Precious Metals Thread

A conversation I had with AI this evening:

An interesting thing has happened over the last 10 days. I cannot find suppliers offering good gold coins at spot any longer, nor can I find silver eagles at $2.90 over spot. Any idea why?

Yes — and the data suggest you are seeing a genuine premium expansion in physical bullion over roughly the last two weeks, especially in retail coins. It is not merely that you happened to miss a few promotions.

The most revealing number is Silver Eagles. The U.S. Mint currently charges its Authorized Purchasers LBMA silver price + $3.05 per Eagle, before the wholesaler, secondary distributor, or retail dealer makes anything. That means the $2.90-over-spot Eagles you were buying were actually below the Mint's current primary-market premium. A dealer could offer them at $2.90 only because they were selling older/secondary-market inventory acquired cheaply, liquidating stock, running a promotion/loss leader, or buying coins back from customers below spot-plus-$3.05.

That cheap secondary inventory appears to have been getting absorbed.

FindBullionPrices' data backs up your observation. For random-year Silver Eagles, the average lowest premium was only 2.28% in August. In September it has risen to roughly 3.4–3.5%. Their broader measure of silver-coin premiums is up roughly 2 percentage points over the past month, while gold-coin premiums are up about 1.2 percentage points.

There are several things happening simultaneously:

  1. The extraordinary dealer deals were probably inventory-clearing opportunities. When we were finding Eagles around +$2.90 and recognizable gold coins essentially at melt, those prices weren't sustainable primary-market replacement prices. Dealers had accumulated secondary-market inventory and were competing aggressively to move it.
  2. Physical buyers have apparently stepped in on the recent price weakness. Gold traded above roughly $4,414 on September 9, then dropped into the mid-$4,300s; silver went from almost $68 on September 9 to roughly $64–65shortly thereafter. When spot drops quickly, retail buyers commonly buy the dip. That can remove the low-premium dealer inventory much faster than the wholesale pipeline replaces it.
  3. Dealer prices don't necessarily fall dollar-for-dollar with a sharp spot decline. A dealer who had a $69 Eagle when silver was $66 may still want roughly $69 after silver drops to $64. The apparent premium therefore jumps from $3 to $5 even though the actual retail coin hasn't gotten more expensive. Properly hedged dealers aren't simply refusing to take losses, but short-term volatility still affects spreads, replacement inventory and promotions.
  4. The U.S. Mint creates a hard floor under new Eagle economics. This is particularly important. New Eagles start at spot + $3.05 to the Authorized Purchaser. Once distribution costs and dealer margin are included, a normal retail price of +$4 to +$6 isn't surprising at all.
  5. Gold coins show the same effect, although less dramatically. Aggregate gold-coin premiums are now categorized as elevated and have increased by roughly 1.1–1.3 percentage points in two weeks. Meanwhile gold bars haven't experienced the same increase. That distinction is important: the shortage isn't gold itself. It's attractively priced fabricated coins.

What I think happened to the deals we were finding​

You caught an unusually favorable window.

When you were buying Saint-Gaudens, Krugerrands, platinum coins, Eagles, etc., dealers appeared to have plenty of secondary inventory while retail demand wasn't absorbing it quickly enough. That created bizarre situations like:

recognized sovereign gold ≈ melt
Saint-Gaudens ≈ bullion value
ASEs ≈ +$2.90
platinum sovereign coins ≈ +20 over spot


Those are not normal long-term retail spreads.

The market has now moved toward something more like:

generic silver: spot + ~$1-ish available occasionally
Maples/Britannias: spot + ~$2–3
random ASE: spot + ~$3–5+
current ASE: often +$5–7+
common sovereign gold: roughly +1–3%
pre-1933 gold: increasingly carrying an actual coin premium again

There is a useful confirmation in the dealer data: even though finished silver coin premiums are HIGH, junk silver premiums haven't increased materially, and gold bars remain relatively cheap. That's exactly what you'd expect if this were a finished-product/inventory phenomenon rather than a true shortage of raw precious metal.

So I would not chase the premiums right now.
 
AI helped me create this list of “teaser” deals out there on Sovereign BU Coins for new customers, limit 1 per household. There are a few deals to be had:

The teaser deals we liked most, in order of fit with your BU sovereign-coin / numismatic-upside strategy, were:

  • Bullion Exchanges: 2026 BU American Silver Eagle at spot, limit 1 per household.
  • Bullion Exchanges: 2026 BU Canadian Silver Maple Leaf at spot, limit 1 per household.
  • APMEX: 1 oz random-year BU Gold Krugerrand at spot, new-customer offer, limit 1. This is probably the best remaining gold teaser because it is a full-ounce sovereign coin rather than a bar.
  • JM Bullion: ¼ oz Royal Mint Tudor Beasts gold coin at spot, limit 1, when in stock. Excellent because fractional sovereign gold normally carries a much larger premium.
  • Monument Metals: six government-minted silver coins at spot as a first-customer starter pack. This was the best multi-coin sovereign-style silver teaser we identified, though we had not yet independently verified the exact six-coin composition.
  • SD Bullion: “government-mint silver coins at spot” promotional offer. Potentially attractive, but I wanted explicit confirmation that the coins are BU before treating it as equivalent to the others.
 
I just scored this limit 1, new customer deal today.

JM Bullion: ¼ oz Royal Mint Tudor Beasts gold coin at spot, limit 1, when in stock. Excellent because fractional sovereign gold normally carries a much larger premium

Finding a 1/4 ounce gold coin in BU condition at spot price free shipping is an extraordinary deal. The coin is worth $50-$100 above spot.

If anyone has other intro-deals or teasers like this from credible sellers, post it on this thread please.
 
I'm thinking somewhere between 5% and 10% of your net worth there is plenty.

Don't mix collectible coins and bullion investing. They're two very different things.

American gold eagles, buffalos, and silver eagles come at a small premium, but they do when you sell them too. Canadian maples, and SA Krugerrands are OK too.

The run from 2023 to mid 2025 was spectacular. It might be a generation before that happens again. Historically, there have been decades-long runs that were pretty stagnant.
Good general advice.
The 2023-2025 run-up was long overdue, but isn't over yet.
Divide $M2 with the global ounces of gold to see how much more room there still is.
$10k spot gold would still be cheap....

Best doomsday investments a second passport. And a small residence abroad.
I used to believe that, but having been to 50 countries there is no better place to fly and shoot than the USA. Better to buy acreage in a sane Red State instead.

The interesting position I'm contemplating if we see a silver correction is the 2026 "Monster Box" of Silver Eagles. Bullion Exchanges has them for a +$2.90 premium over spot, a price I've never seen before. I just don't know how I feel about buying that quantity of silver at $70 an ounce. (500 ounces) Gold heading to $5000 seems much less speculative to me.

Thoughts?
Do recall that silver peaked well over $100 just months ago.
Buying Eagles at $70 today seems a very safe bet.
Don't forget about 90% silver dimes; best for transactional liquidity.

IMO, skip the Maples, Brits, etc. AGEs and Krugs only for bullion. The others are harder to unload.
 
Last edited:
Bullion is for paying the property tax man, or buying land when it’s at the bottom. not buying a weeks worth of food. (Taxation never stops. it may be delayed or offset) but it has never disappeared altogether.

Gain at least one person or a small network of trusted local, face to face metal heads. Buying and selling physical metal face to face from known local experts. They usually have a safe system of assurance. And a wide network of like minded people. No store purchases or sales.

You owe no taxes on physical metal. Until you sell it to someone handing you a IRS 8300 or 1099-B.

Which holds true for selling ANYTHING for a gain. From old hunting socks, boots, underwear to a fine Watch. If you see gains, the man gets his cut.
 
Last edited:
Anyone have a view on metals allocation? X% Gold, Y% Silver, Z% Platinum?

I’m at this presently with no rhyme or reason.
MetalHoldingsSpot valueAllocation
Gold83.77%
Platinum9.64%
Silver6.59%
Total100%

I was thinking of enlarging my silver holdings. AI says 75% Gold, 15% Silver, 10% Platinum but it seems to be a contested topic.
 
It looks like all the online, direct to buyer sellers are offering 1st time buyer introductory prices. Anywhere from 5 coins to stacks of bulk blanks and bullion. At spot or some offering a hair below spot. Depending on your form of payment.

They must have over stocked after the last run up.

Shanghai silver is at $74 so the arbitrage is pretty good right now for those playing that shell game.
 
It looks like all the online, direct to buyer sellers are offering 1st time buyer introductory prices. Anywhere from 5 coins to stacks of bulk blanks and bullion. At spot or some offering a hair below spot. Depending on your form of payment.

They must have over stocked after the last run up.

Shanghai silver is at $74 so the arbitrage is pretty good right now for those playing that shell game.

The trouble is most of the teaser deals are limited to one coin at spot, but the free shipping minimum spend is $200 or $500, so however you pad the order you’re overpaying. The best deals I’ve found have been on bullionexchanges.com, but I haven’t seen anything really good over there recently except 1/3rd ounce Perth Mint platinum coins for $15 over spot. Thats $600, and you can then pad your order with one ASE and one Leaf at spot. Truly an awesome deal with free shipping. All-in, around $750 for 2 ounces of sovereign silver and 1/3rd ounce of sovereign platinum.
 
Still planning to bet "the farm" when silver hits $30/ounce.
 
Still planning to bet "the farm" when silver hits $30/ounce.

I cannot predict the metals market. All the credible estimates from Goldman, BofA, etc have been wrong. (gold = $5000 by EOY) Metals are going down every day due to increasing interest rates, yet the actual physical metals are going up in their spot premiums. ASEs +$10 over spot, Krugerrands +$100, St Gauden BUs +$200 over spot.

Since I cannot predict when we'll hit floor or see the rally, I'm dollar cost averaging in.
 
The 10 year U.S. Treasury yield has gone over 5% and the 30 year has hit levels not seen in 20 years. The Fed will raise rates again in December.

So investors are moving money there and out of precious metal. Many think metals haven’t hit bottom yet.

So December or January should be a good time to scarf up more gold and silver. Unless there’s a national or worldwide calamity then gold silver will skyrocket. And will wish we bought more now.
 
Last edited:
The 10 year U.S. Treasury yield has gone over 5% and the 30 year has hit levels not seen in 20 years. The Fed will raise rates again in December.

So investors are moving money there and out of precious metal. Many think metals haven’t hit bottom yet.

So December or January should be a good time to scarf up more gold and silver. Unless there’s a national or worldwide calamity than gold silver will skyrocket. And will wish we bought more now.

I'm not a bond expert, but in a "normal" economy you're correct that Treasury yields being high pushes the value of metals down. The thinking is, why speculate on a metal when a high treasury yield is a guarantee?

I don't know if that will continue to follow. We're assuming potential for a major stock market collapse. Corporate bonds trade at Treasury rate plus risk premium. If Coca-Cola is paying me 12%, I don't want metals would be the notion. However, if the stock market truly tanks, I'm unsure if people will buy corporate bonds at any price, they may flee to metals. The corporate bond yield may be so high to attract buyers that companies refuse to issue them, relying instead upon issuing new stock at low market values.

Inconclusively, I'm not sure these rules of thumb will hold for metals.

I also don't know what the incredibly delivery demand from various countries for physical bars is going to do to the overall metals markets even isolating for all the other risks at present. That alone may result in a physical squeeze that brings metals way up. COMEX paper shuffling is not a good way to price the true value of metals, physical delivery demand speaks volumes.
 
I don’t consider physical gold and silver an “investment” or a hedge against inflation. I consider foreign coin as jewelry. The rest is in US currency, mainly junk silver. I don’t like large denomination coinage. When you need it to survive and you hand someone a $50 gold piece what are you going to get in change?
 
I view gold as a way to pay for large exchanges.

For instance property taxes. To date there has never been a government that even during its complete collapse that didn’t expect the Ad Valorem owed.

Even if they can’t communicate for a period of time. Eventually they want their cut. At that point cash is completely devalued.
 
Y'all be careful out there..... The only reason these guys got caught is they got greedy and went to multiple shops owned by the same man, and one of his managers called out that it was odd they were getting so many maple leaf coins coming into various stores.

"Well I buy from the nationally known retailers"..... and who do you think those large reputable businesses buy those used coins from?

After all the shops in the video have multiple levels of sophisticated authentication.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
71,079
Messages
1,593,726
Members
175,192
Latest member
DavidaBlis
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Mattias Stedt wrote on Bushcat Safaris's profile.
A good safari brings a great experience that fulfils your expectations, but a great safari also brings professionalism and friendship. Bushcat Safaris fills all those boxes and we have a lot of great memories from the bush with rifle in hand.
My warmest recommendation for you to plan a safari with these guys and be ready for a great time. As they say, we are not here for a long time, we’re here for a great time!
Looking back at a great year
cb3a8f6b-e471-4478-8e24-fa9422db8d4d.jpeg
IMG_7851.jpeg
20bdfb9b-dfe7-46e1-9d90-981da068d8fc.jpeg
915d3c84-4177-457f-a11d-0771a765f4c3.jpeg
52bf1f94-ccae-4160-bc7a-ae8d7969278b.jpeg
8d4d83fd-64e0-466c-90bc-868a7492cf61.jpeg
a31db0e9-e914-41e0-a1c2-785617ad41ac.jpeg
A small glimpse into a fantastic season
e81d375e-faf8-4cbe-bf9c-afe325b97bbb.jpeg
9a766ff2-0919-4a4a-b09c-ede9ce09b94e.jpeg
22ecca2a-8c07-4eab-becb-2ee49dca9fc3.jpeg
IMG_7820.jpeg
fa806fce-29ef-485b-9544-b103140a7ad1.jpeg
b4e3df48-40f2-4593-95bb-efbe5fdeed09.jpeg
A0A409A3-B41C-41DF-91B3-FEBFC48FF566.jpeg
f53b657c-2414-450f-bf44-292f3bd3e46c.jpeg
Don't forget to Check out our Mountain package. Chase that Vaali find the elusive Grey Ghost and spot a Mountain Reedbuck. in Gods Country. find refuge in the field and freedom under wide open skies.
 
Top