may be a good idea...

HWL
 
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Damon Engel wrote on Saul's profile.
Hello! I noticed your E Type in your avatar. What year is it? I have a '69 that looks identical, minus the wire wheels. My car has the steel rims, as I understand it,a more expensive option, but I like the wire wheel much better!
pamtnman wrote on Timothy Doyle's profile.
Interested in the 450/400 dies. I have PayPal. Thank you
Hunt booked 2022
ve7poi wrote on ZANA BOTES SAFARI's profile.
See you in May 2022
twenty days with you time seems to have slowed now after booking lol
tarbe wrote on Royal27's profile.
Current ETA to Buc-ees is 11 am or we can meet you there about 2 hrs later in the way back.
 
Top