This is a discussion on Judging Eland within the Hunting Africa forums, part of the Hunting Forums - Hunting in Africa category; I going to try to finish my spiral horn collection in May 2009 in the Limpopo Province. How long of ...
04-28-2009, 07:37 PM #1
I going to try to finish my spiral horn collection in May 2009 in the Limpopo Province. How long of horns and how big of bases should I be looking for in the Cape Eland. I saw very few in Namibia last year and I know the females have long skinny horns.
I would like a thick based Eland with like 2 twists...long would be great...but I would just like to get one that has nice thick bases with twists.
Guys and Gals...please give me some advice.
04-28-2009, 11:41 PM #2
Eland is one of those animals that you take for the hunt and not just the trophy although you may end up with a very good trophy with older bulls it will not be the case. The reason for that is that eland use their horns on a constant basis and with that comes wear. The older they get the less hair they have on their bodies as well and get known as blue bulls. These are the ones that make impressive trophies irrespective of horn size just of their size and look.
Hunting eland in Limpopo in proper mopane veldt is one of the most challenging hunts you can have done on foot. They move like nomads and you will usually pick up tracks from a waterhole or salt lick and start from there. Enjoy
Before I forget thickness of the horns looks better to me than thin long ones.Frederik Cocquyt, Outfitter and Professional Hunter
Cell: +27 83 709 8927
04-29-2009, 12:14 AM #3
- Member of SCI, Ducks Unlimited
- Hunted Namibia
- derekwest has no Articles
- View derekwest's Photos
I've only taken one eland and in no way am an expert in the subject and would defer trophy size to the experts here but can tell you that although my eland will not break any records, the hunt, stalk and character of the eland makes it a true trophy to me.
The stalk was epic with the last 200 yards being closed on our hands & knees to pop up and nail him within 150 yards. The eland was the heard bull and had a great brown brush with well worn horns, plenty of battle scars and a blue/grey hide. There are a lot of bigger/younger bulls out there but I wouldn't trade mine for an SCI scoring bull. Take a look here and good luck on your hunt and good shooting. Eland picture has been uploaded here My Eland...thanks again Jerome! - Hunting Videos, Bowhunting Videos, Fishing Videos
04-29-2009, 12:48 AM #4
You're spot on and you have a very good eland there.Frederik Cocquyt, Outfitter and Professional Hunter
Cell: +27 83 709 8927
04-29-2009, 09:27 AM #5
That is beautiful Eland bull Derekwest. I agree I wouldn't trade him for anything. Nice color and facial hair look really great. Sounds like I will have a hard hunt in the Limpopo. Interesting!
04-29-2009, 01:41 PM #6
Very nice bull!!Skyline Adventures
04-30-2009, 12:57 PM #7
- Member of SCI Internatiol chapter; NAPHA.
- Andries has no Articles
- View Andries's Photos
A good eland trophy is in my opinion more in the cape than the horns. If you see a bull with a big dewlap and a good brush on it's forehead, you know you got a good trophy. Eland hunting are nearly always a bit physical and a lot of fun. Not all bulls get that blue colour on their shoulders.
Not that I know any PH or client that will let that 40" bull go because there are no brush !!!
enysse, glad you asked the question as I too have Eland on my list. I love this series of posts on judging Oryx, Kudu and Buffalo. Once again thanks to all for the great information, I wonder if Jerome is working on another one of his uber posts for the Eland as well (hint, hint)?
derekwest, nice "rug" on that Eland (sorry I know it's called brush, it just looks like a toupe)! That is a big beautiful beast.
05-07-2009, 02:58 PM #9
- Member of NRA, SCI, TWA
- Hunted Tanzania, Zimbabwe
- drclader has no Articles
- drclader has no Photos
Blue color, heavy brush (or rug!), and ivory tips on heavy horns.The old boys also look heavier and stockier than their younger mates.
05-14-2009, 07:17 PM #10
The Eland is the largest species of antelope in Africa and one of its' most sought after spiral horned trophies. Additionally these immense animals are often hard earned trophies for sport hunters which makes it that much more close to the heart of many who have hunted them.
For the sake of this post I am referring to Common Eland, but the criteria here applies equally well to the subspecies that fall under the category of Common Eland which are Cape Eland, Livingstone Eland and East African Eland.
When discussing Eland horn measurement here, I refer to horn length for a Eland in it's simplest form which is taking the measurement of the longest horn from the base along the top of the spiral ridge to the tip only. This, of course, is a basic method but for a primer on How To Measure Your Trophies you can read AfricaHunting.com article by clicking here.
I should start by saying that being able to consistently and accurately judge Eland trophy size and quality can be more challenging than one might first imagine and the most reliable way to get the trophy that you are seeking is to heed the advice of your Professional Hunter.
While judging Eland, body appearance plays a big role and is the easiest way to rapidly assess at first glance the maturity of a possible trophy bull. Body appearance is integral in assessing a Eland's maturity and a few characteristics are to be considered.
Weighing nearly twice as much as a female, mature bulls will really stand out in comparison due to their large, muscular and massive looking bodies. Female Eland have smaller bodies and much slimmer necks. Mature males also have a much larger and prominent dewlap on their throat. Females wear a tannish color coat while older mature males have a darker tan coat with a blueish gray tinge to it and even sometimes have areas of hair loss (this is normal).
01. Here is an example of a fully matured Eland bull with a
massive body, thick neck, large dewlap, blueish gray coat and
dense forehead brush.
02. Clearly distinguishable from a bull is the mature
Eland female with a smaller body, slender neck, petite dewlap
and tan coat.
In bachelor herds, among other grown males, a mature bull will stand out by body mass and darker coat color. These are the same factors that make them stand out among females but they will be harder to discern as the differences will be less noticeable among other males.
03. Here is a grown Eland bull without any of those strong
characteristics of maturity in his body yet.
The most significant factor to look at to differentiate between Eland bulls is their neck girth, as they mature their necks get "fatter" growing so large over time that they bulge out on either side of the neck.
04. Here is an example of an old Eland bull with a thick and
Another distinctive characteristic which can be seen only on some older males is the presence of a very distinctive brush or 'rug' of hair on their foreheads. The brush is most often brown varying in color from very dark to reddish and can be very thick and prominent to almost non-existent. One thing is clear if a Eland has a heavy brush it is a reliable sign of maturity but lack of one does not mean it is not mature.
05. Here is an example of an old bull with a very dark brown
06. Here is an example of a spectacular bull with no apparent
A great indicator of a very old Eland bull is a massive body with bulging neck and horns that appear proportionately small on the body (this does not mean that the horns are actually small). This visual effect only occurs when the bull reaches it's maximum body size and the horns are well worn down. This can be used as a guide even when a Eland bull is observed standing alone.
07. Here is an example of giant body size dwarfing horn size
perception and of course a "fat" bulging neck.
I call this look "Eland on steroids".
Now that we have dealt with the body aspect of judging the Eland maturity we can begin to discuss the horn criteria.
Eland bulls usually carry well matched symmetrical spiral horns with prominent visible raised and steady ridges along the two twists. The spread of the horns can vary greatly, from a narrow almost parallel look to a "V" shape. Most often, mature bulls have considerably thicker bases, more massive and straighter horns compared to female horns that are significantly thinner with less apparent ridges and a tendency to become crooked the older they get. Although female Eland horns can appear longer they are usually not hunted for their horns.
Using Rowland Ward Methods Of Measurement for spiral-horned antelopes (Method 8) does require taking the spread measurement from horn to horn into account. However, using Safari Club International Methods Of Measurement for spiral-horned animals (Method 2) does NOT require taking the spread measurement into account.
Judging Eland horn size simply based on the visual appearance of the length of the horns can be quite misleading. There are three factors that need to be taken into account in judging the horns of the Eland. A combination of thickness, prominent ridges and length are the key to an amazing trophy.
Probably the first thing that hunters are conditioned to notice and look at is the straight out length of the horns but this is a mistake. A longer thinner horn can measure significantly less than a shorter thick horn.
08. Here is a terrific example of how deceptive just looking
at straight up horn length can be and how much measurement
you can gain in the thickness of the horns and prominent ridges.
Using the Eland face as a guide you can clearly see that the
straight up horn length of the Eland taken by bow appears
quite a bit longer, however the Eland in the top picture is
actually 8 inches longer not taking into account the
measurement of the base.
Eland in top picture measures an impressive
right horn 42 inch (106 cm) - right base 12 3/4 inch (32.5 cm)
Record book #3 in Namibia when taken
Eland in bottom picture measures
right horn 34 inch (86.5 cm) - right base no measurement
Actually the first thing that should be looked at and evaluated is the thickness of the entire horn starting at the base and maintaining girth from the base up into the horn itself. Looking at the bases alone is not enough, because where you will gain in the horn measurement is the continued thickness. If the horn tapers quickly upward from the base it will loose several inches and not score as high as thickness throughout.
09. Here is two examples of horns that are clearly thick through
the length and both will score well however the top Eland
with the more prominent ridges will score a lot higher.
Now we can began to look at the importance of the prominence of the protruding ridges along the twists. How much these ridges protrude will make a big difference in the measurement of the horns, often adding several inches for a trophy with prominent ridges. In my opinion, this factor along with the girth of the horn is where most really impressive Eland trophies are made, add to that some length and you've got an exceptional trophy. Ridges however can sometimes be difficult to see at long distances which is often the case when hunting Eland, so depending upon the circumstances it may be challenging to use this as a criteria.
10. Here is an example of prominent protruding ridges along
the twists of the horn. The mass of the horn itself is quite
average on this Eland, however the extreme protrusion of
the ridges and the above average length give this eland
right horn 38 1/2 inch (98 cm) - right base 11 1/3 inch (29 cm)
Usually if the tips of the horns are still very sharp, the Eland is either still growing or is just in its' prime. When Eland bulls horns are past their prime they tend to loose length and their horns, on the way down, will often appear much thicker at the top as their tips wear down even appearing somewhat blunt with advanced age.
In terms of trophy size when it comes to mature Eland bulls, an exceptional trophy is 40 inch plus (101.6 cm). I would say that horns above 37 inches (94 cm) make for an amazing trophy, horns above 34 inches (86.36 cm) make for a great trophy, horns above 30 inches (76.2 cm) make for a good trophy and horns below that make for a beautiful trophy and great memories!
On a personal note an amazing Eland trophy isn't about horn length for me at all, but it's in the character of an old Eland Bull. The Eland is special in that as it ages, it transforms physically as a few other species do to show qualities of age that I find desirable in an exceptional trophy. I would much prefer an old "blue" bull, with thick brush, gigantic bulging neck and seriously worn down thick horns than one that scores well. It's just personal preference.
11. Here is what I'm talking about, beautiful!
All of these Cape Eland trophy photos came from my place in Namibia, Ozondjahe Hunting Safaris, I included numbers for each picture if anyone wanted to comment or refer to an image...
Note that trophy size can differ from region to region and what may easily be found in one area may be unexpectedly large in another. As with most animals there is always localities where the bigger trophies tend to be found.
05-14-2009, 11:27 PM #11
- Member of SCI
- Hunted Namibia
- safari hunter has no Articles
- View safari hunter's Photos
From now on, will look at an Eland bull a bit differently thanks!
05-15-2009, 04:36 AM #12
- Hunted South Africa, Namibia, USA
- huntatafrica has no Articles
- huntatafrica has no Photos
Greate post Jerome, I fully aggree with you that when it come's to Eland, a good cape is musch more importend than the hornes itself.
Have a look at 2 Eland Bulls hunted in one Safaris @ Photos - HennieVHennie Viljoen
Professional Hunter and Tour Guide
Permit nr: CPM-005-00122 & LP0918
05-30-2009, 11:41 PM #14
I took a old bull down in the East Cape. I feel lucky and privileged to have gotten one that has 30 inch horns, gray colored and covered in ticks. Yes, his companions were a lot longer...but they had no dewlap.
They are a devil to hunt in the bushveld. Better be in excellent shape, be able to glass well, and shoot fast.
Hopefully, I'll get a chance to hunt another one day!
06-01-2009, 11:07 PM #15
- Member of SCI, Ducks Unlimited
- Hunted Namibia
- derekwest has no Articles
- View derekwest's Photos
Congratulations! I just got mine back from Tru-Life Taxidermy and up on my wall. If you are like me, you will count the days until you either get your trophy or get the chance to hunt them again!
Post pictures when you get a chance, I a big fan of the big blue beasts!
05-10-2011, 10:58 AM #16
I hope people add eland pictures and memories to this thread.
05-10-2011, 12:02 PM #17
- Member of BBFT Mexico,SCI New Monterrey Chapter,IHEA
- Hunted Zimbabwe, USA, Mexico , Central America, Kyrgysztan, Scotland
- davidarizpe has no Articles
- View davidarizpe's Photos
Here is one from Zimbabwe
NEW SCI CHAPTER MONTERREY MEXICO
05-10-2011, 12:07 PM #18
He's a nice one, has a great ruff of hair on his forehead!
05-10-2011, 06:23 PM #19
- Member of SCI
- Hunted Canada (AB, SK, NWT, BC) USA (NM) South Africa (Limpopo, KZN, Free State, Eastern Cape, Northen Cape), Kyrgyzstan
- Diamondhitch has no Articles
- View Diamondhitch's Photos
Althougth I am normally a horn hunter I have to say that without a good hairdo an eland just isnt the same. I personally would not want to shoot one without, regardless of size (I have been known to change my opinion at the last minute though LOL)The journey is the reward.
05-10-2011, 08:25 PM #20
David, that is what I will be looking for in June! Verrrrrry nice.
By Conservation Force in forum Hunting AfricaReplies: 1Last Post: 09-23-2011, 12:04 PM
By Dox in forum Hunting AfricaReplies: 3Last Post: 09-10-2011, 10:59 AM
By TERMINATOR in forum Hunting AfricaReplies: 8Last Post: 06-12-2011, 07:44 PM
By Calhoun in forum Hunting AfricaReplies: 25Last Post: 05-14-2011, 12:53 AM
By safari-lawyer in forum Hunting AfricaReplies: 14Last Post: 03-23-2011, 04:12 AM