Where is the best steak (and why)

Piedmontese beef, at my house.
After that, McGuire's and the Peddler.

Angus is too soft of an English single muscle. Take a double muscle steak. If you don't understand this, you don't know steak.
 
I might have once voted for McGuire's Irish Pub in Destin, Florida--a great dry aged steak, though they do apply a proprietary rub.
After tonight I might vote for The Keg, a Canadian based enterprise, and we ate at the Arlington, Tx location. Difference? Their New York strip was so good, I couldn't even bring myself to salt or pepper it, and used a béarnaise sauce to dip bread in, rather than dip steak in it. Just Wow. Near as I can tell, the grade of meat and the well seasoned grill did their magic, no doubt aided by good cooking.
What makes you defend you favorite steak or method as champion?
wow... some excellent candidates already in the mix. The keg is hard to beat , as is the 3 monkeys , Id like to also throw "The Butchers Block" in Windhoek into the ring as a candidate. As an aside a lot of the beef outside US is less marbled but can be more flavorful especially the aged stuff. Thats where southern africa and places like argentinea and paraguay in south america can really shine
 
wow... some excellent candidates already in the mix. The keg is hard to beat , as is the 3 monkeys , Id like to also throw "The Butchers Block" in Windhoek into the ring as a candidate. As an aside a lot of the beef outside US is less marbled but can be more flavorful especially the aged stuff. Thats where southern africa and places like argentinea and paraguay in south america can really shine

The best Keg is the one in downtown Calgary. However, if you’re already there, you’re right around the corner from Caesar’s… just saying…
 
The ones I make on my Pitt Boss pellet grill are the best , I have had.
 
The ones I make on my Pitt Boss pellet grill are the best , I have had.

Funny you should say that. I sent a South African friend to the best steakhouse in Florence, Italy for bisteca alla fiorentina. He said it was the second best steak he’d ever had, the best being a reverse seared filet mignon cooked on my pellet grill prior to a reverse seare on cast iron.
 
Hard to beat my backyard. Go to the local butcher and pick out a good ribeye or strip. Put on kosher salt, black pepper and granulated garlic. Leave uncovered in the fridge 24 ish hours. Sous vide to 129 degrees for 2 hours then sear on a very hot grill. Pair with grilled asparagus, baked potato and a Napa Cab.
 
I might have once voted for McGuire's Irish Pub in Destin, Florida--a great dry aged steak, though they do apply a proprietary rub.
After tonight I might vote for The Keg, a Canadian based enterprise, and we ate at the Arlington, Tx location. Difference? Their New York strip was so good, I couldn't even bring myself to salt or pepper it, and used a béarnaise sauce to dip bread in, rather than dip steak in it. Just Wow. Near as I can tell, the grade of meat and the well seasoned grill did their magic, no doubt aided by good cooking.
What makes you defend you favorite steak or method as champion?

Honestly, I would say there was a period of time when my favorite steak were mine I dry aged myself. At my old place I had a Dry Ager and found that a 30 day wet aging of a primal, followed by 65 days for Ribeye or 75 days for a bone-in Kansas City Strip was about as good as it gets.

I got my inspiration the first time I went to Gallagher's steakhouse at NYNY casino in Vegas. They do dry-aged meats up to 300 days and I of course ordered the Ribeye because I've never had a NY Strip that didn't suck before. My colleagues started passing their steaks around the table and I tried the 100 day dry aged NY Strip and couldn't believe it. That disgusting, inedible gristle on the NY Strip had transformed into a delightful, soluable fat that bursted with flavor in the spirit of a Ribeye yet the beef flavor of the meat was even better.

As to home-prep, I like to sous vide the steaks to 110F and then sear them on both sides on a Big Green Egg at 600F-750F for about 90 seconds until medium rare. (129F internal)

Honorable mention: Any Brazilian Churrascarria that serves Picanha (Sirloin Coulotte) is spectacular.
 
Honestly, I would say there was a period of time when my favorite steak were mine I dry aged myself. At my old place I had a Dry Ager and found that a 30 day wet aging of a primal, followed by 65 days for Ribeye or 75 days for a bone-in Kansas City Strip was about as good as it gets.

I got my inspiration the first time I went to Gallagher's steakhouse at NYNY casino in Vegas. They do dry-aged meats up to 300 days and I of course ordered the Ribeye because I've never had a NY Strip that didn't suck before. My colleagues started passing their steaks around the table and I tried the 100 day dry aged NY Strip and couldn't believe it. That disgusting, inedible gristle on the NY Strip had transformed into a delightful, soluable fat that bursted with flavor in the spirit of a Ribeye yet the beef flavor of the meat was even better.

As to home-prep, I like to sous vide the steaks to 110F and then sear them on both sides on a Big Green Egg at 600F-750F for about 90 seconds until medium rare. (129F internal)

Honorable mention: Any Brazilian Churrascarria that serves Picanha (Sirloin Coulotte) is spectacular.
Can you expand even more on the dry aging details. I am rather flabbergasted at the suggestion of up to 300 days! How does it keep from spoiling?
 
Can you expand even more on the dry aging details. I am rather flabbergasted at the suggestion of up to 300 days! How does it keep from spoiling?

It's controlled decomposition. The USDA notes that there is ZERO flavor change until 30 days of dry aging. Peak tenderness is achieved at 28 days. Yet when you buy dry-aged steak from a meat locker or store, its usually 7 day dry aged, a worthless scam.

The steak agers have a few mechanisms at work. First, you're dry aging around 35-38F, above freezing so live bacteria can develop, but below 40F, the temperature where harmful bacteria can exist. In addition, they have a UV light that sterilizes dangerous pathogens on the meat. They also have a humidfication system to slow evaporation within the steak. Some will also have blocks of Himalayan sea salt that kills some bacteria and adds a bit of salinity to the meat.

What is actually happening to the dry aged beef? First thing that happens is a reduction in moisture which consolidates that beefy flavor. Just that activity which results in about 15% weight loss over a long dry age period creates a better taste profile. The second thing that happens is that the fats break down and become that delicious, edible, soluable fat you get out of a standard Ribeye but exists nowhere on a NY or KC Strip loin when fresh. The fat starts to get that nice, flaky texture and when grilled you will eat every bite of the fat that has that fantastic, buttery, best-part of the experience taste. The third thing that happens is a matter of personal taste preferences. At about 45 days you get a very subtle, delightful "funk" on the meat that 99% of people enjoy. At 60-75 days that grows to a point where 90% of people enjoy it, noting taste of black truffle or really good quality mushrooms in a positive sense of the term. Strong notes of nutty taste are present. When you go past those timeframes the steaks become pungent and opinions begin to diverge, some finding them unpleasant or at least unexpected to a normal palate. I've tried everything up to 300 days and I've personally dry aged steaks up to 125 days. I personally do not think the 90-125 day dry aging is worth the squeeze. The flavors aren't really developing that much yet you start getting a LOT of meat loss as the edge margins oxidize and become basically meat-jerky that reduces the weight of the edible steaks you'll cut from the primal.

The very best steaks I've dry aged turned out to be this process. 1.) I would buy a primal T-Bone in that 10-15 pound range. 2.) I would have the butcher open the cryovac and use a bone saw to cut the bone-in Filet Mignons off of the primal and cut them into 2" thick steaks. (Those I'd eat immediately, the very best filet mignon you will ever have) 3.) I would take the primal "strip loin" remaining that had the L shaped bone in it and a huge fat cap on it, placing it into the dry ager for 75 days.

The Primal Kansas City Strip loin above is ideal, it has the best bone and membrane to prevent moisture loss on two sides, the best fat cap to slow evaporation on the third side. The two exposed ends are where moisture loss primarily occurs although I'm told you can dip the ends in warm tallow several times to seal the ends, yielding more finished product.

What to do with the dry-aged bones? Absolutely spectacular if roasted and then used for bone broth, espanole, or demi-glace.

What do you do with the pellicle? Pellicle is the dry fat and meat chunks that you carve off the primals at the end of the dry aging when you cut your steaks. The pellicle can be soaked in au jus, beef broth, or bone broth overnight in a fridge. The next day, you add 20%-25% pellicle to your grind when you make ground beef. You ever hear about those $1000 hamburgers at the michilen star restaurants in NYC? Yeah, that's what's in them. That's what Pat Lefreda does on his most expensive ground beef as well.

I'm not much of a ground beef guy these days, I find it ludicrously expensive for what it is at present market prices. You know what is cheap these days? Prime Brisket at Sam's club is spectacular and its $5 a pound. Dry aging a prime brisket 45 days and then grinding it for burgers would put you at <$7 a finished pound and would trump any ground beef on the planet for the same exact price.
 
The best steaks I have ever had were in several steakhouses in Buenos Aires. Steakhouses in Uruguay and South Africa came close.

One of the worst steaks I have ever had was at Gallaghers Steakhouse in New York. I could have gotten a better steak in a supermarket and cooked it myself. The tomatoes in the salad appetizer were not even ripe enough. The “service” was abominable.
 
The best steaks I have ever had were in several steakhouses in Buenos Aires. Steakhouses in Uruguay and South Africa came close.

I think your observation is based on facts, not opinion. There are two ways to butcher animals: 1.) The American/European method that creates the cuts we are familiar. 2.) The South American method.

The South American method has a rule: Never cut across muscle groups. The result is they disassemble an animal, not butcher it. Each muscle group becomes its own steak and therefore the grain of the muscle goes in a single direction. The net result is every piece of meat is more tender. I find it interesting that American hunters actually break down deer very similarly to how South Americans process beef because its benefit is self-evident. More tender meat.
 
I think your observation is based on facts, not opinion. There are two ways to butcher animals: 1.) The American/European method that creates the cuts we are familiar. 2.) The South American method.

The South American method has a rule: Never cut across muscle groups. The result is they disassemble an animal, not butcher it. Each muscle group becomes its own steak and therefore the grain of the muscle goes in a single direction. The net result is every piece of meat is more tender. I find it interesting that American hunters actually break down deer very similarly to how South Americans process beef because its benefit is self-evident. More tender meat.
Yeh South American cuts of meat are different, I absolutely fell in love with South American style cooked meat on a bird hunt with my dad and his friends, all the Brazilian steak houses around here are always packed.
I like a good American style steak also but no way in hell could I pick a best place as I have had some great experiences in Kansas City, New York, Houston, San Antonio,
There used to be a tiny little place called the wagon wheel in lyford Tx that cooked up everything on a flat top ( hamburgers, steaks, chicken fried steak , ect ) it probably was the seasoned cast iron flattop that made everything so good?
A KISS seasoned steak is my favorite ( keep it simple stupid) salt & pepper rub , cooked medium rare
 
I discovered my favorite steak by accident 30+ years ago in BA Argentina. I ordered it out of curiosity as I had absolutely no idea what exactly it was.
Hanger steak... roasted medium rare over a hot wood fire...served with chimichuri dip sauce.
IMHO several steaks are it's equal...
however none bests it.
Cheers
Spike
 
@rookhawk, where did you get your dry ager. What are brands to trust?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
69,385
Messages
1,546,527
Members
161,463
Latest member
RobertFearm
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Nomosendero wrote on gregrn43's profile.
Between Blak Rock and Pocahontas, I did not want to say that on the forum. That's a nice Cat!
curt672 wrote on WoodencrossIII's profile.
just making sure my message went threw
30-06Ken wrote on ftothfadd's profile.
I'll take the Vortex scope cover you have listed in the Pay it Forward thread.

Ken [redacted]
Scott CWO wrote on mark-hunter's profile.
Hi Mark. My email is [redacted]
Selling real estate in dchum’s head
 
Top