Gunbroker Merkel double 416 Rigby, Good deal or Possible Scam?

Noah Hutchens

Silver supporter
AH veteran
Joined
Nov 20, 2025
Messages
205
Reaction score
268
Media
17
Hunting reports
Africa
1
I’ve been looking at buying a dangerous game caliber double for a while and saw this one pop up on gunbroker. Seller only has 1 review and it was as a Buyer not a seller. Looks questionable to me, title and listing also seems weird to me but I don’t really know what I’m looking at. Figure I should pass on bidding on an abundance of caution, thoughts?

 
Also want to mention my budget is fairly limited when it comes to a double so this appeals even more, but again, seems fishy to me.
 
Only one review as a buyer. No other listings. No info other than manufacturer specs. Smells like a scam to me. Your gut already told you.
 

Same budget, known seller.
 
I would pass on the Merkel.
 
I’ve been looking at buying a dangerous game caliber double for a while and saw this one pop up on gunbroker. Seller only has 1 review and it was as a Buyer not a seller. Looks questionable to me, title and listing also seems weird to me but I don’t really know what I’m looking at. Figure I should pass on bidding on an abundance of caution, thoughts?

If you do not see the verified seller logo on top of the sellers name do not even think of touching this
 
PM sent.
 
I’ve been looking at buying a dangerous game caliber double for a while and saw this one pop up on gunbroker. Seller only has 1 review and it was as a Buyer not a seller. Looks questionable to me, title and listing also seems weird to me but I don’t really know what I’m looking at. Figure I should pass on bidding on an abundance of caution, thoughts?

Contact the seller…if his name is Chuck…I bet you are good to go. You can ask if his name is Chuck and does he know Will. Or if you decided you were really interested in the rifle, I can give you Chuck’s phone number. He has a 416 Merkel that he is helping a longtime friend sell, that looks like the gun, and Chuck lives in Wasilla. A friend of mine and fellow forum member was going to buy it and they had a deal worked out, but Chuck was told it was an ejector gun, something on my buds mandatory list, but when the rifle made it to Chuck and he looked it over in hand, he let us know it had extractors. So the deal was undone. The starting bid is south of their deal too.

I was sad since Chuck was going to drive it down here to Soldotna so I run test it out and try a few Rigby loads through it before mailing it south. AND….Chuck was going to bring his vintage 577 down with so I could try it out. We were going to have a play day of sorts, he wanted to shoot my Heym and Westley Richards 450/400’s.

I have to believe this is the same rifle. And Chuck is a hellova nice guy, longtime member of Wild Sheep up here in Alaska and now more medically semi-retired I believe. We met and had a long conversation at the Wilds Sheep banquet as we were both dumping tickets into the Heym Martini 404J raffle. Splendid conversation with him and his daughter and then into doubles, and so on. We’ve corresponded regularly since. We don’t have just dozens and dozens of double fanatics here in the state, so when you meet one, you take note. Most seem to know each other.

Anyway, cheers and good luck with your search. While you may decide a Merkel isn’t want you are looking for, I wouldn’t just skip this rifle because it looks scammy….we can help you sort that part.
 
This look like the gun? Gent in the photo isn’t Chuck, it’s his buddy who is the original owner.
IMG_1249.jpeg
IMG_1242.jpeg
 
Contact the seller…if his name is Chuck…I bet you are good to go. You can ask if his name is Chuck and does he know Will. Or if you decided you were really interested in the rifle, I can give you Chuck’s phone number. He has a 416 Merkel that he is helping a longtime friend sell, that looks like the gun, and Chuck lives in Wasilla. A friend of mine and fellow forum member was going to buy it and they had a deal worked out, but Chuck was told it was an ejector gun, something on my buds mandatory list, but when the rifle made it to Chuck and he looked it over in hand, he let us know it had extractors. So the deal was undone. The starting bid is south of their deal too.

I was sad since Chuck was going to drive it down here to Soldotna so I run test it out and try a few Rigby loads through it before mailing it south. AND….Chuck was going to bring his vintage 577 down with so I could try it out. We were going to have a play day of sorts, he wanted to shoot my Heym and Westley Richards 450/400’s.

I have to believe this is the same rifle. And Chuck is a hellova nice guy, longtime member of Wild Sheep up here in Alaska and now more medically semi-retired I believe. We met and had a long conversation at the Wilds Sheep banquet as we were both dumping tickets into the Heym Martini 404J raffle. Splendid conversation with him and his daughter and then into doubles, and so on. We’ve corresponded regularly since. We don’t have just dozens and dozens of double fanatics here in the state, so when you meet one, you take note. Most seem to know each other.

Anyway, cheers and good luck with your search. While you may decide a Merkel isn’t want you are looking for, I wouldn’t just skip this rifle because it looks scammy….we can help you sort that part.
I messaged him and his name is in fact Chuck.
 
Yepper, I figured it had to be so. Chuck is a hellova nice gent. If you ever talk to him on the phone, have some patience as he has some medical complications that affects his speech and movements. He’s great to chat with, just can take some additional time.

I don’t think you have anything to worry about in the scam/ripoff department. As soon as we discovered it was an extractor gun which my other bud really only wanted an ejector model, Chuck tore up the check and sent photos of it. He seems a solid gent all the way around.

Good luck and enjoy your double search.
 
Contact the seller…if his name is Chuck…I bet you are good to go. You can ask if his name is Chuck and does he know Will. Or if you decided you were really interested in the rifle, I can give you Chuck’s phone number. He has a 416 Merkel that he is helping a longtime friend sell, that looks like the gun, and Chuck lives in Wasilla. A friend of mine and fellow forum member was going to buy it and they had a deal worked out, but Chuck was told it was an ejector gun, something on my buds mandatory list, but when the rifle made it to Chuck and he looked it over in hand, he let us know it had extractors. So the deal was undone. The starting bid is south of their deal too.

I was sad since Chuck was going to drive it down here to Soldotna so I run test it out and try a few Rigby loads through it before mailing it south. AND….Chuck was going to bring his vintage 577 down with so I could try it out. We were going to have a play day of sorts, he wanted to shoot my Heym and Westley Richards 450/400’s.

I have to believe this is the same rifle. And Chuck is a hellova nice guy, longtime member of Wild Sheep up here in Alaska and now more medically semi-retired I believe. We met and had a long conversation at the Wilds Sheep banquet as we were both dumping tickets into the Heym Martini 404J raffle. Splendid conversation with him and his daughter and then into doubles, and so on. We’ve corresponded regularly since. We don’t have just dozens and dozens of double fanatics here in the state, so when you meet one, you take note. Most seem to know each other.

Anyway, cheers and good luck with your search. While you may decide a Merkel isn’t want you are looking for, I wouldn’t just skip this rifle because it looks scammy….we can help you sort that part.
Nice validation and great recommendation!
 
Even as an extractor, that is a very fair price.

FYI My krieghoff 500/416 is an extractor gun but with practice you can reload very quickly.
 
Yepper, I figured it had to be so. Chuck is a hellova nice gent. If you ever talk to him on the phone, have some patience as he has some medical complications that affects his speech and movements. He’s great to chat with, just can take some additional time.

I don’t think you have anything to worry about in the scam/ripoff department. As soon as we discovered it was an extractor gun which my other bud really only wanted an ejector model, Chuck tore up the check and sent photos of it. He seems a solid gent all the way around.

Good luck and enjoy your double search.
Thank you for all your information, Ive messaged with him a little and am going to have a call with him tomorrow about the rifle.
 
Yepper, I figured it had to be so. Chuck is a hellova nice gent. If you ever talk to him on the phone, have some patience as he has some medical complications that affects his speech and movements. He’s great to chat with, just can take some additional time.

I don’t think you have anything to worry about in the scam/ripoff department. As soon as we discovered it was an extractor gun which my other bud really only wanted an ejector model, Chuck tore up the check and sent photos of it. He seems a solid gent all the way around.

Good luck and enjoy your double search.
I just talked to him today for over 30 minutes and we agreed on a price and I am mailing a check this week. I have total confidence in the deal as he repeated your posted information almost verbatim when I inquired about the rifles history. He said the fellow he is selling it for took it to Africa and took a Bull elephant among others. He also sent me photos of the rifle in hand and other closeups I asked for.
 
Safe to say I now need to sell a few other rifles to offset the cost to save my self from the bosses(wife) wrath….
 

Forum statistics

Threads
68,993
Messages
1,537,190
Members
159,092
Latest member
VernonDown
 

 

 
 
Top